Abstract
In this essay, I suggest that Spinoza acknowledges a distinction between formal reality that is infinite and timelessly eternal and formal reality that is non-infinite (i. e., finite or indefinite) and non-eternal (i. e., enduring). I also argue that if, in Spinoza’s system, only intelligible causation is genuine causation, then infinite, timelessly eternal formal reality cannot cause non-infinite, non-eternal formal reality. A denial of eternal-durational causation generates a puzzle, however: if no enduring thing – not even the sempiternal, indefinite individual composed of all finite, enduring things – is caused by the infinite, eternal substance, then how can Spinoza consistently hold that the one infinite, eternal substance is the cause of all things and that all things are modes of that substance? At the end of this essay, I sketch how Spinoza could deny eternal-durational causation while still holding that an infinite, eternal God is the cause of all things and that all things are modes. I develop the interpretation more in the companion essay.1
1 In “Spinoza’s Monism II,” in the next issue of this journal.
Bennett, J. 1984. A Study of Spinoza’s Ethics. Indianapolis.Search in Google Scholar
Caird, J. 1883. Spinoza. London.Search in Google Scholar
Campbell, K. 1990. Abstract Particulars. Oxford.Search in Google Scholar
Curley, E. 1969. Spinoza’s Metaphysics: An Essay in Interpretation. Cambridge, MA.10.4159/harvard.9780674330450Search in Google Scholar
–. 1988. Behind the Geometrical Method: A Reading of Spinoza’s Ethics. Princeton.Search in Google Scholar
–. 1990. “Notes on a Neglected Masterpiece (II); The TTP as a Prolegomenon to the Ethics.” In Central Themes in Early Modern Philosophy, ed. by J. A. Cover/M. Kulstad.Search in Google Scholar
Delahunty, R. J. 1985. Spinoza. London.Search in Google Scholar
Della Rocca, M. 1996. Representation and the Mind-Body Problem in Spinoza. Oxford.10.1093/oso/9780195095623.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
–. 2008a. “Rationalism Run Amok: Representation and the Reality of the Emotions in Spinoza.” In Interpreting Spinoza. Ed. by Ch. Huenemann. Cambridge, 26–52.Search in Google Scholar
–. 2008b. Spinoza. New York.Search in Google Scholar
–. 2012. “Rationalism, Idealism, Monism, and Beyond.” In Spinoza and German Idealism. Ed. by E. Forster/Y. Melamed. Cambridge, 7–26.Search in Google Scholar
Descartes, R. 1964–74. Œuvres de Descartes. Ed. by Ch. Adam/P. Tannery, 12 vols. Paris.Search in Google Scholar
Donagan, A. 1988. Spinoza. Chicago.Search in Google Scholar
Friedman, J. 1986. “How the Finite Follows from the Infinite in Spinoza’s Metaphysical System.” Synthese 69(3), 371–407.10.1007/BF00413979Search in Google Scholar
Garber, D. 2015. “Superheroes in the History of Philosophy: Spinoza, Super-Rationalist.” Journal of the History of Philosophy 53(3), 507–21.10.1353/hph.2015.0045Search in Google Scholar
Garrett, A. 2003. Meaning in Spinoza’s Method. Cambridge.10.1017/CBO9780511487194Search in Google Scholar
Garrett, D. 1991. “Spinoza’s Necessitarianism.” In God and Nature in Spinoza’s Metaphysics. Ed. by Y. Yovel. Leiden, 191–218.Search in Google Scholar
–. 2009. “Spinoza on the Essence of the Human Body and the Part of the Mind that is Eternal.” In Cambridge Companion to Spinoza’s Ethics. Ed. by O. Koistinen. Cambridge, 284–302.Search in Google Scholar
–. 2017. “The Puzzle of Misrepresentation and Error in Spinoza’s Philosophy of Mind.” In The Oxford Handbook of Spinoza. Ed. by M. Della Rocca. Oxford.Search in Google Scholar
Grey, J. (2014). “Spinoza on Composition, Causation, and the Mind’s Eternity.” British Journal for the History of Philosophy 22(3), 446–67.10.1080/09608788.2014.908114Search in Google Scholar
Gueroult, M. 1974/[1968]. Spinoza, 2 vols. Paris.Search in Google Scholar
Hardin, C. L. 1978. “Spinoza on Immortality and Time.” In Spinoza: New Perspectives. Ed. by R. W. Shahan/J. I. Biro. Norman, 129–38.10.5840/swjphil19778358Search in Google Scholar
Hübner, K. 2017. “The Trouble with Feelings, or Spinoza on the Identity of Power and Essence.” Journal of the History of Philosophy 55(1), 35–53.10.1353/hph.2017.0001Search in Google Scholar
–. 2019. “Spinoza on Intentionality, Materialism, and Mind-body Relations.” Philosophers’ Imprint 43, 1–23.Search in Google Scholar
Jarrett, C. 2001. “Spinoza’s Distinction between Essence and Existence.” Iyyun: The Jerusalem Philosophical Quarterly 50, 245–52.Search in Google Scholar
Laerke, M. 2017. “Aspects of Spinoza’s Theory of Essence.” In The Actual and The Possible. Ed. by M. Sinclair. Oxford.Search in Google Scholar
–. 2017. “Leibniz’s Encounter with Spinoza’s Monism, October 1675 to February 1678.” In The Oxford Handbook of Spinoza. M. Della Rocca (ed.). Oxford.Search in Google Scholar
Leibniz, G. W. 1999. Réfutation inedite de Spinoza. Ed. by M. de Gaudemar/trans. by L. A. Foucher de Careil. Paris.Search in Google Scholar
Lennox, J. 1976. “The Causality of Finite Modes in Spinoza’s Ethics.” Canadian Journal of Philosophy 6(3), 479–500.10.1080/00455091.1976.10716161Search in Google Scholar
Lin, M. 2012. “Rationalism and Necessitarianism,” Noûs 46 (3): 418–48.10.1111/j.1468-0068.2011.00832.xSearch in Google Scholar
Martin, C. (2008). “The Framework of Essences in Spinoza’s Ethics.” British Journal for the History of Philosophy 16(3), 489–509.10.1080/09608780802200489Search in Google Scholar
Matson, W. 1990. “Body, Essence and Mind Eternity in Spinoza.” In Spinoza: Issues and Directions. Ed. by E. Curley/P.-F. Moreau. Leiden, 82–95.10.1163/9789004246638_009Search in Google Scholar
Melamed, Y. 2013. Spinoza’s Metaphysics: Substance and Thought. Oxford.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195394054.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Moreau, P.-F. 1994. Spinoza: l’expérience et l’éternité. Paris.Search in Google Scholar
Nadler, S. 2006. Spinoza’s Ethics: An Introduction. Cambridge.10.1017/CBO9780511815737Search in Google Scholar
–. 2012. “Spinoza’s Monism and the Reality of the Finite.” In Spinoza on Monism. Ed. by P. Goff. Houndmills/Basingstoke/Hampshire, 223–43.Search in Google Scholar
Newlands, S. 2018. “Spinoza’s Modal Metaphysics.” The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2018 Edition), Ed. by E. N. Zalta, URL = <https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2018/entries/spinoza-modal/>.Search in Google Scholar
Peterman, A. 2015. “Spinoza on Extension.” Philosophers’ Imprint 15(14), 1–23.Search in Google Scholar
Pollock, F. 1880. Spinoza: His Life and Philosophy. London.Search in Google Scholar
Primus, K. 2019. “Spinoza’s ‘Infinite Modes’ Reconsidered.” Journal of Modern Philosophy 1(1) 11, 1–29.10.32881/jomp.69Search in Google Scholar
–. 2021. “Reflective Knowledge.” In The Blackwell Companion to Spinoza. Ed. by Y. Melamed. Hoboken, NJ, 265–75.Search in Google Scholar
Rivaud, A. 1905. Les notions d’essence et d’existence dans la philosophie de Spinoza. Paris.Search in Google Scholar
Schaffer, J. 2010. “Monism: The Priority of the Whole.” Philosophical Review 119(1), 31–76.10.1215/00318108-2009-025Search in Google Scholar
Schmaltz, T. 1997. “Spinoza’s Mediate Infinite Mode.” Journal of the History of Philosophy 35(2), 199–235.10.1353/hph.1997.0024Search in Google Scholar
–. 1999. “Spinoza on the Vacuum.” Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophy 81(2), 174–205.Search in Google Scholar
–. 2008. Descartes on Causation. Oxford.Search in Google Scholar
–. 2015. “Spinoza on Eternity and Duration: The 1663 Connection.” In The Young Spinoza: A Metaphysician in the Making. Ed. by Y. Melamed. Oxford, 205–20.Search in Google Scholar
–. 2019. The Metaphysics of the Material World. Oxford.Search in Google Scholar
Schnepf, R. 2011. “The One Substance and Finite Things (1p16-28).” In Spinoza’s Ethics. Ed. by M. Hampe/U. Renz/R. Schnepf. New York, 37–56.10.1163/ej.9789004194250.i-380.17Search in Google Scholar
Scribano, E. 2008. Guida alla lettura dell’Etica di Spinoza. Rome/Bari.Search in Google Scholar
Spinoza 1972[1925]. Spinoza Opera (4 vols.). Ed. by C. Gebhardt. Heidelberg.Search in Google Scholar
–. 2016/[1985]. The Collected Works of Spinoza (2 vols.). Ed./trans. by E. Curley. Princeton.Search in Google Scholar
Steinberg, D. 1981. “Spinoza’s Theory of the Eternity of the Mind.” Canadian Journal of Philosophy 11, 55–65.10.1080/00455091.1981.10716291Search in Google Scholar
Viljanen, V. 2011. Spinoza’s Geometry of Power. Cambridge.10.1017/CBO9781139005210Search in Google Scholar
–. 2014. “Spinoza on Virtue and Eternity.” In Essays on Spinoza’s Ethical Theory. Ed. by M. J. Kisner/A. Youpa. New York, 258–71.Search in Google Scholar
Ward, T. 2011. “Spinoza on the Essences of Modes.” British Journal for the History of Philosophy 19(1), 19–46.10.1080/09608788.2011.533010Search in Google Scholar
Watt, A. J. 1972. “The Causality of God in Spinoza’s Philosophy.” Canadian Journal of Philosophy 2(2), 178–80.10.1080/00455091.1972.10716037Search in Google Scholar
Wilson, M. 1991. “Spinoza’s Causal Axiom (Ethics I, Axiom 4).” In God and Nature: Spinoza’s Metaphysics. Ed. by Y. Yovel. New York, 133–60.Search in Google Scholar
Youpa, A. 2011. “Spinoza on the Very Nature of Existence.” Midwest Studies in Philosophy 35(1), 310–34.10.1111/j.1475-4975.2011.00221.xSearch in Google Scholar
Yovel, Y. 1991. “The Infinite Mode and Natural Laws in Spinoza.” In God and Nature: Spinoza’s Metaphysics. Ed. by Y. Yovel. New York, 79–96.10.1163/9789004451650Search in Google Scholar
–. 1994. Spinoza and Other Heretics, Volume 1: The Marrano of Reason. Princeton.Search in Google Scholar
© 2021 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
