Abstract
The following pages sketch the outlines of “a Canaanite reading” of the health system. Beginning with the Black person—African, Afro-diasporic, Aboriginal, and Torres Strait Islander—who is seen by a health professional, the functions and effects of the racializing gaze are examined. I wrestle with Al Saji’s understanding of “colonial disregard,” Whittaker’s insights into the extractive disposition of settler institutions vis-à-vis Indigenous peoples, and Saidiya Hartman and Fred Moten’s struggle with the spectacular. This leads me to conclude that the situation of the Black within the health system is a tragic one. The prescription for the path out of this tragedy that I settle on, responding to Okiji’s opening call, is found in Vernon Ah Kee’s “Unwritten” series.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
“The Chinese martial arts Wushu is helpful here: when one holds a stance, such as the horse stance, this is an active endeavour (that the leg muscles begin to shake in resistance after a few short moments is testament to this) … But while a horse stance can be held for the sake of training, it is also more: in the context of a form or routine, the stance serves as a foundation for transition, preparing and positioning the body for the next movement or strike. It is significant that in Chinese the word for stance, 步, can also be translated into English as ‘step.’ Holding is not only active, it also enables and prepares us for action and movement” (Ngo 2017, 40, emphasis in original).
In his conversation with Wole Soyinka, Anthony Appiah delivers the following caution: “I think the concept of tragedy tends to get used in our culture very much and in a debased form and with very little sense of classical tragedy.” In response, Soyinka suggests that Appiah is only correct “if one begins by accepting the European definition of tragedy” (Appiah 1988, 782). For Soyinka, the tragic has little to do with genre or technical niceties but has to do with existence, particularly its dangers and insecurity. My use of tragedy here is in reference to that situation whereby the Black has always already fallen from “grace to grass,” as Soyinka puts it. It is an evaluation of that situation described by Fanon (2008) whereby, given the prevailing racist, colonial order, the Black, among others, arrives “too late” onto the plane of meaning making where the frameworks on which society is to function are articulated (see also Al-Saji 2013).
“I have chosen not to reproduce Douglass’s account of the beating of Aunt Hester in order to call attention to the ease with which such scenes are usually reiterated, the casualness with which they are circulated, and the consequences of this routine display of the slave’s ravaged body. Rather than inciting indignation, too often they immure us to pain by virtue of their familiarity … and especially because they reinforce the spectacular character of black suffering. What interests me are the ways we are called upon to participate in such scenes. Are we witnesses who confirm the truth of what happened …? Or are we voyeurs fascinated with and repelled by exhibitions of terror and sufferance? What does the exposure of the violated body yield? … does the pain of the other merely provide us with the opportunity for self-reflection?” (Hartman 1997, 3–4, emphasis mine).
With respect to the former, Frantz Fanon notes: “The upheaval reached the black man from the outside. The black man was acted upon [Le Noir a été agi]. Values that were not engendered by his actions, values not resulting from the systolic gush of his blood, whirled around him in a colorful dance” (Fanon 2008, 194).
Regarding the later, Steve Biko writes: “Since that unfortunate date—1652—we have been experiencing the process of acculturation. It is perhaps presumptuous to call it’“acculturation’ because this term implies a fusion of different cultures. In our case the fusion has been extremely one-sided … the Anglo-Boer culture had all the trappings of a colonist culture and therefore was heavily equipped for conquest … This is where the African began to lose a grip on himself and his surroundings” (Biko 1987, 40–41, emphasis mine).
As Henry Kyburg (1974) helpfully points out in the preface to his The Logical Foundations of Statistical Inference, “Everyone knows that it is easy to lie with statistics. It is important then to be able to tell a statistical lie from a valid statistical inference” (vii). These are in fact the very opening lines of the book. Let us assume that the finding that ACEM was guilty of racial discrimination was overturned on the basis of valid statistical inference. Kyburg also states the following:
If we turn to philosophers, or to mathematical statisticians, or to probability theorists for criteria of validity in statistical inference, for the general principles that distinguish well grounded from ill grounded generalizations and laws, or for the interpretation of that probability we must, like a gambler, take as our guide in life, we find disagreement, confusion, and frustration. (vii)
My point is simply that a favourable statistical finding is a measure of how likely a particular set of mathematic operations determine one thing to be related to another. There is therefore an unbridgeable gulf that lies between that favorable outcome and the absence of racial discrimination.
This assumption is a plea for the suspension of disbelief. It asks that one put aside Chelsea Bond’s testimony: “For a long time, I had been trying to find the way to get beyond the veil—to outperform and outsmart racism. But I have resigned myself to the fact that the academy … is theirs, not ours” (Mukandi and Bond 2019, 261). It also demands that one look past Bond and David Singh’s observation: “Closing the Gap tends to focus our attention disproportionately on the behaviour of individuals, suggesting that health inequalities are a product of Indigenous lack, morally and intellectually, rather than socially determined” (Bond and Singh 2020, 1). Belief in the ability to train individuals to overturn a system similarly evades the structural while overdetermining the possibilities inherent with the individual.
References
Ah Kee, V. 2011a. lynching (unbecoming). Etching on paper, image 16 x 14 cm, sheet 40 x 30.5 cm. Museum of Contemporary Art Australia, Sydney.
______. 2011b. unwritten (becoming). Etching on paper, image 20 x 15.5 cm, sheet 40 x 30cm. Museum of Contemporary Art Australia, Sydney.
______. 2011c. unwritten (unbecoming). Etching on paper, image 51 x 33.5 cm, sheet 70.5 x 50cm. Museum of Contemporary Art Australia, Sydney.
Al-Saji, A. 2013. Too late: Racialized time and the closure of the past. Insights 6(5): 2–13.
______. 2018. SPEP Co-director's address: Hesitation as philosophical method—travel bans, colonial durations, and the affective weight of the past. The Journal of Speculative Philosophy 32(3): 331–359.
______. 2019. Glued to the image: A critical phenomenology of racialization through works of art. The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 77(4): 475–488.
Althusser, L. 2001. Lenin and philosophy and other essays. Translated by B. Brewster. New York: Monthly Review Press.
Andrews, D. 2018. RANZCO CEO responds. Insight, November 6. https://www.insightnews.com.au/Article3/1909/RANZCO-CEO-responds. Accessed October 31, 2018.
Appiah, A. 1988. An evening with Wole Soyinka. Black American Literature Forum 22(4): 777–785.
Arendt, H. 1971. Thinking and moral considerations: A lecture. Social Research 38(3): 417–446.
Biko, S. 1987. I write what I like: A selection of his writings. Oxford: Heinemann.
Bond, C., and D. Singh. 2020. More than a refresh required for closing the gap of Indigenous health inequality. Medical Journal of Australia 212(5): 198–199.
Castro, J.J. 2017. The critical image: Ethics and the art of Vernon Ah Kee. PhD dissertation, University of Southern Queensland.
Dauber, M. 2018. Bioethics and the law: Should courts be allowed to make end of life decisions? Reflections on the Charlie Gard and Alfie Evans controversies. Ethics, Medicine and Public Health 6: 94–104.
Derrida, J. 1978. Writing and difference. Translated by Alan Bass. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
Even, Y. 1991. The Loggia dei Lanzi: A showcase of female subjugation. Woman's Art Journal 12(1): 10–14.
Ewen, S.C. 2011. Unequal treatment: The possibilities of and need for Indigenous parrhesiastes in Australian medical education. Journal of Immigrant and Minority Health 13(3): 609–615.
Fanon, F. 1967. Towards the African revolution: Political essays. Translated by Haakon Chevalier. New York: Grove Press.
______. 2008. Black skin, white masks. New York: Grove Press.
Hartman, S. 1997. Scenes of subjection: Terror, slavery, and self-making in nineteenth-century America. New York: Oxford University Press.
Jaima, A. 2019. On the discursive orientation toward whiteness. Journal of Intercultural Studies 40(2): 210–224.
Jay, M. 1993. Downcast eyes: The denigration of vision in twentieth-century French thought. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Knaus, C. 2017a. Australian emergency medicine college cleared of racial discrimination. The Guardian, October 11. https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2017/oct/11/australian-emergency-medicine-college-cleared-of-racial-discrimination. Accessed February 25, 2020.
______. 2017b. Racism claims in College for Emergency Medicine to be investigated over exam results. The Guardian, February 2. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/feb/02/racism-claims-in-college-for-emergency-medicine-to-be-investigated-over-exam-results. Accessed February 25, 2020.
Kyburg, H. 1974. The logical foundations of statistical inference. Dordrecht: Springer.
Macoun, A., K. Parker, and E. Strakosch. 2019. Australian political studies and the production of disciplinary innocence. Australian Journal of Political Science 54(3): 378–395.
Mills, C. 2005. “Ideal theory” as ideology. Hypatia 20(3): 165–184.
Moreton-Robinson, A. 2013. Towards an Australian Indigenous women’s standpoint theory. Australian Feminist Studies 28(78): 331–347.
______. 2015. The white possessive: Property, power, and Indigenous sovereignty. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Morrison, T. 1994. The bluest eye. London: Vintage.
Moten, F. 2003. In the break: The aesthetics of the Black radical tradition. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Mukandi, B. 2019. The North African syndrome: Traversing the distance to the cultural “other.” In The Bloomsbury companion to philosophy of psychiatry, edited by Ş. Tekin and R. Bluhm, 413–428. London: Bloomsbury Academic.
Mukandi, B., and C. Bond. 2019. “Good in the hood” or “burn it down”? Reconciling Black presence in the academy. Journal of Intercultural Studies 40(2): 254–268.
Ngo, H. 2017. The habits of racism: A phenomenology of racism and racialized embodiment. Lanham: Lexington Books.
Nietzsche, F. 1967. The birth of tragedy and other writings. Translated by R. Speirs. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
______. 2019. On truth and untruth: Selected writings. Translated and edited by T. Carman. New York: Harper Collins.
Okiji, F. 2018. Jazz as critique: Adorno and Black expression revisited. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Ochieng, O. 2018. Intellectual imagination: Knowledge and aesthetics in North Atlantic and African philosophy. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press
______. 2020. Meaning at the end of meaning: Nihilism, great nonsense, and praxis in the shadow of extinction. Philosophy & Rhetoric 53(3): 312–318.
Pascoe, V. 2019. Australia’s toxic medical culture: International medical graduates and structural power. Singapore: Springer.
Phillips, K. 2018. His brain-damaged toddler is about to die. But this father isn’t allowed to say goodbye. The Washington Post, February 23. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2018/02/23/his-brain-damaged-toddler-is-about-to-die-but-this-father-isnt-allowed-to-say-goodbye/. Accessed February 24, 2020.
QAGOMA. 2017. Vernon Ah Kee discusses “Unwritten” series. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZIyim0D4OXQ. Accessed February 26, 2020.
Rallah-Baker, K. 2018. Closing the gap from both sides. Insight, September 7. https://www.insightnews.com.au/Article3/1819/Closing-the-gap-from-both-sides Accessed September 7, 2018.
Ramose, Mogobe. 1999. African philosophy Through ubuntu. Harare: Mond Books
Said, E.W. 1986. Michael Walzer’s “Exodus and revolution”: A Canaanite reading. Grand Street 5(2): 86–106.
Singh, D. 2018. RANZCO urged to apologise to first Indigenous ophthalmologist—and more news from #MovingBeyondTheFrontline. Croakey, November 8, updated November 14. https://croakey.org/ranzco-urged-to-apologise-to-first-indigenous-ophthalmologist-and-more-news-from-movingbeyondthefrontline/. Accessed February 24, 2020.
Singh, D. 2020. Racial complaint and sovereign divergence: The case of Australia's first Indigenous ophthalmologist. The Australian Journal of Indigenous Education 49(2): 145–152.
Stanford, P.K. 2019. Unconceived alternatives and conservatism in science: The impact of professionalization, peer-review, and Big Science. Synthese 196(10):3915–3932.
Sweet, M. 2018. RANZCO apologises “unreservedly” to first Indigenous ophthalmologist. Croakey, November 21. https://croakey.org/ranzco-apologises-unreservedly-to-first-indigenous-ophthalmologist/. Accessed February 25, 2020.
Taylor, A., ed. 2009. Examined life: Excursions with contemporary thinkers. New York: The New Press.
Watson, I. 2015. Aboriginal peoples, colonialism and international law: Raw law. London: Routledge.
Whittaker, A. 2018. The unbearable witness, seeing: A case for Indigenous methodologies in Australian soft law. Pandora’s Box: 23–35.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mukandi, B. Being Seen by the Doctor: A Meditation on Power, Institutional Racism, and Medical Ethics. Bioethical Inquiry 18, 33–44 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-021-10087-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-021-10087-2