Abstract
Nihilism, Nietzsche and the Doppelganger Problem Was Nietzsche a nihilist? Yes, because, like J. L. Mackie, he was an error-theorist about morality, including the elitist morality to which he himself subscribed. But he was variously a diagnostician, an opponent and a survivor of certain other kinds of nihilism. Schacht argues that Nietzsche cannot have been an error theorist, since meta-ethical nihilism is inconsistent with the moral commitment that Nietzsche displayed. Schacht’s exegetical argument parallels the substantive argument (advocated in recent years by Wright and Blackburn) that Mackie’s error theory can’t be true because if it were, we would have to give up morality or give up moralizing. I answer this argument with a little bit of help from Nietzsche. I then pose a problem, the Doppelganger Problem, for the meta-ethical nihilism that I attribute to Mackie and Nietzsche. (If A is a moral proposition then not-A is a moral proposition: hence not all moral propositions can be false.) I solve the problem by reformulating the error theory and also deal with a variant of the problem, the Reinforced Doppelganger, glancing at a famous paper of Ronald Dworkin’s. Thus, whatever its demerits, the error theory, is not self-refuting, nor does it require us to give up morality.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Schacht (1995, chs. 2–3).
Thus my interpretation is broadly in accord with that of Leiter (2002).
Though as we shall see, this has to be carefully qualified to avoid self-refutation.
Pigden ed. (1999, pp. 119–124).
Mackie (1977, p. 35).
Field (1989).
Garner (1994, pp. 1–3).
Hinckfuss (1987, p.1).
Cawkwell (1985, pp. 219–220).
Pybus (1993, pp. 206–207).
Blackburn (1993, pp. 149–150).
Wright (1992, pp, 9–10).
See Pigden (ed., 1999, pp. 184–188).
Sayre-McCord (1988).
References
Ansell-Pearson K (1994) An introduction to Nietzsche as a political thinker: the perfect nihilist. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Berkowitz PN (1995) The ethics of an immoralist. Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA
Blackburn S (1993) Errors and the phenomenology of value. In: Blackburn S (ed) Essays in Quasi-Realism. Oxford University Press, New York
Cawkwell GL (1985) A memorial address. In: Honderich T (ed) Morality and objectivity. Routledge, London
Danto A (1965) Nietzsche as philosopher. Macmillan, New York
Dworkin R (1996) Objectivity and truth: you’d better believe it. Philos Public Aff 25(2):87–139
Field H (1989) Realism, mathematics and modality. Blackwell, Oxford
Garner R (1994) Beyond morality. Temple University Press, Philadelphia
Hinckfuss I (1987) The moral society: its structure and effects. Australian National University, Canberra
Leiter B (2002) Nietzsche on morality. Routledge, London
Mackie JL (1946) The refutation of morals. Australas J Philos 24:77–90
Mackie JL (1977) Ethics: inventing right and wrong. Penguin, Harmondsworth
Nietzsche F (1954) The portable Nietzsche (trans and ed: Kaufmann W) [includes Thus Spake Zarathrustra]. Viking Penguin, New York
Nietzsche F (1968a) The basic writings of Nietzsche (trans and ed: Kaufmann W) [includes Beyond Good and Evil]. Modern Library, New York
Nietzsche F (1968b) The will to power (ed: Kaufmann W, trans: Kaufmann W and Hollingdale RJ). Vintage, New York
Nietzsche F (1982) Daybreak (trans: Hollingdale RJ). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Nietzsche F (1994) The genealogy of morals (ed: Ansell-Pearson K, trans: Diethe C). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Nietzsche F (2005) The anti-Christ, Ecce Homo, Twilight of the idols (eds: Ridley A and Norman J, trans: Norman J). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Pigden, CR (ed) (1999) Russell on ethics. Routledge, London
Pybus C (1993) Gross moral turpitude: the Orr case reconsidered. William Heinemann, Melbourne
Sayre-McCord G (1988) Introduction: the many modal realisms. In: Sayre-McCord G (ed) Essays on Moral Realism. Cornell University Press, Ithaca
Schacht R (1995) Making sense of Nietzsche. University of Illinois Press, Urbana
Smith M (ed) (1995) Meta-ethics: Aldershot: Dartmouth
Wright C (1992) Truth and objectivity. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Pigden, C.R. Nihilism, Nietzsche and the Doppelganger Problem. Ethic Theory Moral Prac 10, 441–456 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10677-007-9097-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10677-007-9097-z