Kagaku tetsugaku
Online ISSN : 1883-6461
Print ISSN : 0289-3428
ISSN-L : 0289-3428
Descriptive Methods and the “Dysfunction” Model in Psychiatry
“Natural Kinds” and the Concept of Mental Disorder
Kohji Ishihara
Author information
JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

2014 Volume 47 Issue 2 Pages 17-32

Details
Abstract

    Throughout the history of modern psychiatry, descriptive methods and operational definitions have featured prominently in endeavors to objectively refer to and classify mental disorders. An alternative to these descriptive approaches is the argument based on the concepts of “natural kinds” and “dysfunction” such as Wakefieldʼs “harmful dysfunction” model. However, none of these approaches seem promising for understanding the nature of mental disorders. This paper proposes that we abandon the prevalent tendency to objectively classify mental disorders, revert to the original meaning of psychiatry (Psychiaterie), a term coined by J. C. Reil, as a method of therapy, and reexamine the concept of mental disorder.

Content from these authors
© 2014 The Philosophy of Science Society, Japan
Previous article Next article
feedback
Top