Abstract
In this paper, a criticism of the traditional theories of approximation and idealization is given as a summary of previous works. After identifying the real purpose and measure of idealization in the practice of science, it is argued that the best way to characterize idealization is not to formulate a logical model – something analogous to Hempel's D-N model for explanation – but to study its different guises in the praxis of science. A case study of it is then made in thermostatistical physics. After a brief sketch of the theories for phase transitions and critical phenomena, I examine the various idealizations that go into the making of models at three difference levels. The intended result is to induce a deeper appreciation of the complexity and fruitfulness of idealization in the praxis of model-building, not to give an abstract theory of it.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Apostel, L.: 1961, 'Towards the Formal Study of Models in the non-Formal Sciences', in H. Freudenthal(ed.), The Concept and the Role of the Model inMathematics and Natural and Social Sciences, Synthese Library, D. Reidel, Dordrecht, pp. 1-37.
Armstrong, D. M.: 1978, Universals and Scientific Realism, Vol. 2: A Theory of Universals, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Armstrong, D. M.: 1983, What Is a Law of Nature? Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Baker, Jr. G. A.: 1961, 'One-dimensional Order-Disorder Model Which Approaches Phase Transition', Physical Reviews 122, 1477-1484.
Balzer, W., C. U. Moulines, and J. D. Sneed: 1987, An Archetectonic for Science: The Structuralist Approach, D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Barr, W. F.: 1971, 'A Syntactic and Semantic Analysis of Idealizations in Science', Philosophy of Science 38, 258-272.
Barr, W. F.: 1974, 'A Pragmatic Analysis of Idealizations in Physics', Philosophy of Science 41, 48-64.
Batterman, R.W.: 1998, 'Why Equilibrium Statistical Mechanics Works: Universality and the Renormalization Group', Philosophy of Science 65, 183-208.
Braithwaite, R. B.: 1962, 'Models in the Empirical Sciences', in E. Nagel, P. Suppes, and A. Tarski (eds.), Logic, Methodology and Philosophy of Science: Proceedings of the 1960 International Congress, Stanford University Press, Stanford, pp. 224-231.
Callender, C.: 2001, 'Taking Thermodynamics (Too) Seriously', forthcoming in Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics.
Carroll, J. W.: 1994, Laws of Nature, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Cartwright, N.: 1983, How the Laws of Physics Lie, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Cartwright, N.: 1989, Nature's Capacities and Their Measurement, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Cartwright, N.: 1997, 'Models: The Blueprints for Laws', Philosophy of Science 64, S292-S303.
Cartwright, N.: 1999, 'Models and the Limits of Theory: Quantum Hamiltonians and the BCS Models of Superconductivity', in Morgan and Morrison (1999), pp. 241-281.
Creary, L.: 1981, 'Causal Explanations and the Reality of Natural Component Forces', Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 62, 148-157.
Dretske, F.: 1977, 'Laws of Nature', Philosophy of Science 44, 248-268.
Emch, G. G.: 1971, Advanced Statistical Mechanics, Lecture Notes, preprint, Rochester, NY.
Emch, G. G. and C. Liu: 2002, The Logic of Thermostatistical Physics, Springer-Verlag, Berlin.
Fisher, M.: 1974, 'The Renormalization Group in the Theory of Critical Behavior', Review of Modern Physics 46, 597-616.
Fisher, M.: 1983, 'Scaling, Universality and Renormalization Group Theory', in F. J. W. Hahne (ed.), Critical Phenomena: Proceedings of the Summer School, the University of Stellenbosch, South Africa, January 18-29, 1982, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp. 1-139.
Fisher, M.: 1998, 'Renormalization Group Theory: Its Basis and Formulation in Statistical Physics', Review of Modern Physics 70, 653-681.
Giere, R.: 1988, Explaining Science: A Cognitive Approach, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Goldenfeld, N.: 1992, Lectures on Phase Transitions and the Renormalization Group, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA.
Griffiths, R. B.: 1972, 'Rigorous Results and Theorems', in C. Domb and M. E. Green (eds.), Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena, New York, Academic Press, pp. 8-109.
Herfel, W., W. Krajewski, I. Niiniluoto, and R.Wójcicki (eds.): 1995, Theories and Models in Scientific Processes (Poznan Studies, Vol. 44), Rodopi, Amsterdam.
Hesse, M.: 1970, Models and Analogies in Science, University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame.
Hilpinen, R.: 1976, 'Approximate Truth and Truthlikeness', in M. Przlecki, K. Szanianwski and R. Wójicki (eds.), Formal Methods in the Methodology of Empirical Sciences, D. Reidel, Dordrecht, pp. 19-42.
Horgan, J.: 1994, 'Icon and Bild: A Note on the Analogical Structure of Models-The Role of Models in Experiment and Theory', The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 45, 599-604.
Kac, M.: 1959, 'On the Partition Function of a One-Dimensional Gas', Physics of Fluids 2, 8-12.
Kadanoff, L. P.: 1966, 'Scaling Laws for Ising Models near Tc', Physics 2, 263-272.
Kline, A. and C. Matheson: 1986, 'How the Laws of Physics Don't Even Fib?', in P. D. Asquith et al. (eds.), PSA 1986, East Lansing, Philosophy of Science Association 1, 336-350.
Krajewski, W.: 1977, Correspondence Principle and the Growth of Knowledge, D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Kuipers, T. A. F.: 2000, From Instrumentalism to Constructive Realism, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht.
Kyburg Jr., H. E.: 1990, Science and Reason, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Laymon, R.: 1980, 'Idealization, Explanation, and Confirmation', in P. D. Asquith and R. N. Giere (eds.), PSA 1980, East Lansing, Philosophy of Science Association 1, 336-350.
Laymon, R.: 1985, 'Idealizations and the Testing of Theories by Experimentation', in P. Achinstein and O. Hannaway (eds.), Observation, Experiment and Hypothesis in Modern Physical Science, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 147-173.
Laymon, R.: 1989, 'Cartwright and the Lying Law of Physics', Journal of Philosophy 86, 353-372.
Lewis, D.: 1973, Counterfactuals, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Lewis, D.: 1983, 'New Works for a Theory of Universals', Australasian Journal of Philosophy 61, 343-371.
Lewis, D.: 1989, On the Plurality of Worlds, Blackwell, Oxford.
Liu, C.: 1997, 'Theories and Models I: the Semantic View Revisited', International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 11, 147-164.
Liu, C.: 1999a, 'Approximation, Idealization, and the Laws of Nature', Synthese 118, 229-256.
Liu, C.: 1999b, 'Explaining the Emergence of Cooperative Phenomena', Philosophy of Science 66(S), S92-S106.
Liu, C.: 2001, 'Infinite Systems in SM Explanations: Thermodynamic Limit, Renormalization (semi-) Groups, and Irreversibility', Philosophy of Science 68(S), S352-S344.
Liu, C.: 2004, 'Laws and Models in a Theory of Idealization', Synthese (forthcoming).
McMullin, E.: 1968, 'What Do Physical Models Tell Us?', in B. van Rootselaar and J. F. Staal (eds.), Logic, Methodology and Philosophy of Science III, North Holland, Amsterdam, p. 392.
McMullin, E.: 1985, 'Galilean Idealization', Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science 16, 247-273.
Marquis, J.-P.: 1991, 'Approximations and Truth Space', Journal of Philosophical Logic 20, 375-401.
Maxwell, J. C.: 1875, 'On the Dynamical Evidence of the Molecular Constitution of Bodies', Nature 11, 357, 374; or The Scientific Papers of James Clark Maxwell, Vol. 2, Dover (1965), p. 418.
Mill, J. S.: 1874, A System of Logic, 8th edn., Harper and Brothers, New York.
Morgan, M. S. and M. Morrison (eds.): 1999, Models as Mediators: Perspectives on Natural and Social Science, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Morrison, M.: 1997, 'Physical Models and Biological Contexts', Philosophy of Science 64, S315-S324.
Morrison, M.: 1999, 'Models as Autonomous Agents', in Morgan and Morrison (1999), pp. 38-65.
Niiniluoto, I.: 1984, Is Science Progressive, D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Niiniluoto, I.: 1986, 'Theories, Approximations and Idealizations', in R. B. Marcus et al. (eds.), Logic, Methodology and Philosophy of Science, North Holland, Amsterdam, pp. 255-289.
Niiniluoto, I.: 1987, Truthlikeness, D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Niiniluoto, I.: 1998, 'Verisimilitude: The Third Period', The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 49, 1-29.
Nowak, L.: 1972, 'Laws of Science, Theories, Measurement', Philosophy of Science 39, 533-548.
Onsager, L.: 1944, 'Crystal Statistics. I. A Two-Dimensional Model with an Order-Disorder Transition', Physical Review 65, 117-149.
Ramsey, J. L.: 1992, 'Towards an Expanded Epistemology for Approximations', in D. Hull, M. Forbes, and K. Okruhlik (eds.), PSA 1992, Vol. 1, Philosophy of Science Association, East Lansing, Michigan, pp. 154-164.
Redhead, M.: 1980, 'Models in Physics', The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 31, 145-163.
Rosenkrantz, R.: 1980, 'Measuring Truthlikeness', Synthese 45, 463-488.
Schultz, T. D., D. C. Mattis, and E. H. Lieb: 1964, 'Two-Dimensional Ising Model as a Soluble Problem of Many Fermions', Review of Modern Physics 36, 856-871.
Schwartz, R. J.: 1978, 'Idealization and Approximations in Physics', Philosophy of Science 45, 595-603.
Sklar, L.: 1993, Physics and Chance, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Sneed, D. L.: 1971, The Logical Structure of Mathematical Physics, D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Stanley, H. E.: 1971, Introduction to Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Stegmüller, W.: 1976, The Structure and Dynamics of Theories, Springer Verlag, New York.
Suàrez, M.: 1999, 'The Role of Models in the Application of Scientific Theories: Epistemological Implications', in Morgan and Morrison (1999), pp. 168-196.
Suppe, F.: 1989, The Semantic Conception of Theories and Scientific Realism, University of Illinois Press, Urbana, IL.
Toda, M., R. Kubo and N. Saitô: 1983, Statistical Physics I: Equilibrium Statistical Mechanics, Springer-Verlag, Berlin.
van Fraassen, B.: 1989, Laws and Symmetry. Oxford, Clarendon Press.
Weston, T.: 1987, 'Approximate Truth', Journal of Philosophical Logic 16, 203-227.
Weston, T.: 1992, 'Approximate Truth and Scientific Realism', Philosophy of Science 59, 53-74.
Wilson, Kenneth G. and J. Kogut: 1974, 'The Renormalization Group and the ? Expansion', Physics Report 12C, 75-197.
Wimsatt, W. C.: 1987, 'False Models as Means to Truer Theories”, in M. Nitecki and A. Hoffman (eds.), Neutral Models in Biology, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 23-55.
Wimsatt, W. C.: 1994, 'The Ontology of Complex Systems: Levels, Perspectives, and Causal Thickets”, in M. Matthen and R. X.Ware (eds.), Biology and Society: Reflections on Methodology, Canadian Journal of Philosophy, Supplementary Vol. 20, pp. 207-274.
Yang, C. N. and T. D. Lee: 1952, 'Statistical Theory of Equations of State and Phase Transitions I. Theory of Condensation', Physical Review 87, 404-409.
Yang, C. N.: 1952, 'The Spontaneous Magnetization of a Two-Dimensional Ising Model', Physical Review 85, 808.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Liu, C. Approximations, Idealizations, and Models in Statistical Mechanics. Erkenntnis 60, 235–263 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:ERKE.0000012883.07507.32
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/B:ERKE.0000012883.07507.32