Abstract
I offer a critical analysis of a view that has become a dominant aspect of recent thought on the relationship between evolution and morality, and propose an alternative. An ingredient in Michael Ruse's 'error theory' (Ruse 1995) is that belief in moral (prescriptive, universal, and nonsubjective) guidelines arose in humans because such belief results in the performance of adaptive cooperative behaviors. This statement relies on two particular connections: between ostensible and intentional types of altruism, and between intentional altruism and morality. The latter connection is problematic because it makes morality redundant, its role having already been fulfilled by the psychological dispositions that constitute intentional altruism. Both behavioral ecology and moral psychology support this criticism, and neither human behavioral flexibility nor the self-regard / other-regard distinction can provide a defense of the error theory. I conclude that morality did not evolve to curb rampant selfishness; instead, the evolutionarily recent 'universal law' aspect of morality may function to update behavioral strategies which were adaptive in the paleolithic environment of our ancestors (to which our psychological dispositions are best adapted), by means of norms more appropriate to our novel social environment.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alcock J. 1993. Animal Behavior: An Evolutionary Approach. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, MA.
Alexander R.D. 1971. ‘The search for an evolutionary philosophy of man’ Proceedings of the Royal Society. 84:, pp. 99–120.
Alexander R.D. 1974. ‘The evolution of social behavior’ Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 5: 325–383.
Alexander R.D. 1979. Darwinism and Human Affairs. University of Washington Press, Seattle.
Alexander R.D. 1987. The Biology of Moral Systems. Aldine de Gruyter, Hawthorne, NY.
Alexander R.D. 1992. ‘Biological considerations in the analysis of morality’ In: Nitecki M.H. and Nitecki D.V. (eds), Evolutionary Ethics. SUNY Press, Albany, NY, pp. 163–196.
Ayala F.J. 1987. ‘The biological roots of morality’ In: Thompson P. (ed.), Issues in Evolutionary Ethics. SUNY Press, Albany, NY, pp. 293–316.
Barkow J.H., Cosmides L. and Tooby J. (eds) 1992. The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture. Oxford University Press, New York.
Batson C.D., Klein T.R., Highberger L. and Shaw L.L. 1995. ‘Immorality from empathy-induced altruism: when compassion and justice conflict’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 68: 1042–1054.
Batson C.D. and Moran T. 1999. ‘Empathy-induced altruism in a prisoner's dilemma’ European Journal of Social Psychology 29: 909–924.
Brown J.L. 1987. Helping and Communal Breeding in Birds. Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Campbell R. 1996. ‘Can Biology Make Ethics Objective?’ Biology and Philosophy 11: 21–31.
Collier J. and Stingl M. 1993. ‘Evolutionary naturalism and the objectivity of morality’ Biology and Philosophy 8: 47–60.
Darwin C. 1871. The Descent of Man and Selection in Relation to Race. 1874th edn. John Murray, London.
Dawkins R. 1976. The Selfish Gene. 1989th edn. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Dawkins R. 1982. The Extended Phenotype. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
de Waal F. 1996. Good Natured: The Origins of Right and Wrong in Humans and Other Animals. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Foot P. 1978. Virtues and Vices and Other Essays in Moral Philosophy. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA.
Goodnight C.J. and Stevens L. 1997. ‘Experimental studies of group selection: what do they tell us about group selection in nature?’ American Naturalist 150: S59–S79.
Grafen A. 1982. ‘How not to measure inclusive fitness’ Nature 298: 425–426.
Hamilton W.D. 1964. ‘The genetical evolution of social behavior, I and II’ Journal of Theoretical Biology 7: 1–52.
Hare R.M. 1981. Moral Thinking: Its Levels, Method, and Point. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Joyce R. 2000. ‘Darwinian ethics and error’ Biology & Philosophy 15: 713–732.
Kempenaers B. and Sheldon B.C. 1996. ‘Why do male birds not discriminate between their own and extra-pair offspring?’ Animal Behaviour 51: 1165–1173.
Maienschein J. and Ruse M. (eds) 1999. Biology and the Foundations of Ethics. Cambridge University Press, New York.
O'Neill P. and Petrinovich L. 1998. ‘A preliminary cross-cultural study of moral intuitions’ Evolution and Human Behavior 19: 349–367.
Payne R.B. 1998. ‘Brood parasitism in birds: Strangers in the nest’ Bioscience 48: 377–386.
Ray L. 1998. ‘Why we give: Testing economic and social psychological accounts of altruism’ Polity 30: 383–415.
Ribar D.C. and Wilhelm M.O. 2002. ‘Altruistic and joy-of-giving motivations in charitable behavior’ Journal of Political Economy 110: 425–457.
Rolston H. III 1999. Genes, Genesis, and God. Cambridge University Press, New York.
Rottschaefer W.A. and Martinsen D. 1990. ‘Really taking Darwin seriously: An alternative to Michael Ruse's Darwinian metaethics’ In: Thompson P. (ed.), Issues in Evolutionary Ethics. SUNY Press, Albany, NY, pp. 375–408.
Ruse M. 1986a. ‘Evolutionary ethics: A phoenix arisen’ In: Thompson P. (ed.), Issues in Evolutionary Ethics. SUNY Press, Albany, NY, pp. 225–247.
Ruse M. 1986b. Taking Darwin Seriously: A Naturalistic Approach to Philosophy. Blackwell, Oxford.
Ruse M. 1989. The Darwinian Paradigm: Essays on Its History, Philosophy and Religious Implications. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.
Ruse M. 1991. ‘The significance of evolution’ In: Singer P. (ed.), A Companion to Ethics. Blackwell, Oxford, pp. 500–510.
Ruse M. 1995. Evolutionary Naturalism: Selected Essays. Routledge, London.
Ruse M. 1999. ‘Evolutionary ethics: what can we learn from the past?’ Zygon 34: 435–451.
Ruse M. and Wilson E.O. 1986. ‘Moral philosophy as applied science’ In: Sober E. (ed.), Conceptual Issues in Evolutionary Biology. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 421–438.
Sorell T. 1991. Scientism: Philosophy and the Infatuation with Science. Routledge, London.
Stearns S.C. 1992. The Evolution of Life Histories. Oxford University Press, New York.
Thompson P. 1999. ‘Evolutionary ethics: its origins and contemporary face’ Zygon 34: 473–484.
Tomasello M. 1999. ‘The human adaptation for culture’ Annual Review of Anthropology 28: 509–529.
Trigg R. 1982. The Shaping of Man: Philosophical Aspects of Sociobiology. Blackwell, Oxford.
Voorzanger B. 1984. ‘Altruism in sociobiology: a conceptual analysis’ Journal of Human Evolution 13: 33–39.
Voorzanger B. 1994. ‘Bioaltruism reconsidered’ Biology and Philosophy 9: 75–84.
Zahavi A. 1995. ‘Altruism as a handicap– the limitations of kin selection and reciprocity’ Journal of Avian Biology 26: 1–3.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lahti, D.C. Parting with illusions in evolutionary ethics. Biology & Philosophy 18, 639–651 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1026356412003
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1026356412003