Abstract
Schrödinger’s equation says that the Hamiltonian is the generator of time translations. This seems to imply that any reasonable definition of time operator must be conjugate to the Hamiltonian. Then both time and energy must have the same spectrum since conjugate operators are unitarily equivalent. Clearly this is not always true: normal Hamiltonians have lower bounded spectrum and often only have discrete eigenvalues, whereas we typically desire that time can take any real value. Pauli concluded that constructing a general a time operator is impossible (although clearly it can be done in specific cases). Here we show how the Pauli argument fails when one uses an external system (a “clock”) to track time, so that time arises as correlations between the system and the clock (conditional probability amplitudes framework). In this case, the time operator is conjugate to the clock Hamiltonian and not to the system Hamiltonian, but its eigenvalues still satisfy the Schrödinger equation for arbitrary system Hamiltonians.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Kuchar̆, K.V.: Time and interpretations of quantum gravity. In: Kunstatter, G., Vincent, D., Williams, J. (eds.) Proc. 4th Canadian Conference on General Relativity and Relativistic Astrophysics, pp. 69–76. World Scientific, Singapore (1992)
Anderson, E.: The problem of time in quantum gravity. In: Frignanni, V.R. (ed.) Classical and Quantum Gravity: Theory, Analysis and Applications. Nova, New York (2012)
Kuchar̆, K.V.: In: Isham, C.J., Penrose, R., Sciama, D.W. (eds.) Quantum Gravity 2: A Second Oxford Symposium. Clarendon, Oxford (1981)
Kuchar̆, K.V.: In: Ashtekar, A., Stachel, J. (eds.) Conceptual Problems of Quantum Gravity. Birkhäuser, Boston (1991)
Isham, C.J.: In: Ibort, L.A., Rodríguez, M.A. (eds.) Integrable Systems, Quantum Groups and Quantum Field Theories. Kluwer, Dordrecht (1993)
Kuchar̆, K.V.: In: Butterfield, J. (ed.) The Arguments of Time. Oxford University Press, Oxford (1999)
Aharonov, Y., Oppenheim, J., Popescu, S., Reznik, B., Unruh, W.G.: Measurement of time of arrival in quantum mechanics. Phys. Rev. A 57, 4130 (1998)
Werner, R.: Arrival time observables in quantum mechanics. Annales de l’I. H. P. 47, 429 (1987)
Mielnik, B.: The screen problem. Found. Phys. 24, 1113 (1994)
Delgado, V., Muga, J.G.: Arrival time in quantum mechanics. Phys. Rev. A 56, 3425 (1997)
Galapon, E.A., Villanueva, A.: Quantum first time-of-arrival operators. J. Phys. A 41, 455302 (2008)
Leon, J.: Time-of-arrival formalism for the relativistic particle. J. Phys. A 30, 479 (1997)
Newton, T.D., Wigner, E.P.: Localized states for elementary systems. Rev. Mod. Phys. 21, 400 (1949)
Brunetti, R., Fredenhagen, K., Hoge, M.: Time in quantum physics: from an external parameter to an intrinsic observable. Found. Phys. 40, 1368 (2010)
Brunetti, R., Fredenhagen, K.: Time of occurrence observable in quantum mechanics. Phys. Rev. A 66, 044101 (2002)
Olkhovsky, V.S., Recami, E.: Time as a quantum observable. Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 22, 5063 (2007)
Olkhovsky, V.S.: Time as a quantum observable, canonically conjugated to energy, and foundations of self-consistent time analysis of quantum processes. Adv. Math. Phys. 2009, 859710 (2009)
Downes, T.G., Milburn, G.J., Caves, C.M.: Optimal Quantum Estimation for Gravitation, arXiv:1108.5220 (2011)
Stueckelberg, E.C.G.: La signification du temps propre en mécanique ondulatoire. Helv. Phys. Acta 14, 322 (1941)
Stueckelberg, E.C.G.: La mécanique du point matériel en théorie des quanta. Helv. Phys. Acta 15, 23 (1942)
Fanchi, J.R.: Review of invariant time formulations of relativistic quantum theories. Found. Phys. 41, 4 (2011)
Aharonov, Y., Popescu, S., Tollaksen, J.: Each instant of time a new Universe. In: Quantum Theory: A Two-Time Success Story (Springer, 2014) pp. 21–36, arXiv:1305.1615 (2013)
Farhi, E., Gutmann, S.: The functional integral constructed directly from the Hamiltonian. Ann. Phys. 213, 182 (1992)
Cotler, J., Wilczek, F.: Entangled histories. Phys. Scripta T168, 014004 (2016)
Peres, A.: Quantum Theory: Concepts and Methods. Kluwer, Dordrecht (1993)
Pauli, W.: General Principles of Quantum Mechanics. Springer, Berlin (1980)
Braunstein, S.L., Caves, C.M., Milburn, G.J.: Generalized uncertainty relations: theory, examples, and lorentz invariance. Ann. Phys. 247, 135 (1996)
Giovannetti, V., Lloyd, S., Maccone, L.: Quantum limits to dynamical evolution. Phys. Rev. A 67, 052109 (2003)
Holevo, A.S.: Quantum Systems, Channels, Information (de Gruyter Studies in Mathematical Physics)
Holevo, A.S.: Estimation of shift parameters of a quantum state. Rep. Math. Phys. 13, 379 (1978)
Greenberger, D.M.: Conceptual Problems Related to Time and Mass in Quantum Theory, arXiv:1011.3709 (2010)
Salecker, H., Wigner, E.P.: Quantum limitations of the measurement of space–time distances. Phys. Rev. 109, 571 (1958)
Peres, A.: Measurement of time by quantum clocks. Am. J. Phys. 48, 552 (1980)
Page, D.N., Wootters, W.K.: Evolution without evolution: dynamics described by stationary observables. Phys. Rev. D 27, 2885 (1983)
Page, D.N.: Clock time and entropy. In: Physical Origins of Time Asymmetry, eds. J.J. Halliwell, et al., (Cambridge Univ. Press, 1993), arXiv:gr-qc/9303020
Wootters, W.K.: ‘Time’ replaced by quantum correlations. Int. J. Theor. Phys. 23, 701 (1984)
Aharonov, Y., Kaufherr, T.: Quantum frames of reference. Phys. Rev. D 30, 368 (1984)
Giovannetti, V., Lloyd, S., Maccone, L.: Quantum time. Phys. Rev. D 92, 045033 (2015)
McCord Morse, P., Feshbach, H.: Methods of Theoretical Physics, Part I. McGraw-Hill, New York (1953)
Zeh, H.D.: Emergence of classical time from a universal wavefunction. Phys. Lett. A 116, 9 (1986)
Zeh, H.D.: Time in quantum theory, http://www.rzuser.uni-heidelberg.de/~as3/TimeInQT.pdf
Vedral, V.: Time, (Inverse) Temperature and Cosmological Inflation as Entanglement, arXiv:1408.6965 (2014)
Banks, T.: TCP, quantum gravity, the cosmological constant and all that. Nucl. Phys. B 249, 332 (1985)
Brout, R.: On the concept of time and the origin of the cosmological temperature. Found. Phys. 17, 603 (1987)
Brout, R., Horwitz, G., Weil, D.: On the onset of time and temperature in cosmology. Phys. Lett. B 192, 318 (1987)
Brout, R.: Time and temperature in semi-classical gravity. Z. Phys. B 68, 339 (1987)
Rovelli, C.: Relational quantum mechanics. Int. J. Theor. Phys. 35, 1637 (1996)
Rovelli, C.: Time in quantum gravity: an hypothesis. Phys. Rev. D 43, 442 (1991)
Rovelli, C.: Quantum Gravity (2003), obtainable from http://www.cpt.univ-mrs.fr/~rovelli/book.pdf
Gambini, R., Porto, R.A., Pullin, J., Torterolo, S.: Conditional probabilities with Dirac observables and the problem of time in quantum gravity. Phys. Rev. D 79, 041501(R) (2009)
Gambini, R., Garcia-Pintos, L.P., Pullin, J.: An axiomatic formulation of the Montevideo interpretation of quantum mechanics. Stud. Hist. Philos. Mod. Phys. 42, 256 (2011)
Gambini, R., Pullin, J.: The Montevideo interpretation of quantum mechanics: frequently asked questions. J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 174, 012003 (2009)
Moreva, E., Brida, G., Gramegna, M., Giovannetti, V., Maccone, L., Genovese, M.: Time from quantum entanglement: an experimental illustration. Phys. Rev. A 89, 052122 (2014)
Hilgevoord, J.: Time in quantum mechanics: a story of confusion. Stud. Hist. Philos. Mod. Phys. 36, 29 (2005)
DeWitt, B.S.: Quantum theory of gravity. I. The canonical theory. Phys. Rev. 160, 1113 (1967)
Peres, A.: Quantum Theory: Concepts and Methods. Kluwer, Dordrecht (1993), Eq. (8.90)
Halvorson, H.: Does quantum theory kill time? http://www.princeton.edu/~hhalvors/papers/ (2010)
Hegerteldt, G.C., Ruijsenaars, S.N.M.: Remarks on causality, localization, and spreading of wave packets. Phys. Rev D 22, 377 (1980)
Busch, P., Grabowski, M., Lahti, P.J.: Time observables in quantum theory. Phys. Lett. A 191, 357 (1994)
Srinivas, M.D., Vijayalakshmi, R.: The ‘time of occurrence’ in quantum mechanics. Pramana 16, 173 (1981)
Dirac, P.A.M.: Relativity quantum mechanics with an application to Compton scattering. Proc. R. Soc. (London) A, 111, 405 (1926)
Hislop, P.D., Sigal, I.M.: Introduction to Spectral Theory. Applied Mathematical Sciences. Springer, Nwe York (1996)
Ballentine, L.E.: Quantum Mechanics, A Modern Development. World Scientific, Singapore (2014)
Borel, E.: Le Hasard. Alcan, Paris (1914)
Mandelstam, L., Tamm, I.G.: The uncertainty relation between energy and time in non-relativistic quantum mechanics. J. Phys. USSR 9, 249 (1945)
Bhattacharyya, K.: Quantum decay and the Mandelstam–Tamm-energy inequality. J. Phys. A 16, 2993 (1983)
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge the FQXi foundation for financial support in the “Physics of what happens” program. JL acknowledges support from MINECO/FEDER Project FIS2015-70856-P and CAM PRICYT Project QUITEMAD+ S2013/ICE-2801 and Giacomo Mauro D’Ariano for the kind hospitality at Pavia University. LM acknowledges very useful feedback from Vittorio Giovannetti and Seth Lloyd.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Leon, J., Maccone, L. The Pauli Objection. Found Phys 47, 1597–1608 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-017-0115-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-017-0115-2