Abstract
A critical survey of recent work on the ontological status of colors supports the conclusion that, while some accounts of color can plausibly be dismissed, no single account can yet be endorsed. Among the remaining options are certain forms of color realism according which familiar colors are instantiated by objects in our extra-cranial visual environment. Also still an option is color anti-realism, the view that familiar colors are, at best, biologically adaptive fictions, instantiated nowhere.
I argue that there is simply no fact of the matter as to which of these remaining options is correct. I blame this indeterminacy on the fact that color vision exhibits several of the hallmarks of a modular input system, as described by Jerry Fodor in The Modularity of Mind.
Finally, I speculate that the range of live options falling within the scope of the indeterminacy may be even broader than initially indicated.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Averill, E. W.: 1985, ‘Color and the Anthropocentric Problem’, Journal of Philosophy 82, 281–303.
Block, N.: 1986, ‘Advertisement for a Semantics for Psychology’, P. A. French, T. E. Uehling, and H. K. Wettstein (eds.), Midwest Studies in Philosophy, Volume X: Studies in the Philosophy of Mind, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.
Boghossian, P. A., and J. D. Velleman: 1989, ‘Colour as a Secondary Property’, Mind 98, 81–103.
Boghossian, P. A. and J. D. Velleman: 1991, ‘Physicalist Theories of Color’, The Philosophical Review 100, 67–106.
Boynton, R. M.: 1975, ‘Color, Hue and Wavelength’, in E. C. Carterette and M. P. Friedman (eds.), Handbook of Perception, Volume V, Academic Press, New York.
Burge, T.: 1977, ‘Belief De Re’, Journal of Philosophy 7, 338–62.
Burge, T.: 1986, ‘Intellectual Norms and Foundations of Mind’, Journal of Philosophy 83, 697–720.
Davidoff, J.: 1991, Cognition Through Color, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Delk, J. L. and S. Fillenbaum: 1965, ‘Differences in Perceived Color as a Function of Change of Characteristic Color’, American Journal of Psychology 78, 290–5.
Dennett, D. C.: 1987, The Intentional Stance, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Descartes, R.: 1931, The Collected Works of Descartes, Volume 1, translated by E. S. Haldane and G. R. T. Ross, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Descartes, R.: 1664/1972, Treatise of Man, with translation and commentary by T. S. Hall, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Donnellan, K.: 1966, ‘Reference and Definite Descriptions’, The Philosophical Review 75, 281–304.
Fodor, J.: 1983, The Modularity of Mind, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Fodor, J.: 1987, Psychosemantics, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Fodor, J.: 1990, ‘A Theory of Content, I: The Problem’, in A Theory of Content and Other Essays, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Gibson, J.: 1979, The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception, Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston.
Gouras, P.: 1981, ‘Color Vision’, in E. R. Kandel and J. H. Schwartz (eds.), Principles of Neural Science, Elsevier/North Holland, New York.
Haber, R. N. and M. Hershenson: 1980, The Psychology of Visual Perception (2nd ed.). Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York.
Hardin, C. L.: 1988, Color for Philosophers: Unweaving the Rainbow, Hackett, Indianapolis.
Hardin, C. L.: 1990, ‘Color and Illusion’, in W. G. Lycan (ed.), Mind and Cognition: A Reader, Basil Blackwell, Cambridge, MA.
Hardin, C. L. (1992). ‘The Virtues of Illusion’, Philosophical Studies 68, 371–82.
Hilbert, D. R.: 1987, Color and Color Perception: A Study in Anthropocentric Realism, Center for the Study of Language and Information, Stanford.
Hilbert, D. R.: 1992, ‘What Is Color Vision?’, Philosophical Studies 68, 351–70.
Hurvich, L. M.: 1981, Color Vision, Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, MA.
Jacobs, G. H.: 1981, Comparative Color Vision, Academic Press, New York.
Jansson, G.: 1978, ‘Human Locomotion Guided by a Matrix of Tactile Point Stimuli’, in G. Gordon (ed.), Active Touch, Pergamon Press, Elmsford, NY.
Kay, P. and C. McDaniel: 1978, ‘The Linguistic Significance of the Meaning of Basic Colour Terms’, Language 54, 610–46.
Kripke, S.: 1972, ‘Naming and Necessity’, in D. Davidson and G. Harman (eds.), Semantics of Natural Language, D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Lakatos, I.: 1970, ‘Falsification and the Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes’, in I. Lakatos and A. Musgrave (eds.), Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Land, E. H.: 1977, ‘The Retinex Theory of Color Vision’, Scientific American 237, 108–28.
Land, E. H.: 1983, ‘Recent Advances in Retinex Theory and Some Implications for Cortical Computations: Color Vision and the Natural Image’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 80, 5263–9.
Land, E. H.: 1986, ‘Recent Advances in Retinex Theory’, Vision Research 26, 7–21.
Landesman, C.: 1989, Color and Consciousness, Temple University Press, Philadelphia.
Lashley, K.: 1950, ‘In Search of the Engram’, Society of Experimental Biology Symposium No. 4: Physiological Mechanism of Animal Behavior, pp. 478–505. Reprinted in T. K. Landauer (ed.), Readings in Physiological Psychology, 1967, McGraw-Hill, New York. pp. 287–313.
Lennie, P.: 1984, ‘Recent Developments in the Physiology of Color Vision’, Trends in Neuro Sciences 7, 243–8.
Lewontin, R.: 1990, ‘The Evolution of Cognition’, in D. N. Osherson and E. E. Smith (eds.), Thinking, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
McCarthy, J.: 1979, ‘Ascribing Mental Qualities to Machines’, in M. Ringle (ed.), Philosophical Perspectives in Artificial Intelligence, Humanities Press, Atlantic Highlands, NJ.
McGilvray, J. A.: 1983, ‘To Color’, Synthese 54, 37–70.
Maloney, L. T. and B. A. Wandell: 1986, ‘Color Constancy: A Method for Recovering Surface Spectral Reflectance’, Journal of the Optical Society of America A 3, 29–33.
Matthen, M.: 1988: ‘Biological Functions and Perceptual Content’, Journal of Philosophy 85, 5–27.
Miller, R.: 1987, Fact and Method, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
Millikan, R. G.: 1984, Language, Thought and Other Biological Categories, The MIT Press, Cambridge.
Montgomery, R.: 1989, ‘Discrimination, Reidentification and the Indeterminacy of Early Vision, Nous 23, 413–35.
Montgomery, R.: 1990, ‘Visual Perception and the Wages of Indeterminacy’, in A. Fine, M. Forbes and L. Wessels (eds.), PSA 1990, Vol. 1 (Proceedings of the Philosophy of Science Association).
Nassau, K.: 1980, ‘The Causes of Color’, Scientific American 243, 124–54.
Putnam, H.: 1975, ‘The Meaning of “Meaning”’, in K. Gunderson (ed.), Language, Mind and Knowledge, University of Press, Minneapolis.
Putnam, H.: 1981, Reason, Truth and History, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Pylyshyn, Z.: 1984, Computation and Cognition, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Smith, A. D.: 1990, ‘Of Primary and Secondary Qualities’, The Philosophical Review 99, 221–54.
Shapere, D.: 1977, ‘Scientific Theories and Their Domains’, in F. Suppe (ed.), The Structure of Scientific Theories (2nd ed.), University of Illinois Press. Excerpted in J. A. Kourany (ed.), Scientific Knowledge, 1987, Wadsworth, Belmont, CA, pp. 77–94.
Thompson, E.: 1995, Colour Vision: A Study in Cognitive Science and the Philosophy of Perception, Routledge, London.
Thompson, E., A. Palacios, and F. J. Varela: 1992, ‘Ways of Coloring: Comparative Color Vision as a Case Study for Cognitive Science’, Behavioral and Brain Sciences 15, 1–74.
van Fraassen, B.: 1980, The Scientific Image, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Wasserman, G. S.: 1978, Color Vision: An Historical Introduction, Wiley and Sons, New York.
Westphal, J.: 1987, Colour: Some Philosophical Problems from Wittgenstein, Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
Wittgenstein, L.: 1958, Philosophical Investigations, translated by G. E. M. Anscombe, Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
Wittgenstein, L.: 1977, Remarks on Colour, University of California Press, Berkeley.
Young, T.: 1802/1965, ‘On the Theory of Light and Colours’, excerpted in R. J. Hernstein and E. G. Boring (eds.), A Source Book in the History of Psychology, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Montgomery, R. The indeterminacy of color vision. Synthese 106, 167–203 (1996). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00413699
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00413699