Abstract
Is it ever permissible to publish a patient’s confidences without permission? I investigate this question for the field of psychoanalysis. Whereas most medical fields adopted a 1995 recommendation for consent requirements, psychoanalysis continues to defend the traditional practice of nonconsensual publication. Both the hermeneutic and the scientific branches of the field justify the practice, arguing that it provides data needed to help future patients, and both branches advance generalizations and causal claims. However the hermeneutic branch embraces methods tending to undermine the reliability of such claims, while the scientific branch aims to improve the field’s empirical base – in their words, to advance psychoanalysis as a science. The scientific branch therefore has the stronger claim to the traditional practice, and it their claim that I consider. An immediate concern arises. We seem unable to answer the applied ethical question without first determining which ethical theory is correct; for defenders of the practice appeal variously to therapeutic privilege, principlism, and utilitarianism, while opponents wage autonomy-based arguments. The concern turns out to be unfounded, however, because all of these ethical approaches fail to justify the traditional practice. The more promising defenses fail partly because even the scientific branch of the field lacks empirically sound methods for establishing its causal claims and generalizations, often appealing to authority instead. I conclude that it is currently unethical for analysts to continue publishing their patients’ confidences without permission, and I suggest that the field help future patients by attending to its methodological problems.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
H.M. Bachrach R. Galatzer-Levy A. Skolnikoff S. Waldron SuffixJr. (1991) ArticleTitle‘On the Efficacy of Psychoanalysis’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 39 871–916 Occurrence Handle1800553 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK387ptlGmsw%3D%3D
Barlow, D. and M. Herson: 1984, Single Case Experimental Designs: Strategies for Studying Behavior Change (2nd ed). Pergamon Press
J.O. Beahrs T.G. Gunheil (2000) ArticleTitle‘Informed Consent in Psychotherapy’ American Journal of Psychiatry 158 IssueID1 4–10 Occurrence Handle10.1176/appi.ajp.158.1.4
T. Beauchamp J. Childress (2001) Principles of Biomedical Ethics EditionNumber5 Oxford University Press New York, NY
S.J. Blatt G. Shahar (2004) ArticleTitle‘Psychoanalysis – With Whom, for What, and How? Comparisons with Psychotherapy’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 52 IssueID2 393–447 Occurrence Handle15222434
J. Blomberg A. Lazar R. Sandell (2001) ArticleTitle‘Long-Term Outcome of Long-Term Psychoanalytically Oriented Therapies: First Findings of the Stockholm Outcome of Psychotherapy and Psychoanalysis Study’ Psychotherapy Research 11 IssueID4 361–382 Occurrence Handle10.1093/ptr/11.4.361
British Journal of Psychiatry, Instructions for Authors
Canterbury v. Spence: 1972. U.S. Court of Appeals. Federal Reporter, 2nd series, Vol. 464
L.H. Clever (1997) ArticleTitle‘Obtain Informed Consent Before Publishing Information About Patients’ JAMA 278 IssueID8 628–629 Occurrence Handle9272884 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK2svhslGisw%3D%3D Occurrence Handle10.1001/jama.278.8.628
S.J. Coen (2000a) ArticleTitle‘Why We Need to Write Openly About our Clinical Cases’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 48 449–469 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DC%2BD3M%2Fks1ahuw%3D%3D
S.J. Coen (2000b) ArticleTitle‘Clinical Discussants as Psychoanalytic Readers’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 48 471–495 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DC%2BD3M%2Fks1agsg%3D%3D
A. Coulter (1999) ArticleTitle‘Paternalism or Partnership?’ British Medical Journal 319 719–720 Occurrence Handle10487980 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK1MvhvVyqsw%3D%3D
H. Dahl (1974) ArticleTitle‘The Measurement of Meaning in Psychoanalysis by Computer Analysis of Verbal Contexts’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 22 37–57 Occurrence Handle4822115 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaE2c7kt1CgsA%3D%3D Occurrence Handle10.1177/000306517402200103
Doe v. Roe: 1977. LEXSEE 400 NY S 2D 668, Jane Doe, Plaintiff, v. Joan Roe et al., Defendants, Supreme Court of New York, New York County; 93 Misc. 2d 201; 400 N.Y.S.2d 668.
Freud S.: 1905, ‘Fragment of an Analysis of a Case of Hysteria’, in: J. Strachey (ed.), The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud,Vol. 7, London: Hogarth Press, 1953, pp. 1–122
A. Furlong (1998) ArticleTitle‘Should We or Shouldn’t We? Some Aspects of the Confidentiality of Clinical Reporting and Dossier Access’ International Journal of Psycho-Analysis 79 727–739 Occurrence Handle9777451
G. Gabbard J. Gunderson P. Fonagy (2002) ArticleTitle‘The place of psychoanalytic treatments within psychiatry’ Arch Gen Psychiatry 59 IssueID6 505–510 Occurrence Handle12044192 Occurrence Handle10.1001/archpsyc.59.6.505
G. Gabbard (2000) ArticleTitle‘Disguise or Consent: Problems and Recommendations Concerning the Publication and Presentation of Clinical Material’ International Journal of Psycho-Analysis 81 1071–1086 Occurrence Handle11144850
R. Galatzer-Levy (2003) ‘Psychoanalytic Research and Confidentiality: Dilemmas’ C. Levin A. Furlong (Eds) Confidentiality: Ethical Perspectives and Clinical Dilemmas Analytic Press, Inc. Hillsdale, NJ, US 86–106
A. Goldberg (1997a) ArticleTitle‘Writing Case Histories’ International Journal of Psycho-Analysis 78 435–438
A. Goldberg (1997b) ArticleTitle‘Response’ International Journal of Psycho-Analysis 78 821
B.H. Gross (2001) ArticleTitle‘Informed consent’ Annals of the American Psychotherapy Association 4 IssueID5 24
A. Grünbaum (2001) ‘Critique of Freud’s Notion of Mental Illness’ A-T. Tymieniecka (Eds) Life: Interpretation and the Sense of Illness Within the Human Condition: Medicine and Philosophy in a Dialogue. Analecta Husserliana NumberInSeriesVol. 72 Kluwer Academic Publishers Dordrecht, The Netherlands
A. Grünbaum (1993) Validation in the Clinical Theory of Psychoanalysis: A Study in the Philosophy of Psychoanalysis. Psychological Issues, Monograph 61l International Universities Press, Inc Madison, CT
A. Grünbaum (1984) The Foundations of Psychoanalysis: A Philosophical Critique University of California Press Berkeley, CA
J. Halpern (2003) ArticleTitle‘Beyond Wishful Thinking: Facing the Harm that Psychotherapists Can Do by Writing About Their Patients’ The Journal of Clinical Ethics 14 IssueID1/2 118–136 Occurrence Handle12953360
R.P Hobson M.P. Patrick J.D. Valentine (1998) ArticleTitle‘Objectivity in Psychoanalytic Judgements’ British Journal of Psychiatry 173 172–177 Occurrence Handle9850231 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK1M%2FmslaitQ%3D%3D
E.G. Howe (2003) ArticleTitle‘Whither Informed Consent? Lessons from Jay Carter’ The Journal of Clinical Ethics 14 IssueID1/2 109–117 Occurrence Handle12953359
InstitutionalAuthorNameInternational Committee of Medical Journal Editors (1995) ArticleTitle‘Protection of Patients’ Rights to Privacy’ British Medical Journal 311 1272
J.L. Kantrowitz (2004a) ArticleTitle‘Writing About Patients: I. Ways of Protecting Confidentiality and Analysts Conflicts over Choice of Method’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 52 IssueID1 69–99
J.L. Kantrowitz (2004b) ArticleTitle‘Writing About Patients: II. Patients’ Reading About Themselves and their Analysts’ Perceptions of its Effect’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 52 IssueID1 101–123
G.H. Klumpner Al Frank (1991) ArticleTitle‘On Methods of Reporting Clinical Material’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 39 537–551 Occurrence Handle1856446 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK3MzhtFSjsQ%3D%3D
J. Lear (2003) ‘Confidentiality as a Virtue’ C. Levin A. Furlong (Eds) Confidentiality: Ethical Perspectives and Clinical Dilemmas Analytic Press, Inc Hillsdale, NJ, US 3–17
S.B. Levine S.J. Stagno (2001) ArticleTitle‘Informed consent for case reports: The ethical dilemma of right to privacy versus pedagogical freedom’ Journal of Psychotherapy Practice and Research 10 IssueID3 193–201 Occurrence Handle11402083 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DC%2BD3MzjsValsg%3D%3D
E.L. Lipton (1991) ArticleTitle‘The Analyst’s Use of Clinical Data and Other Issues of Confidentiality’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 39 967–985 Occurrence Handle1800556 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK387ptlGmtg%3D%3D
L. Luborsky E. Luborsky (1995) ‘The Era of Measures of Transference: the CCRT and Other Measures’ T. Shapiro R.N. Emde (Eds) Research in Psychoanalysis: Process, Development, Outcome International Universities Press Madison, CT 329–351
R. Michels (2000a) ArticleTitle‘The Case History’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 48 355–375 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DC%2BD3M%2Fks1ahtQ%3D%3D
R. Michels (2000b) ArticleTitle‘Response to Commentaries on ‘The Case History’’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 48 417–420
Nuremberg Code: 1949. ‘Reprinted’, in: Robert J. Levine (ed.), Ethics and Regulation of Clinical Research, Baltimore, MD: Urban & Schwarzenberg, 1981, pp. 285–286
E.S. Person (1983) ArticleTitle‘Women in Therapy’ International Review of Psychoanalysis 10 193–204
L.W. Reiser (2000) ArticleTitle‘The Write Stuff’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 48 351–354 Occurrence Handle10916763 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DC%2BD3M%2Fks1ahtA%3D%3D
O. Renik (1994) ArticleTitle‘Presentation of Clinical Facts’ International Journal of Psycho-Analysis 75 1245–1250 Occurrence Handle7713659
R. Rudner (1953) ArticleTitle‘The Scientist Qua Scientist Makes Value Judgments’ Philosophy of Science 20 IssueID1 1–6 Occurrence Handle10.1086/287231
J.S. Scharff (2000) ArticleTitle‘On Writing from Clinical Experience’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 48 421–447 Occurrence Handle10916765 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DC%2BD3M%2Fks1ahug%3D%3D
P. Siegel L. Josephs J. Weinberger (2002) ArticleTitle‘Where’s the Text? The Problem of Validation in Psychoanalysis’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 50 IssueID2 407–428 Occurrence Handle12206538
R. Smith (1995) ArticleTitle‘Publishing Information About Patients: Time to Change from Guarding Anonymity to Getting Consent’ British Medical Journal 311 1240–1241 Occurrence Handle7496217 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK28%2FmvFSlug%3D%3D
R.J. Stoller (1988) ArticleTitle‘Patients’ Responses to Their Own Case Reports’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 36 371–391 Occurrence Handle3403910 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaL1c3pvFCqtA%3D%3D Occurrence Handle10.1177/000306518803600205
M. Target P. Fonagy (1994a) ArticleTitle‘Efficacy of Psychoanalysis for Children with Emotional Disorders’ Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry 33 IssueID3 361–371 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK2c3it1yjtQ%3D%3D
M. Target P. Fonagy (1994b) ArticleTitle‘The Efficacy of Psychoanalysis for Children: Prediction of Outcome in a Developmental Context’ Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry 33 IssueID8 1134–1144 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK2M%2Fntl2ntw%3D%3D
D. Tuckett (1998) ArticleTitle‘Evaluating Psychoanalytic Papers: Towards the Development of Common Standards’ International Journal of Psycho-Analysis 79 431–448 Occurrence Handle9717094
D. Tuckett (2000a) ArticleTitle‘Commentary on ‘The Case History’ by Robert Michels’ Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 48 403–411
D. Tuckett (2000b) ArticleTitle‘Editorial Reporting Clinical Events in the Journal: Towards the Construction of a Special Case’ International Journal of Psycho-Analysis 81 1065–1069
D. Tuckett (1994) ArticleTitle‘The Conceptualization and Communication of Clinical Facts in Psychoanalysis’ International Journal of Psycho-Analysis 75 865–870 Occurrence Handle7713665
W. Ver Eecke (2003) ArticleTitle‘The Role of Psychoanalytic Theory and Practice in Understanding and Treating Schizophrenia: A Rejoinder to the PORT Report’s Condemnation of Psychoanalysis’ Journal of the American Academy of Psychoanalysis and Dynamic Psychiatry 31 IssueID1 11–29 Occurrence Handle12722885 Occurrence Handle10.1521/jaap.31.1.11.21929
J. Vollmann H. Helmchen (1996) ArticleTitle‘Publishing Information about Patients: Obtaining Consent May be Unethical in some Cases’ British Medical Journal 312 578 Occurrence Handle8595306 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK287nslGiuw%3D%3D
M. Warnock (1998) ArticleTitle‘Informed Consent – A Publisher’s Duty’ British Medical Journal 316 1002 Occurrence Handle11645039
D. Widlocher (1994) ArticleTitle‘A Case is Not a Fact’ International Journal of Psycho-Analysis 75 IssueID5–6 1233–1244 Occurrence Handle7713658
G. Wilkinson T. Fahy G. Russell D. Healy I. Marks D. Tantam B. Dimond (1995) ArticleTitle‘Case Reports and Confidentiality’ British Journal of Psychiatry 166 555–558 Occurrence Handle7620739 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK2Mzks1Wnsw%3D%3D Occurrence Handle10.1192/bjp.166.5.555
World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki: Recommendations Guiding Medical Doctors in Biomedical Research Involving Human Subjects, revised 1975. Reprinted in Ethics and Regulation of Clinical Research, Robert J. Levine. Baltimore, MD: Urban & Schwarzenberg, 1981, pp. 287–289
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kochiras, H. ‘Freud Said – or Simon Says? Informed consent and the advancement of psychoanalysis as a science’. Med Health Care Philos 9, 227–241 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-005-5513-0
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-005-5513-0