Abstract
What I call theoretical abduction (sentential and model-based)certainly illustrates much of what is important in abductive reasoning, especially the objective of selecting and creating a set of hypotheses that are able to dispense good (preferred) explanations of data, but fails to account for many cases of explanation occurring in science or in everyday reasoning when the exploitation of the environment is crucial. The concept of manipulative abduction is devoted to capture the role of action in many interesting situations: action provides otherwise unavailable information that enables the agent to solve problems by starting and performing a suitable abductive process of generation or selection of hypotheses. Many external things, usually inert from the epistemological point of view, can be transformed into what I callepistemic mediators, which are illustrated in the last part of the paper, together with an analysis of the related notions of ``perceptual and inceptual rehearsal'' and of ``external representation''.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Boutilier, C. and V. Becher: 1995, Abduction as Belief Revision, Artificial Intelligence 77: 43–94.
Cornuéjols, A., A. Tiberghien and G. Collet: 2000, A New Mechanism for Transfer Between Conceptual Domains in Scientific Discovery and Education. Foundations of Science 5(2): 129–155. Special Issue on Model-Based Reasoning in Scientific Discovery: Learning and Discovery, L. Magnani, N.J. Nersessian, and P. Thagard, eds.
Galilei, G.: 1632, Dialogues Concerning the Two Chief World Systems, S. Drake (trans.), M.R. Matthews (ed.) (1989), 61–81.
Gooding, D.: 1990, Experiment and the Making of Meaning. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Gooding, D. and T.R. Addis: 1999, A Simulation of Model-Based Reasoning about Disparate Phenomena. In L. Magnani, N.J. Nersessian and P. Thagard (eds.), Model-Based Reasoning in Scientific Discovery. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 103–123.
Hempel, C.G.: 1966, Philosophy of Natural Science. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Holyoak, K.J. and P. Thagard: 1995,Mental Leaps. Analogy in Creative Thought. Cambridge,MA: MIT Press.
Hutchins, E.: 1995, Cognition in the Wild. Cambridge,MA: MIT Press. Ippolito,M.F. and R.D. Tweney: 1995, The Inception of Insight. In The Nature of Insight. Cambridge,MA: MIT Press, 433–462.
Johnson-Laird, P.N.: 1983, Mental Models: Towards a Cognitive Science of Language, Inference, and Consciousness. Cambridge,MA: Harvard University Press.
Kant, I.: 1929, Critique of Pure Reason, N. Kemp Smith (trans.).London: MacMillan, reprint 1998; originally published 1787.
Kirlik, A.: 1998, The Ecological Expert: Acting to Create Information to Guide Action. In Proceedings of the 1998 Conference on Human Interaction with Complex Systems(HICS'98). Piscataway, NJ: IEEE Press.
Magnani, L.: 1992, Abductive Reasoning: Philosophical and Educational Perspectives in Medicine. In D.A. Evans and V.L. Patel (eds.), AdvancedModels of Cognition for Medical Training and Practice. Berlin: Springer, 21–41.
Magnani, L.: 1999a, Model-Based Creative Abduction. In L. Magnani, N.J. Nersessian and P. Thagard (eds.), Model-Based Reasoning in Scientific Discovery. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 219–238.
Magnani, L.: 1999b, Inconsistencies and Creative Abduction in Science. In AI and Scientific Creativity. Proceedings of the AISB99 Symposium on Scientific Creativity. Society for the Study of Artificial Intelligence and Simulation of Behaviour, Edinburgh College of Art and Division of Informatics, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, 1–8.
Magnani, L.: 2001a, Abduction, Reason, and Science. Processes of Discovery and Explanation. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.
Magnani, L.: 2001b, Philosophy and Geometry. Theoretical and Historical Issues. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Magnani, L.: 2002, EpistemicMediators and Model-Based Discovery in Science. In L. Magnani and N.J. Nersessian (eds.), 305–329.
Magnani, L., S. Civita and G. Previde Massara: 1994, Visual Cognition and Cognitive Modeling. In V. Cantoni (ed.), Human and Machine Vision: Analogies and Divergences. New York: Plenum, 229–243.
Magnani, L. and R. Dossena: 2002, Perceiving the Infinite and the Infinitesimal World: Unveiling and Optical Diagrams and the Construction of Mathematical Concepts, Foundations of Science, forthcoming.
Magnani, L. and N.J. Nersessian (eds.): 2002, Model-Based Reasoning. Science. Technology, Values. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.
Magnani, L., N.J. Nersessian and P. Pizzi (eds.): 2002, Logical and Computational Aspects of Model-Based Reasoning. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic.
Matthews, M.R. (ed.): 1989, The Scientific Background to Modern Philosophy. Indianapolis/Cambridge: Hackett.
Mill, J.S.: 1843, A System of Logic. Reprinted in The Collected Works of John Stuart Mill, J.M. Robson (ed.). London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Miller, A.I.: 1992, Scientific Creativity: A Comparative Study of Henri Poincaré and Albert Einstein, Creativity Research Journal9: 113–130.
Morgan, M.S. and M. Morrison (eds.): 1999, Models as Mediators. Perspectives on Natural and Social Science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Nersessian, N.J.: 1998, Kuhn and the Cognitive Revolution, Configurations 6: 87–120.
Nersessian, N.J.: 1999, Model-Based Reasoning in Conceptual Change. In L. Magnani, N. J. Nersessian and P. Thagard (eds.), Model-Based Reasoning in Scientific Discovery, New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 5–22.
Newell, A.: 1990, Unified Theories of Cognition. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Norman, D.A.: 1993, Things that Make Us Smart. Defending Human Attributes in the Age of the Machine. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Peirce, C.S.: 1955a, Abduction and Induction, in: C.S. Peirce. Philosophical Writings of Peirce, J. Buchler (ed.). New York: Dover, 150–156.
Peirce, C.S.: 1955b, Perceptual Judgments, in: C.S. Peirce. Philosophical Writings of Peirce, J. Buchler (ed.). New York: Dover, 302–305.
Peirce, C.S.: 1931-1958 (CP), Collected Papers, 8 vols., C. Hartshorne and P Weiss (vols. I-VI), and A.W. Burks (vols. VII-VIII) (eds.). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Piaget, J.: 1974, Adaptation and Intelligence. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Popper, K.R.: 1959, The Logic of Scientific Discovery. London/New York: Hutchinson.
Ramoni, M., M. Stefanelli, L. Magnani and G. Barosi: 1992, An Epistemological Framework for Medical Knowledge-Based Systems, IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics 22(6): 1361–1375.
Shelley, C.: 1996, Visual Abductive Reasoning in Archaeology, Philosophy of Science 63(2): 278–301.
Thagard, P.: 1988, Computational Philosophy of Science. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Thagard, P. 1992, Conceptual Revolutions. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Tweney, R.D.: 1996, Presymbolic Processes in Scientific Creativity, Creativity Research Journal 9(2-3): 163–172.
Tweney, R.D.: forthcoming,What Happened to the Brass and Glass? The Rise of Statistical “Instruments” in Psychology, 1900-1950, Archives for the History of American Psychology.
Zhang, J.: 1997, The Nature of External Representations in Problem Solving, Cognitive Science 21(2): 179–217.
Zhang, J. and D.A. Norman: 1994, Representations in Distributed Cognitive Tasks, Cognitive Science 18: 87–122.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Magnani, L. Model-Based and Manipulative Abduction in Science. Foundations of Science 9, 219–247 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:FODA.0000042841.18507.22
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/B:FODA.0000042841.18507.22