Abstract
Emphasis on “cutting edge” science is common today. This paper shows that the concept, which selects some science at any given time as epistemically preferable and therefore “better,” actually gained acceptance by the turn of this century in biology and began immediately to have consequences for what biological research was done. The result, that some research is cut out while other work is privileged, can have pernicious results. Some of what is designated as not cutting edge may, in a different — and equally defensible epistemological framework, prove just as “good” as the officially cutting edge research. Cutting edges cut both ways, and those who study science should begin exploring the implications of that fact.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bernard, C.: 1949,An Introduction to the Study of Experimental Medicine, translated by C. Greene, Henry Schuman, New York. Original 1865,Introduction à l'étude de la médecine expérimentale, Paris.
Brush, S.G.: 1978, ‘Nettie M. Stevens and The Discovery of Sex Determination by Chromosomes’,Isis 69, 163–172.
Caron, J.A.: 1988, ‘“Biology” in the Life Sciences: A Historiographical Contribution’,History of Science 26, 223–268.
Coleman, W.: 1977,Biology in the Nineteenth Century, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Cranefield, P.E.: 1957, ‘The Organic Physics of 1847 and the Biophysics of Today’,Journal of the History of Medicine 12, 407–423.
Gilbert, S.F., editor: 1991,A Conceptual History of Modern Embryology, Plenum Press, New York.
Harrison, R.G.: 1907, ‘Observations on the Living Developing Nerve Fiber’,Anatomical Record 4, 140–143.
Harrison, R.G.: 1910, ‘The Outgrowth of the Nerve Fibers as a Mode of Protoplasmic Movement’,Journal of Experimental Zoology 9, 787–846.
Harwood, J.: 1993,Styles of Scientific Thought: The German Genetics Community, 1900–1933, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Holmes, F.L.: 1974,Claude Bernard and Animal Chemistry, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
Huxley, T.H.: 1893, ‘Address on University Education’ and ‘On the Study of Biology’ inScience and Education, Macmillan, London, 235–261 and 262–293 (originally presented 1876).
Kohler, R.E.: 1991,Partners in Science. Foundations and Natural Scientists 1900–1945, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Lacaze-Duthiers, H.D.: 1872, ‘Direction des Études Zoologiques’,Archives de Zoologie Expérimentale et Générale 1, 1–64. Translated by W. Coleman as ‘The Study of Zoology’ inThe Interpretation of Naimal Form, 1967, Johnson Reprint Corporation, New York, 135–163.
Lesch, J.E.: 1984,Science and Medicine in France. The Emergence of Experimental Physiology, 1790–1855, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
Maienschein, J.: 1991, ‘Epistemic Styles in German and American Embryology’,Science in Context (1991)4: 407–427.
Maienschein, J.: 1991b,Transforming Traditions in American Biology, 1880–1915, Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.
Maienschein, J., editor: 1986,Defining Biology — Lectures from the 1890s, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
Maienschein, J.: 1991c, ‘Cytology in 1924: Expansion & Collaboration’ in K.R. Benson, et al., editors:The Expansion of American Biology, Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, 23–51.
Maienschein, J.: 1983, ‘Experimental Biology in Transition’,Studies in History of Biology 6: 107–127.
Morgan, T.H.: 1897,The Development of the Frog's Egg: An Introduction to Experimental Embryology, Macmillan, New York.
Morgan, T.H.: 1901,Regeneration, Macmillan, New York.
Morgan, T.H.: 1913,Heredity and Sex, Columbia University Press, New York.
Morgan, T.H.: 1910, ‘Sex-limited Inheritance in Drosophila’,Science 32: 120–122.
Nyhart, L.K.: 1986, ‘Morphology and the German University, 1860–1900’, Ph.D. dissertation, University of Pennsylvania.
Nyhart, L.K.: 1987, ‘The Disciplinary Breakdown of German Morphology’,Isis 78: 365–389.
Pauly, P.J.: 1988, ‘Summer Resort and Scientific Discipline: Woods Hole and the Structure of American Biology, 1882–1925’ in Ronald Rainger, et al., editors,The American Development of Biology, University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadalphia, 121–150.
Rainger, R., et al., editors: 1988,The American Development of Biology, University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia.
Roux, W.: 1985, ‘The Problems, Methods, and Scope of Developmental Mechanics’, translated by W.M. Wheeler,Biological Lectures Delivered at the Marine Biological Laboratory, Woods Hole 1984, 107–148. Also reprinted in Maienschein, 1986, 107–148.
Sapp, J.: 1987,Beyond the Gene. Cytoplasmic Inheritance and the Struggle for Authority in Genetics, Oxford University Press, New York.
Wilson, E.B.: 1966,The Cell in Development and Inheritance, Johnson Reprint Corporation, New York. Original 1896.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Maienschein, J. Cutting edges cut both ways. Biol Philos 9, 1–24 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00849911
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00849911