Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-c47g7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-23T19:30:32.662Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Family tombs and tomb cult in ancient Athens: tradition or traditionalism?*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 October 2013

S. C. Humphreys
Affiliation:
University College London

Extract

Fustel de Coulanges' thesis that ancient society was founded upon the cult of ancestral tombs has had, for a thoroughly self-contradictory argument, a remarkably successful career. Neither Fustel himself nor the many subsequent scholars who have quoted his views with approval faced clearly the difficulty of deriving a social structure dominated by corporate descent groups from the veneration of tombs placed in individually owned landed property. On the whole, historians have tended to play down Fustel's insistence on the relation between ancestor-cult and property and to exaggerate the role of the corporate kin group. This tendency, which assimilates Fustel to Sir Henry Maine and other lawyers interested in the reconstruction of Indo-European institutions (e.g. Bonfante) has in my view considerably impeded understanding of the role of kinship in early Greek society; it also obscures one of the most individual aspects of Fustel's work which, thanks to the researches of Philippe Ariès (II) on the development of the modern tomb-cult in the nineteenth century, can now be placed in its historical context.

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Society for the Promotion of Hellenic Studies 1980

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Ahlberg, (G.): Prothesis and ekphora in Greek Geometric art, Stud. in Medit. Arch. xxxii (Göteborg 1971).Google Scholar
Alexandres, (O.) I: ‘Peribolos oikogeneiakon taphon para ten hodon pros Akademeian’, AAA ii (1969) 257–66.Google Scholar
Alexandres, (O.) II: ‘3e ephoreia klass. arch. Ath.’, ADelt. xxv (1970) 4091.Google Scholar
Alexandres, (O.) III: ‘3e ephoreia klass. arch. Ath.’, ADelt. xxvii (1972) 22146.Google Scholar
Alexiou, (M.): The ritual lament in Greek tradition (Cambridge 1974).Google Scholar
Amandry, (P.): ‘Chronique des fouilles et découvertes archéologiques en Grèce en 1948’, BCH lxxiii (1949) 516–36.Google Scholar
Andreiomenou, (A.K.): ‘Anaskaphai eis Athenas kai Attiken’, ADelt. xvii (1961/1962) 3643.Google Scholar
Andronikos, (M.): Totenkult, Archaeologia Homerica iii W (Göttingen 1968).Google Scholar
Ariès, (P.) I: L'enfant et la vie familiale sous l'ancien régime (Paris 1960) (trans. Centuries of Childhood [London 1962]).Google Scholar
Ariès, (P.) II: L'homme devant la mort (Paris 1977).Google Scholar
Asgari, (N.)Firali, (N.) ‘Die Nekropole von Kalchedon’, in Stud. zur Religion u. Kultur Kleinasiens. Festschr. F. K. Dörner (Leiden 1978) 192.Google Scholar
Bakalakis, (G.): ‘Die Lutrophoros Athen (ex Schliemann)—Berlin 3209’, AK xiv (1971) 7483.Google Scholar
Beazley, (J.D.) I: Attic Black-figure Vase Painters (Oxford 1956).Google Scholar
Beazley, (J.D.) II: Attic Red-figure Vase Painters 2 (Oxford 1963).Google Scholar
Bérard, (C.): Eretria. Fouilles et recherches iii. L'héroon à la porte de l'ouest (Berne 1970).Google Scholar
Bingen, (J.) I: ‘L'établissement du IXe siècle et les nécropoles du secteur ouest’, Thorikos 1966/7 (Brussels 1967) 2546.Google Scholar
Bingen, (J.) II: ‘L'établissement géometrique et la necropole ouest’, Thorikos 1965 3156.Google Scholar
Bingen, (J.) III: ‘La nécropole ouest 4’, Thorikos 1963 5986.Google Scholar
Boardman, (J.M.) I: ‘Painted funerary plaques and some remarks on prothesis’, BSA l (1955) 5166.Google Scholar
Boardman, (J.M.) II: Greek Sculpture: the Archaic Period (London 1978).Google Scholar
Boehlau, (J.)Schefold, (K.): Larisa am Hermos i (Berlin 1940Google Scholar
Bourriot, (F.): Recherches sur la nature du génos: étude d'histoire sociale athénienne, périodes archaïque et classique (Paris 1975).Google Scholar
Bradeen, (D.W.) I: ‘The Athenian casualty lists’, CQ xix (1969) 145–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bradeen, (D.W.) II: The Athenian Agora xvii. Inscriptions. The funerary monuments (Princeton 1974).Google Scholar
Browne, (Sir T.): Hydrotaphia, Urne Buriall (London 1658).Google Scholar
Bruckner, (A.)Pernice, (E.): ‘Ein attischer Friedhof’, Ath. Mitt. xviii (1893) 73191.Google Scholar
Buck, (C.D.): The Greek dialects (Chicago 1955).Google Scholar
Charitonides, (S.I.) I: ‘Anaskaphe klassikon taphon para ten plateian Syntagmatos’, AE 1958 1152.Google Scholar
Charitonides, (S.I.) II: ‘The first half of a bouleutic list of the fourth century B.C.’, Hesp. xxx (1961) 3057.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chateaubriand(F.R., Viscomte de) (F.R., Viscomte de) I: Le génie du Christianisme (Paris 1802).Google Scholar
Chateaubriand(F.R., Viscomte de) (F.R., Viscomte de) II: Mémoires d'outre-tombe i (Paris 1948, first publ. 1850).Google Scholar
Chrestos, (Ch.): ‘Spartiatikoi archaikoi taphoi’, ADelt. xix A (1964) 123–63.Google Scholar
Clairmont, (C.): Gravestone and Epigram (Mainz 1970).Google Scholar
Clarysse, (W.): ‘Note on the new temenos stele of King Antiochos I’, ZPE xxiii (1976) 264.Google Scholar
Coldstream, (J.N.) I: Greek Geometric Pottery (London 1968).Google Scholar
Coldstream, (J.N.) II: ‘Hero-cults in the age of Homer’, JHS xcvi (1976) 817.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coldstream, (J.N.) III: Geometric Greece (London 1977).Google Scholar
Conze, (A.): Die Attischen Grabreliefs (Berlin 18931922).Google Scholar
Couchoud, (P.-L.): ‘L'interprétation des stèles funéraires attiques’, RA xviii (1923) 99118, 233–60.Google Scholar
Dareste, (R.), Haussoullier, (B.), Reinach, (Th.): Recueil des inscriptions juridiques (Paris 1898).Google Scholar
Daux, (G.): ‘Sur quelques stèles funéraires grecques’, Arch. Class, xxv/vi (1973/1974) 238–49.Google Scholar
Davaras, (K.): ‘Anaskaphai Perisylloges kai tychaia heuremata. Attike’, ADelt. xx (1965) B 118–27.Google Scholar
Davies, (J.K.): Athenian Propertied Families (Oxford 1971).Google Scholar
Dover, (K.J.): Greek Homosexuality (London 1978).Google Scholar
Ducat, (J.): ‘Fonctions de la statue dans la Grèce archaïque: kouros et kolossos’, BCH c (1976) 239–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dunant, (C.)Pouilloux, (J.): Recherches sur l'histoire et les cultes de Thasos, ii. De 196 avant J.-C. jusqu'à la fin de l'antiquité (Paris 1958).Google Scholar
Duval, (Amaury): Des sépultures (Paris 1801).Google Scholar
Eichler, (F.): ‘ΣΗΜΑ und ΜΝΗΜΑ in älteren griechischen Grabinschriften’, Ath. Mitt. xxxix (1914) 138–43.Google Scholar
Etienne, (R.): ‘Collection Dolly Goulandris, ii. Stèle funéraire attique’, BCH xcix (1975) 379–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fabricius, (J.A.): Bibliographia Antiquaria 3 (Hamburg 1760).Google Scholar
Ferrarius, (O.): Dissertatio de veterum lucernis sepulcralibus (1699) in Graevius vol. xii.Google Scholar
Fraser, (P.M.) I: ‘An inscription from Cos’, Bull. Soc. arch. d'Alexandrie xl (1953) 3562.Google Scholar
Fraser, (P.M.) II: Rhodian funerary monuments (Oxford 1977).Google Scholar
Freytag (Löringhoff), (B. von): ‘Archaische und klassische Grabfunde auf dem Hang nördlich der “Eckterrasse” im Kerameikos’, Ath. Mitt. xci (1976) 3161.Google Scholar
Friedländer, (P.): Epigrammata. Greek Inscriptions in verse from the beginnings to the Persian Wars (Berkeley 1948).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fuchs, (W.): review of Dohrn, T., Attische Plastik vom Tode des Phidias bis zum Wirken der grossen Meister des 4. Jh. v. Chr. (Krefell 1957) in Gnomon xxxiii (1961) 237–42.Google Scholar
Fustel de Coulanges, (N.D.): La cité; antique (Paris 1864).Google Scholar
Gernet, (L.): ‘La création du testament’, REG xxxiii (1920) 123–68, 249–90 (revised and abridged in Gernet, Droit et société dans la Grèce ancienne [Paris 1955]).Google Scholar
Gomme, (A.W.): A Historical Commentary on Thucydides i–ii (Oxford 1945, 1956).Google Scholar
Grace, (V.): ‘Ancient cemetery and road at 28 Lenormant Street’, AE 1968, Chronika 44–8.Google Scholar
Graeven, (C.F.): De Coemeteriis ex urbibus tollendis (Diss. [Canon law] Frankfurt 1730), erroneously attributed to C. G. Hoffman, the presiding Dean, by Fabricius.Google Scholar
Graevius, (J. G.): Thesaurus Antiquitatum i–xii (Leiden/Utrecht 1694 ff.).Google Scholar
Hainsworth, (J.B.): Tituli ad dialectos graecas illustrandas selecti, ii. Tituli dorici et ionici, Textus Minores xliv (Leiden 1972).Google Scholar
Hammond, (N.G.L.) I: ‘Strategia and hegemonia in 5th century Athens’, CQ xix (1969) 111–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hammond, (N.G.L.) II: Migrations and Invasions in Greece and adjacent areas (Paul Ridge, N.J. 1977).Google Scholar
Hartog, (F.): ‘Les funérailles des rois scythes: la mort de l'autre’ in L'idéologie funéraire.Google Scholar
Harvey, (A.E.): ‘The classification of Greek lyric poetry’, CQ v (1955) 157–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Helbig, (W.): ‘Zu den homerischen Bestattungsgebräuchen’, SBAW München (1900) 199279.Google Scholar
Hondius, (J.J.E.): ‘A new inscription of the deme Halimous’, BSA xxiv (1921) 151–60.Google Scholar
Hornstein, (É.): Les sépultures (Paris 1868).Google Scholar
Humphreys, (S.C.) I: ‘Public and private interests in classical Athens’, CJ lxxiii (1977) 97104.Google Scholar
Humphreys, (S.C.) II: ‘Introduction, part ii’, in Fustel de Coulanges, N. D., The Ancient City (Baltimore 1980).Google Scholar
Jacoby, (F.) I: ‘Genesia. A forgotten festival of the dead’, CQ xxxviii (1944) 6575.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jacoby, (F.) II: ‘Patrios nomos: state burial in Athens and the public cemetery in the Kerameikos’, JHS lxiv (1944) 3766.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jeffery, (L.H.) I: The Local Scripts of archaic Greece (Oxford 1961).Google Scholar
Jeffery, (L.H.) II: ‘The Inscribed Gravestones of archaic Attica’, BSA lvii (1962) 115–53.Google Scholar
Kahrstedt, (U.): Untersuchungen zur Magistratur in Athen (Stuttgart/Berlin 1936).Google Scholar
Kallipolitis, (V.G.) I: ‘Anaskaphai taphon Anagyrountos’, A Delt. xviii (1963) A 115–32.Google Scholar
Kallipolitis, (V.G.) II: ‘Archaiotetes kai mnemeia Attikes kai neson’, ADelt. xx (1965) B 110–17.Google Scholar
Kallipolitis, (V.G.)Petrakos, (V.Ch.): ‘Attike kai Aigina’, ADelt. xviii (1963) B 4352.Google Scholar
Kamps, (W.): ‘Les origines de la fondation cultuelle dans la Grèce ancienne’, Archives d'histoire du droit oriental i (1937) 145–79.Google Scholar
Karouzou, (S.) I: ‘Un cimetière de l'époque classique à Athènes’, BCH lxxi/ii (1947/1948) 385–91.Google Scholar
Karouzou, (S.) II: ‘Epitymbia stele titthes sto Ethniko Mouseio’, Hellenika xv (1957) 311–23.Google Scholar
Karouzou, (S.) III: Angeia tou Anagyrountos (Athens 1963).Google Scholar
Kastriotis, (P.)Philadelpheus, (A.): ‘Anaskaphes Anavysou: perigraphe anaskaphes taphon’, PAE 1911 110–31.Google Scholar
Kern, (O.): Die Inschriften von Magnesia am Maeander (Berlin 1900).Google Scholar
Klein, (A.E.): Child life in Greek art (New York 1932).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Knigge, (U.): Der Südhügel (Kerameikos. Ergebnisse der Ausgrabungen ix: Berlin 1976).Google Scholar
Kotzias, (N.Ch.): ‘Epigraphai Attikes’, Polemon iii (1948) 145–51.Google Scholar
Kübler, (K.) I: Die Nekropole des 10. bis 8. Jahrhunderts (Kerameikos v: Berlin 1954).Google Scholar
Kübler, (K.) II. Die Nekropole des späten 8. bis frühen 6. Jahrhunderts (Kerameikos vi 1: Berlin 1959).Google Scholar
Kübler, (K.) III: Die Nekropole der Mitte des 6. bis Ende des 5. Jahrhunderts (Kerameikos vii 1: Berlin 1976).Google Scholar
Kurtz, (D.C.): Athenian White Lekythoi, Patterns and Painters (Oxford 1975).Google Scholar
Kurtz, (D.C.)Boardman, (J.M.): Greek Burial Customs (London 1971).Google Scholar
Kyparisses, (N.): ‘Hai anaskaphai ton vasilikon stavlon’, ADelt. Parartema (19221925) 6872.Google Scholar
Laum, (B.): Stiftungen in der greichischen und römischen Antike (Leipzig 1914).Google Scholar
Lemerle, (P.): ‘Chronique des fouilles 1937’, BCH lxi (1937) 441–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Liakouras, (A.G.): ‘B' ephoreia klassikon archaioteton’, ADelt. xxvii (1972) B 1 147–82.Google Scholar
L'idéologie funéraire. La mort et les morts dans les sociétés anciennes, ed. Vernant, J.-P. (Cambridge: in press).Google Scholar
Linders, (T.): Studies in the treasure records of Artemis Brauronia found in Athens (Stockholm 1972).Google Scholar
Loraux, (N.): ‘Mort civique et idéologie de la cité’, in L'idéologie funéraire.Google Scholar
Mastrokostas, (E.I.) I: ‘Epistemata ek Myrrhinountos’, Charisterion eis A. K. Orlandon iii (Athens 1966) 281–99.Google Scholar
Mastrokostas, (E.I.) II: ‘He kore Phrasikleia Aristionos tou Pariou kai kouros marmarinos anekalyphthesan en Myrrhinounti’, AAA v (1972) 298324.Google Scholar
Meliades, (I.): ‘Anaskaphai notios tes Akropoleos’, PAE 1955 3652.Google Scholar
Metzger, (H.): Les Représentations dans la céramique attique du IV siècle (Paris 1951).Google Scholar
Möbius, (H.): ‘Eigenartige attische Grabreliefs’, Ath. Mitt. lxxxi (1966) 136–60.Google Scholar
Mommsen, (A.): Feste der Stadt Athen im Altertum (Leipzig 1898).Google Scholar
Mylonas, (G.): To dytikon nekrotapheion tes Elefsinos (Athens 1975).Google Scholar
Nilsson, (M.): ‘Der Ursprung der Tragödie’, Neue Jb. für das klass. Altertum xxvii (xiv) (1911) 609–42, 673–96.Google Scholar
North, (H.): Sophrosyne. Self-knowledge and self-restraint in Greek literature (Ithaca 1966).Google Scholar
Pantos, (A.)Epitymbion epigramma ex Athenon’, AAA vii (1974) 406–15.Google Scholar
Peek, (W.) I: ‘Attische Inschriften’, Ath. Mitt. lxvii (1942) 1217.Google Scholar
Peek, (W.) II: Griechische Vers-Inschriften i. Grab-Epigramme (Berlin 1955).Google Scholar
Peek, (W.) III: Attische Grabschriften ii. (ADAW Berlin iii 1956).Google Scholar
Petrakos, (V.Ch.) I: ‘Anaskaphe Rhamnountos’, PAE 1975 535.Google Scholar
Petrakos, (V.Ch.) II: ‘Anaskaphe Rhamnountos’, PAE 1976 560.Google Scholar
Pfohl, (G.): Greek Poems on Stones i. Epitaphs from the 7th to the 5th centuries B.C. (Leiden 1967).Google Scholar
Potter, (J.): Archaeologiae Graecae, or the Antiquities of Greece (London 16971699).Google Scholar
Pouilloux, (J.): La forteresse de Rhamnonte, BEFAR clxxix (Paris 1954).Google Scholar
Price, (T.H.): ‘Hero-cult and Homer’, Historia xxii (1973) 129–44.Google Scholar
Riemann, (H.): ‘Archäologische Funde vom Sommer 1936 bis Sommer 1937. Griechenland’, AA 1937 86184.Google Scholar
Riezler, (W.): Weissgrundige attische Lekythen (Munich 1914).Google Scholar
Roux, (G.): ‘Les grimaces de Cleisthènes’, REG lxxx (1967) 165–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Saurmann, (J.F.): Tractatus historico-juridicus de Jure circa sepulchra et hominum demortuorum cadavera (Bremen 1737).Google Scholar
Schilardis, (D.-O.) I: ‘Anaskaphai para tas “Erias Pylas” kai topographica problemata tes perioches’, AE 1968, Chronika 852.Google Scholar
Schilardis, (D.-O.) II: ‘Tymbos klassikou taphou ex Athenon’, AAA ii (1969) 334–8.Google Scholar
Schilardis, (D.-O.) III: ‘Anaskaphe para ta Makra Teiche kai he oinochoe tou Taurou’, AE 1975 66149.Google Scholar
Schlorb-Vierneisel, (B.): ‘Eridanos-Nekropole’, Ath. Mitt. lxxxi (1966) 1111.Google Scholar
Schmitt, (P.): ‘Évergétisme et mémoire du mort: à propos des fondations de banquets publics dans les cités grecques à l'époque hellénistique et romaine’, in L'idéologie funéraire.Google Scholar
Smithson, (E.L.) I: ‘The Protogeometric cemetery at Nea Ionia, 1949’, Hesp. xxx (1961) 147–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smithson, (E.L.) II: ‘A Geometrie cemetery on the Areopagus: 1897, 1932, 1947’, Hesp. xliii (1974) 325–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Snodgrass, (A.M.): ‘The origins of the Greek hero cults’, in L' idéologie funéraire.Google Scholar
Sokolowski, (F.) I: Lois sacrées de l'Asie Mineure (Paris 1955).Google Scholar
Sokolowski, (F.) II: Lois sacrées des cités grecques (Paris 1969).Google Scholar
Soteriades, (G.): ‘Anaskaphe Marathonos’, PAE 1939 2739.Google Scholar
Stais, (V.) I: ‘Ho tymbos en Vourvai’, Ath. Mitt. xv (1890) 318–29.Google Scholar
Stais, (V.) II: ‘Anaskaphai tymbon en Attike’, ADelt. vi (1890) 1628, 49, 100, 105–13.Google Scholar
Stais, (V.) III: ‘Peri ton en Varei anaskaphon’, ADelt. vii (1891) 2832.Google Scholar
Stavropoulos, (Ph.D.): ‘Athenai-Attike: B'. Anaskaphikai ereunai kai tychaia heuremata’, ADelt. xx (1965) B 44109.Google Scholar
Stone, (L.): The Family, Sex and Marriage in England 1500–1800 (London 1977).Google Scholar
Stupperich, (R.): Staatsbegrabnis und Privatgrabmal im klassischen Athen (Diss. Münster 1977).Google Scholar
Technau, (W.): Exekias (Leipzig 1936).Google Scholar
Thimme, (J.): ‘Die Stele des Hegeso als Zeugnis des attischen Grabkultes’, AK vii (1964) 1629.Google Scholar
Thompson, (W.E.) I: ‘The marriage of first cousins in Athenian society’, Phoenix xxi (1967) 273–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thompson, (W.E.) II: ‘Some Attic kinship terms’, Glotta xlviii (1970) 7581.Google Scholar
Thompson, (W.E.) III: De Hagniae Hereditate, an Athenian inheritance case (Mnem. Suppl. xliv: Leiden 1976).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thönges-Stringaris, (R.N.): ‘Das griechische Totenmahl’, Ath. Mitt. lxxx (1965) 199.Google Scholar
Tod, (M.N.): A Selection of Greek historical inscriptions ii. From 403 to 323 B.C. (Oxford 1948).Google Scholar
Tuplin, (C.J.): ‘Some emendations to the family-tree of Isokrates’, CQ xxx (1980).Google Scholar
Vermeule, (E.) I: ‘Five vases from the grave precinct of Dexileos’, JdI lxxxv (1970) 94111.Google Scholar
Vermeule, (E.) II: Aspects of death in early Greek art and poetry (Berkeley 1979).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vernant, (J.-P.) I: ‘Étude comparée des religions antiques’, Ann. du Coll. de France lxxvii (1977) 423–43.Google Scholar
Vernant, (J.-P.) II: ‘Étude comparée des religions antiques’, Ann. du Coll. de France lxxviii (1978) 451–65.Google Scholar
Vernant, (J.-P.) III: ‘L'idéologie de la mort héroique’, in L'idéologie funéraire.Google Scholar
Vierneisel, (K.): ‘Die Grabung in der Nekropole 1962’, AA 1964 420–67.Google Scholar
Wagner, (J.)Petzl, (G.): ‘Eine neue Temenos-stele des Königs Antiochus I von Commagene’, ZPE xx (1976) 201–23.Google Scholar
Waldmann, (H.): Die kommagenischen Kultreformen unter König Mithradates I Kallinikos und seinem Sohn Antiochos I (Leiden 1973).Google Scholar
Wallace, (M.B.): ‘Notes on early Greek grave epigrams’, Phoenix xxiv (1970) 95105.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walter, (O.): ‘Archäologische Funde in Griechenland von Frühjahr 1939 bis Frühjahr 1940’, AA 1940 121308.Google Scholar
Wehrli, (F.) I: ed., Die Schule des Aristoteles iv. Demetrios von Phaleron (Basel 1949).Google Scholar
Wehrli, (F.) II: ‘Les gynéconomes’, Mus. Helv. xix (1962) 33–8.Google Scholar
Wilamowitz, (U. von): ‘Lesefrüchte cclxxvi’, Hermes lxv (1930) 253–4.Google Scholar
Wilhelm, (A.): ‘Bemerkungen zu den attischen Grabinschriften IG ii 2’, ZPE xxix (1978) 5790.Google Scholar
Young, (R.S.) I: Late Geometric graves and a 7th century well in the Agora (Hesp. Suppl. ii: 1939).Google Scholar
Young, (R.S.) II: ‘Sepulturae intra urbem’, Hesp. xx (1951) 67134.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zapheiropoulos, (N.S.): ‘Marmarine lekythos met' epitymbiou parastaseos’, AE 1953/1954 ii 237–46.Google Scholar
Zschietzschmann, (W.): ‘Die Darstellungen der Prothesis in der griechischen Kunst’, Ath. Mitt. liii (1928) 1747.Google Scholar