Abstract
In this article, I propose a semantic account of temporally mismatched past subjunctive counterfactuals. The proposal consists of the following parts. First, I show that in cases of temporal mismatch, [past] cannot be interpreted inside the proposition where it occurs at surface structure. Instead, it must be interpreted as constraining the time argument of the accessibility relation. This has the effect of shifting the time of the evaluation of the conditional to some contextually salient past time. Second, I will propose specific felicity conditions (presuppositions) for subjunctive conditionals and I will argue that there is a strict correspondence between the time of evaluation in the truth conditions of a conditional and the time relevant for the felicity conditions. In other words, if the time relevant for the accessibility relation has been shifted to the past, then the conditional's presupposition will make reference to a past context. On the other hand, if no past is constraining the time argument of the accessibility relation, the conditional's felicity will make reference to the current (main) context. Third, I will argue that the intuition that the antecedent of mismatched counterfactuals is not true is a scalar implicature arising from a competition not between assertions but between presuppositions. Finally, I will investigate the repercussions of my proposal for the general theory of modality.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anderson, A. R.: 1951, 'A Note on Subjunctive and Counterfactual Conditionals', Analysis 12, 35–38.
Carnap, R.: 1947, Meaning and Necessity. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Copley, B.: 2001, 'On the Syntax and Semantics of Futurate Readings', in E. Guerzoni and O. Matushansky (eds.), A Few from Building E39, MITWPL 36, pp. 23–42. MIT, Cambridge, Mass.
Copley, B.: 2002, The Semantics of the Future, PhD dissertation, MIT.
Dowty, D.: 1977, 'Towards a Semantic Analysis of Verb Aspect and the English “Imperfective” Progressive', Linguistics and Philosophy 1, 45–77.
Dudman, V. H.: 1983, 'Tense and Time in English Verb Clusters of the Primary Pattern', Australian Journal of Linguistics 3, 25–44.
Dudman, V. H.: 1984, 'Conditional Interpretations of If-sentences', Australian Journal of Linguistics 4, 143–204.
EnÇ, M.: 1986, 'Towards a Referential Analysis of Temporal Expressions', Linguistics and Philosophy 9, 405–426.
von Fintel, K.: 1998, 'The Presupposition of Subjunctive Conditionals', in U. Sauerland and O. Percus (eds.), The Interpretive Tract, MITWPL 25, pp. 29–44. MIT, Cambridge, Mass.
von Fintel, K.: 2001, 'Counterfactuals in a Dynamic Context', in M. Kenstowicz (ed.), Ken Hale. A Life in Language, pp. 132–152. MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.
Grice, H. P.: 1975, 'Logic and Conversation', in P. Cole and J. Morgan (eds.), Syntax and Semantics 3: Speech Acts, pp. 41–58. Academic Press, New York.
Hawkins, J.: 1991, 'On (In)definite Articles; Implicatures and (Un)grammaticality Prediction', Journal of Linguistics 27, 405–442.
Heim, I.: 1988, The Semantics of Definite and Indefinite Noun Phrases. Garland Press, New York.
Heim, I.: 1991, 'Artikel und Definitheit', in A. von Stechow and D. Wunderlich (eds.), Semantik. Ein internationales Handbuch der zeitgenössischen Forschung, pp. 487–535. De Gruyter, Berlin.
Heim, I.: 1992, 'Presupposition Projection and the Semantics of Attitude Verbs', Journal of Semantics 9, 183–221.
Heim, I.: 1994, 'Comments on Abusch's Theory of Tense', in H. Kamp (ed.), Ellipsis, Tense and Questions, pp. 141–170. University of Amsterdam.
Heim, I. and A. Kratzer: 1998, Semantics in Generative Grammar. Blackwell, Cambridge, Mass.
Hintikka, J.: 1961, 'Modality and Quantification', Theoria 27, 119–128.
Iatridou, S.: 2000, 'The Grammatical Ingredients of Counterfactuality', Linguistic Inquiry 31, 231–270.
Iatridou, S. and D. Embick: 1994, 'Conditional Inversion', Proceedings of NELS 24. GLSA, University of Massachusetts, Amherst.
Ippolito, M.: 2002a, 'On the Semantic Composition of Subjunctive Conditionals', ms., MIT/Tübingen University.
Ippolito, M.: 2002b, The Time of Possibilities: Truth and Felicity of Subjunctive Conditionals, PhD dissertation, MIT.
Ippolito, M.: forthcoming, 'A Pragmatic Analysis of Imperfect Conditionals', in R. Núñez-Cedeño, L. Lopez, and R. Cameron (eds.), Language Knowledge and Use: A Romance Perspective. John Benjamins, Amsterdam.
Karttunen, L.: 1974, 'Presupposition and Linguistic Context', Theoretical Linguistics 1, 181–194.
Kratzer, A.: 1981, 'The Notional Category of Modality', in H.-J. Eikmeyer and H. Rieser (eds.), Words, Worlds, and Contexts, pp. 38–74. De Gruyter, Berlin.
Kratzer, A.: 1986, 'Conditionals', in A. M. Farley, P. Farley, and K.-E. McCullough (eds.), CLS 22: Papers from the Parasession on Pragmatics and Grammatical Theory, pp. 1–15. Chicago Linguistic Society, Chicago.
Kratzer, A.: 1991, 'Modality', in A. von Stechow and D. Wunderlich (eds.), An International Handbook of Contemporary Research, pp. 639–650. De Gruyter, Berlin.
Kratzer, A.: 1998, 'More Structural Analogies Between Pronouns and Tenses', in D. Strolovitch and A. Lawson (eds.), Proceedings of SALT 8. CLC Publications, Cornell University, Ithaca, N.Y.
Kripke, S.: 1959, 'A Completeness Theorem in Modal Logic', Journal of Symbolic Logic 24, 1–14.
Kripke, S.: 1963, 'Semantic Analysis of Modal Logic I: Normal Modal Propositional Calculi', Zeitschrift für mathematische Logik und Grundlagen der Mathematik 9, 67–96.
Kripke, S.: (undated), 'Presuppositions and Anaphora: Remarks on the Formulation of the Projection Problem', ms., Princeton University.
Lewis, D.: 1968, On the Plurality of Worlds. Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
Lewis, D.: 1973, Counterfactuals. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.
Lewis, D.: 1975, 'Adverbs of Quantification', in E. Keenan (ed.), Formal Semantics of Natural Language, pp. 3–15. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Lewis, D.: 1979, 'Counterfactual Dependence and Time's Arrow', Noûs 13, 455–476. Reprinted in D. Lewis (1986), Philosophical Papers, Vol. 2, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Musan, R.: 1997, On the Temporal Interpretation of Noun Phrases (Outstanding Dissertations in Linguistics). Garland, New York.
Ogihara, T.: 2000, 'Counterfactuals, Temporal Adverbs, and Association with Focus', in Proceedings of SALT 10, pp. 115–131. CLS Publications, Cornell University, Ithaca, N.Y.
Palmer, F. R.: 1986, Mood and Modality. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Palmer, F. R.: 2001, Mood and Modality, second ed. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Partee, B.: 1973, 'Some Structural Analogies between Tense and Pronouns', The Journal of Philosophy 70, 601–609.
Pesetsky, D.: 1989, 'Language Particular Processes and the Earliness Principle', ms., MIT.
Pesetsky, D.: 2000, Phrasal Movement and Its Kin. MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.
Rooth, M.: 1985, Association with Focus, PhD dissertation, University of Massachusetts at Amherst.
Rooth, M.: 1992, 'A Theory of Focus Interpretation', Natural Language Semantics 1, 75–116.
Schwarzschild, R.: 1999, 'GIVENness, AvoidF and Other Constraints on the Placement of Accent', Natural Language Semantics 7, 141–177.
Stalnaker, R.: 1968, 'A Theory of Conditionals', in N. Rescher (ed.), Studies in Logical Theory 2 (American Philosophical Quarterly Monograph series), pp. 98–122. Blackwell, Oxford.
Stalnaker, R.: 1973, 'Presuppositions', Journal of Philosophical Logic 2, 447–457.
Stalnaker, R.: 1974, 'Pragmatic Presuppositions', in M. Munitc and D. Unger (eds.), Semantics and Philosophy, pp. 197–213. New York University Press, New York.
Stalnaker, R.: 1975, 'Indicative Conditionals', Philosophia 5, pp. 269–286. Reprinted in R. Stalnaker, Context and Content, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1999.
Stalnaker, R.: 1981, 'A Defense of the Conditional Excluded Middle', in W. Harper, R. Stalnaker, and G. Pearce (eds.), Ifs: Conditionals, Belief, Decision, Change and Time, pp. 87–104. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Stalnaker, R.: 1984, Inquiry. MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.
Stowell, T.: 1982, 'The Tense of Infinitives', Linguistic Inquiry 13, 561–570.
Truckenbrodt, H.: 1995, Phonological Phrases: Their Relation to Syntax, Focus, and Prominence, PhD dissertation, MIT.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ippolito, M. Presuppositions and Implicatures in Counterfactuals. Natural Language Semantics 11, 145–186 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1024411924818
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1024411924818