Abstract
In the early 2000s, the development of local food systems in advanced industrial countries has expanded beyond creation and support of farmers’ markets and community supported agriculture farms and projects to include targeted Buy Local Food campaigns. Non-governmental groups in many U.S. places and regions have launched such campaigns with the intent of motivating and directing consumers toward more local food purchasing in general. This article examines the current manifestations and possibilities for social justice concerns in Buy Local Food campaigns, by considering them within the more general category of “selective patronage“ campaigns. Historical campaign examples, such as Buy Union, Buy American, and Buy Black campaigns, offer instructive comparisons to contemporary consumer campaigns promoting local food. Through examining the construction of threats, intended beneficiaries, products to be avoided, and those to be preferentially selected, the paper demonstrates how selective patronage campaigns have emphasized social justice needs and concerns for designated groups in ways that have been potentially exclusionary of other disadvantaged groups and thus undermining of social justice more broadly. As a contemporary instance of “selective patronage,“ Buy Local Food campaigns exhibit similar contradictory impulses, which are intensified by the conceptual and practical pitfalls in designating “local.“ The article concludes by considering how the challenges and prospects for commitments to social justice in local food consumer campaigns reinforce the importance of emerging initiatives centered on domestic fair trade.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allen P. (1993). Connecting the Social and the Ecological in Sustainable Agriculture. In P. Allen (Ed.), Food for the Future: Conditions and Contradictions of Sustainability (pp. 1–16). New York: Wiley
Allen P. (1999). Reweaving the Food Security Safety Net: Mediating Entitlement and Entrepreneurship. Agriculture and Human Values, 16, 117–129
Allen P. (2004). Together at the Table: Sustainability and Sustenance in the American Agrifood System. University Park, PA: Penn State University Press
Allen P., M. FitzSimmons, M. Goodman, K. Warner (2003). Shifting Plates in the Agrifood Landscape: The Tectonics of Alternative Agrifood Initiatives in California. Journal of Rural Studies 19, 61–75
Allen P., J. Guthman, A. W. Morris (2006). Meeting Farm and Food Security Needs Through Community Supported Agriculture and Farmers’ Markets in California. Santa Cruz, CA: Center for Agroecology and Sustainable Food Systems. Center Research Brief #9
Allen P., C. Hinrichs (2007). Buying Into ‹Buy Local’: Engagements of United States Local Food Initiatives. In D. Maye, L. Holloway, M. Kneafsey (Eds.), Constructing “Alternative” Food Geographies: Representation and Practice (pp. 255–272). Oxford: Elsevier
Allen P., M. Kovach (2000). The Capitalist Composition of Organic: The Potential of Markets in Fulfilling the Promise of Sustainable Agriculture. Agriculture and Human Values 17, 221–232
Barnett C., P. Cloke, N. Clarke, A. Malpass (2005). Consuming Ethics: Articulating the Subjects and Spaces of Ethical Consumption. Antipode, 37, 23–45
Bates T. M. (1993). Banking on Black Enterprise: Potential of Emerging Firms for Revitalizing Urban Economies. Washington, DC: Joint Center for Economic and Political Studies
Bellows A. C., M. W. Hamm (2001). Local Autonomy and Sustainable Development: Testing Import Substitution in Localizing Food Systems. Agriculture and Human Values 18, 271–284
Bird M. M., J. W. Robinson (1972). The Effectiveness of the Union Label and ‹Buy Union’ Campaigns. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 25, 512–552
Born B., M. Purcell (2006). Avoiding the Local Trap: Scale and Food Systems in Planning Research. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 26, 195–207
Boyd R. L. (1990). Black and Asian Self-Employment in Large Metropolitan Areas: A Comparative Analysis. Social Problems, 37, 258–274
Buck D., C. Getz, J. Guthman (1997). From Farm to Table: The Organic Vegetable Commodity Chain of Northern California. Sociologia Ruralis, 37, 4–20
CISA (Community Involved in Sustainable Agriculture) (n.d.), CISA’s Local Hero Campaign. Retrieved December 5, 2005, from http://www.buylocalfood.com/LOCAL%20Hero.htm
Cohen E. (2003). A Consumers’ Republic: The Politics of Mass Consumption in Postwar America. New York: Knopf
Cohen M., A. Comrov, and B. Hoffner, “The New Politics of Consumption: Promoting Sustainability in the American Marketplace.“ Sustainability: Science, Practice and Policy, 1 (2005), 58–76. Retrieved April 14, 2007, from http://ejournal/ nbii/org
Dobson A. (2003). Social Justice and Environmental Sustainability: Ne’er The Twain Shall Meet? In J. Agyeman, R. D. Bullard, B. Evans (Eds.), Just Sustainabilities: Development in an Unequal World (pp. 83–98). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
Domestic Fair Trade Working Group, (2005) Principles for Domestic Fair Trade: For Health, Justice and Sustainability. Retrieved May 24, 2007 from http://www.equalexchange.com/dftfiles/dftprinciplesflyer.pdf
DuPuis E. M., D. Goodman (2005). Should We Go “Home“ to Eat? Toward a Reflexive Politics of Localism. Journal of Rural Studies, 21, 359–371
Fainstein S. (2001). Competitiveness, Cohesion and Governance: Their Implications for Social Justice. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 25, 884–888
Feenstra G. W. (1997). Local Food Systems and Sustainable Communities. American Journal of Alternative Agriculture, 12, 28–36
Fink D. (1998). Cutting Into the Meatpacking Line: Workers and Change in the Rural Midwest. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press
Frank D. (1999). Buy American: The Untold Story of Economic Nationalism. Boston: Beacon
Frank D. (2003). Where are the Workers in Consumer-Worker Alliances? Class Dynamics and the History of Consumer-Labor Campaigns. Politics and Society, 31, 363–379
Friedland W. H., A. E. Barton, R. J. Thomas (1981). Manufacturing Green Gold: Capital, Labor and Technology in the Lettuce Industry. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Friedman M. (1996). A Positive Approach to Organized Consumer Action: The ‹Buycott’ as an Alternative to the Boycott. Journal of Consumer Policy, 19, 439–451
Gibson D. P. (1978). $70 Billion in the Black: American’s Black Consumers. New York: Macmillan
Granzin K. L., J. E. Olsen, (1999). Americans’ Choice of Domestic Over Foreign Products: A Matter of Helping Behavior? Journal of Business Research, 43, 39–54
Greenberg C. (2004). Political Consumer Action: Some Cautionary Notes from African American History. In M. Micheletti, A. Follesdal, D. Stolle (Eds.), Politics, Products and Markets: Exploring Political Consumerism Past and Present (pp. 63–82). Piscataway, NJ: Transaction Publishers
Guthman J. (2000). Raising Organic: An Agro-ecological Assessment of Grower Practices in California. Agriculture and Human Values, 17, 257–266
Guthman J. (2007). The Polanyian Way? Voluntary Food Labels as Neoliberal Governance. Antipode, 39, 456–478
Harvey D. (1992). Social Justice, Postmodernism and the City. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 16, 588–601
Hinrichs C. C. (2000). Embeddedness and Local Food Systems: Notes on Two Types of Direct Agricultural Markets. Journal of Rural Studies, 16, 295–303
Hinrichs C. C. (2003). The Practice and Politics of Food System Localization. Journal of Rural Studies, 19, 33–45
Hinrichs C., K. S. Kremer (2002). Social Inclusion in a Midwest Local Food System Project. Journal of Poverty, 6, 65–90
Howard P. H., P. Allen (2006). Beyond Organic: Consumer Interest in New Labeling Schemes in the Central Coast of California. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 30, 439–451
Jaffee D., J. R. Kloppenburg, M. B. Monroy (2004). Bringing the ‹Moral Charge’ Home: Fair Trade Within the North and Within the South. Rural Sociology, 69, 169–196
Johnston J., L. Baker (2005). Eating Outside the Box: FoodShare’s Good Food Box and the Challenge of Scale. Agriculture and Human Values, 22, 313–325
Kloppenburg J., J. Hendrickson, G. W. Stevenson (1996). Coming in to the Foodshed. Agriculture and Human Values, 13, 33–42
Maniates M. (2002). Individualization: Plant a Tree, Buy a Bike, Save the World? In T. Princen, M. Maniates, K. Conca (Eds.), Confronting Consumption (pp. 43–65). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
Micheletti M. (2003). Political Virtue and Shopping: Individuals, Consumerism, and Collective Action. New York: Palgrave Macmillan
Micheletti M., A. Follesdal, D. Stolle (2004). Introduction. In M. Micheletti, A. Follesdal, D. Stolle (Eds.), Politics, Products and Markets: Exploring Political Consumerism Past and Present (pp. ix–xxvi). Piscataway, NJ: Transaction Publishers
Miele M. (2005). Consumption Culture: The Case of Food. In P. J. Cloke, T. Marsden, P. Mooney (Eds.), Handbook of Rural Studies (pp. 344–354). London: Sage
Miller D. (2001). Principles of Social Justice. Cambridge: Harvard University Press
Mooney P., T. Majka (1995). Farmers’ and Farm Workers’ Movements: Social Protest in American Agriculture. New York: Twayne
O’Connor J. (1998). Natural Causes: Essays in Ecological Marxism. New York: Guilford
Perez J., P. Allen (2007). Farming the College Market: Results of a Consumer Study at UC Santa Cruz. Santa Cruz, CA: Center for Agroecology and Sustainable Food Systems. Center Research Brief #11
Schreck A., C. Getz, G. Feenstra (2006). Social Sustainability, Farm Labor and Organic Agriculture: Findings from an Exploratory Analysis. Agriculture and Human Values, 23, 439–449
Sewell S. K. (2004). The ‹Not-Buying Power’ of the Black Community: Urban Boycotts and Equal Employment Opportunity, 1960–1964. Journal of African American History, 89, 135–149
Smith D. M. (1998). How Far Should We Care? On the Spatial Scope of Beneficence. Progress in Human Geography, 22, 15–38
Smith D. M. (2000). Social Justice Revisited. Environment and Planning A, 32, 1149–1162
Stull D. D., M. J. Broadway, D. Griffith (1995). Any Way You Cut it: Meat Processing and Small Town America. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas
Villarejo, D. “FIVE Cents for Fairness: The UFW Strawberry Campaign Goes Public.“ Rural California Report (California Institute for Rural Studies, Davis, CA, 1997). Retrieved May 23, 2007 from http://www.cirsinc.org/rcr/ufw.html
Weems R. E. (2002). The End of Black Nationalism? Declining African–American Support for Black-Owned Businesses. In J. L. Conyers (Ed.), Black Culture and Race Relations (pp. 142–153). Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield
Wells M. J. (1996). Strawberry Fields: Politics, Class and Work in California Agriculture. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press
Wiedenhoft W. A. (2006). Consumer Tactics as ‹Weapons’: Black Lists, Union Labels and the American Federation of Labor. Journal of Consumer Culture, 6, 261–285
Young I. M. (1990). Justice and the Politics of Difference. Princeton: Princeton University Press
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hinrichs, C.C., Allen, P. Selective Patronage and Social Justice: Local Food Consumer Campaigns in Historical Context. J Agric Environ Ethics 21, 329–352 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-008-9089-6
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-008-9089-6