Abstract
This paper discusses a way of introducing ascientific controversy, which emphasizes objectiveaspects of such issues as multiple theoreticalinterpretation of phenomena, choosing a theory,insistence on the chosen theory, and others. The goalis to give students a better insight into the workingsof science and provide guidelines for buildingtheories in their own research.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aldini, G.: 1794, De Animali Electricitate. Dissertationes Due, Bologna, I, 5-8.
Davy, H.: 1800, ‘Notice of Some Observations on the Causes of the Galvanic Phenomena’, Nicholson's Journal of Natural Philosophy 4, 337–342.
Galvani, L.: 1953, Commentary on the Effects of Electricity in Muscular Motion [1791], transl. by M.F. Foley, Norwalk, CT.
Galvani, L.: 1794, Dell;uso et dell'attivita dell'arco Conduttore nelle Contrazione dei Muscoli. Supplemento, pp. 4-6, Bologna. See an English translation of the description of this experiment in Dibner, B.: 1952, Galvani-Volta, Norwalk, CT, pp. 50–51.
Kipnis, N.: 1987, ‘Luigi Galvani and the Debate on Animal Electricity, 1791–1800’, Annals of Science 44, 107–142.
Kipnis, N.: 1992, Rediscovering Optics, BENA Press, Minneapolis.
Mertens, J.: 1998, ‘Shocks and Sparks: The Voltaic Pile as a Demonstration Device’, Isis 89, 300–311.
Nicholson, W.: 1800, ‘Account of the New Electrical Apparatus of Sig. Alex. Volta....’, Nicholson's Journal of Natural Philosophy 4, 179–187.
Pera, M.: 1992, The Ambiguous Frog, transl. by J. Mandelbaum, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Volta, A.: 1793, ‘Account of Some Discoveries Made by Mr. Galvani.... In a letter to Mr. Tiberius Cavallo’, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. Lond. 83, 10-44; also Le Opere di Alessandro Volta, 7 vols (Milano, 1918; reprint: New York, 1968), I, 173–208.
Volta, A.: 1797a, ‘Lettera Prima al Prof. Gren di Halla, 1 August 1796’, Neues Journal der Physik, 3, 479-481; also Opere I, 395–413.
Volta, A.: 1797b, ‘Lettera Seconda al Prof. Gren [August 1796]’, Neues Journal der Physik 4, 107-135; also Opere I, 417–431.
Volta, A.: 1797c, ‘Lettera Terza al Prof. Gren [March 1797]’, Brugnatelli's Annali di chimica 14, 40ff; also Opere I, 435–447.
Volta, A.: 1797d, ‘Mémoire sur l'Électricité Excitée par le Contact Mutuel des Conducteurs Même les Plus Parfaits... en une Suite de Lettres au Dr. VanMarum’, unpublished, Opere I 493–516.
Volta, A.: 1800, ‘On the Electricity Excited by the Mere Contact of Conducting Substances of Different Kinds’ (in French), Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. Lond. 90(2), 403-431; see also the English translation in: 1800, Philosophical Magazine 7, 289–311.
Volta, A.: 1802, ‘Électricité Voltaïque’, Bibliotheque Britannique 19, 270-289, 339–350.
Wollaston, W.H.: 1801, ‘Experiments on the Chemical Production and Agency of Electricity’, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. Lond. 90, 427–434.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kipnis, N. Scientific Controversies in Teaching Science: The Case of Volta. Science & Education 10, 33–49 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1008760521211
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1008760521211