Abstract
Chemistry is concerned with all aspects of the changing of one kind of matter into another. It has many parts and all but one of these are so different from all the adjacent sciences that their distinctness is obvious; the exception is physical chemistry. The activities of its practitioners resemble prima facie those of physicists. These however deal with unchanging matter that retains its chemical identity, and virtually all their experimental information is numerical. The physical chemist's concerns are the nature, extent, and rate of chemical changes, and on these much information may be gathered by the observer's unaided senses.
A fundamental feature or chemistry with few parallels in other sciences is that the variables determining chemical behaviour include the purity of reaction vessels, reagents, and the gas-phase in contact with these, as well as the exact experimental procedures when bringing about the chemical changes. For this reason, when encountering ostensibly new chemical phenomena, it is even more important than in other areas to distinguish between repeatability (of phenomena, e.g. explosions) and reproducibility (of quantities, e.g. reduction potentials). The distinction is not always clear, as differences of degree may develop into differences of kind. Unrepeatability may be of great heuristic significance, but irreproducibility is often of trivial origin. Examples from the author's researches illustrate how chemical behaviour, e.g. electrochemical conductivity or the nature of a product, such as the shape of a polymer molecule, can be altered profoundly by very small changes of experimental conditions, which is uncommon in other sciences.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Y. Firat, F.R. Jones, P.H. Plesch and P.H. Westermann, The Propagating Species in the Polymerisation of 1,3-Dioxacycloalkanes by Perchloric Acid. Makromol. Chem. Suppl. 1: 203–216, 1975.
A. Gandini, Ph.D. Thesis, Keele, 1964.
D.W. Grattan and P.H. Plesch, Ionisation of Aluminium Halides in Alkyl Halides. Journal of the Chemical Society, Dalton Transactions: 1734–1744, 1977.
W.R. Longworth and P.H. Plesch, The Interaction of Metal Chlorides with Alkyl Chlorides. Part II Electrochemical Studies of Titanium Tetrachloride in Some Alkyl Chlorides. Journal of the Chemical Society (London): 1887–1894, 1959.
O. Nuyken and P.H. Plesch, Binary Ionogenic Equilibria Exemplified by Acetyl Hexafluoroantimonate and their Implications for Cationic Polymerisations. Chemistry and Industry (London): 379–380, 1973.
P.H. Plesch, Binary Ionogenic Equilibria. Education in Chemistry 27: 75–76, 1990.
M. Polanyi, Science, Faith, and Society. University of Chicago Press, Chicago 60637, 1964.
J.J. Throssell, S.P. Sood, M. Szwarc and V. Stannett, The Instantaneous Polymerization of Styrene by Trifluoroacetic Acid. Journal of the American Chemical Society 78: 1122–1125, 1956.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Plesch, P.H. On the Distinctness of Chemistry. Foundations of Chemistry 1, 6–15 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009980225127
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009980225127