Abstract
Tagore and Gandhi shared a relationship across 26 years. They argued about many things including the means for the attainment of swaraj/freedom. In terms of this central concern with the nature of freedom they came fairly close to an issue that has perhaps dominated the (European) Enlightenment. For the Enlightenment has sought to clarify what is meant by individual freedom and attempted to secure such freedom to the individual. This article argues that the Tagore-Gandhi debate can perhaps be reconstructed around the issue of freedom and the collective. Gandhi was able to employ the idea of collective action with conceptual and practical ease. He seemed to have felt no tension between individual freedom and the notion of the collective of which an individual becomes a part in his/her attempt to deal with the contending ‘other’ and secure his /her freedom/swaraj. To understand Tagore’s opposition to the Gandhian idea of swaraj this article draws a philosophical parallel between Tagore and Kant on individual freedom as primarily the freedom to reason. Tagore’s argument seemed to have centered on the insight that the location of the individual in a collective hypostatized self in order to protect his or her freedom from ‘others’ reaffirms the self other divide. The insider-outsider exclusionary dynamics that are generated not only consolidate such distinctions as external to (and outside of) the collective self, but they also initiate internal dynamics that create the ‘silenced insider.’
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Tagore (1921) in Bhattacharya (ed) (2008), 56
Tagore (1921) in Bhattacharya (ed) (2008), 56
Bhattacharya (ed) (2008), 3.
Giri (2001), 130.
Bhattacharya (ed) (2008), 21.
Habermas (1998), 129–153.
Puri (2011), 673–698.
Gandhi (1909) in Parel (ed) (1997), 73.
Gandhi (2008), 7.
Gandhi (2008), 7.
Terchek, Ronald J. (2002),
Puri (2011), 673–698.
Kant in Gregor (ed) (1996), 190.
Gier (2008), 121–142.
Gandhi (1917), 64–65.
Ray (2003), 38.
Habermas (1998), 129–153.
Gandhi (1925 ) in Bhattacharya (ed) (2008), 124.
Tagore (1961), 506.
Tagore (1961), 506.
Kant (1784) in Reiss (ed) (1991).
Kant (1784) in Reiss (ed) (1991), 1.
Kant (1784) in Reiss (ed) (1991), 3.
Kant (1784) in Reiss (ed) (1991), 2.
Kant (1784) in Reiss (ed) (1991), 2.
Kant (1784) in Reiss (ed) (1991), 8.
Tagore (1922b) in Das (ed) (1996), 545.
Tagore (1925b), in Bhattacharya (ed) (2008), 99.
Tagore (1925a), in Bhattacharya (ed) (2008), 119.
Tagore (1914) in Das (ed) (1996), 308.
Tagore (1914) in Das (ed) (1996), 308.
Tagore (1914) in Das (ed) (1996), 308.
Amiyo Dev (et al.) (ed) (2011), 242.
Bhattacharya (2008), 25.
Tagore (1925a) in Bhattacharya (ed) (2008), 116.
Tagore (1914) in Das (ed) (1996), 312.
Tagore (1924b) quoted in Nandy (1994), 37.
Tagore (1917a) in Das (ed) (1996), 456.
Tagore (1917a) in Das (ed) (1996), 458.
Tagore (1922a) in Das (ed) (1996), 549.
Tagore (1922a) in Das (ed) (1996), 551.
Tagore (1917c) in Das (ed) (1996), 427.
Macedo (1998), 56.
Flathman (1998), 82.
Habermas (1998), 129–153.
Patel and Sykes (1987), 62.
Bhattacharya (ed) (2008), 27.
Bhattacharya (ed) (2008), 28.
Bhattacharya (ed) (2008), 26.
Tagore (1905) quoted in Bhattacharya (ed) (2008), 25.
Tagore (1917a) in Das (ed) (1996), 461.
Tagore (1917a) in Das (ed) (1996), 458.
Tagore (1917a) in Das (ed) (1996), 460.
Ray (2003), 36.
Ray (2003), 36.
Duara (2011), 338.
Tagore (1924a) in Das (ed) (1996), 621.
Tagore (1924a) in Das (ed) (1996), 621.
Tagore (1924a) in Das (ed) (1996), 621.
Tagore (1902), 7.
Tagore (1924a) in Das (ed) (1996), 626.
Tagore (1924a) in Das (ed) (1996), 622.
Tagore (1917b) in Das (ed) (1996), 440.
Ray (2003), 38.
Tagore (1914) in Das (ed) (1996), 313.
Herder (1968), 7.
References
Amiyo, D., Liming, W., Chung, T., & Bangwei, W. (Eds.). (2011). Tagore and China. New Delhi: Sage Publications India Pvt Ltd.
Bhattacharya, S. (Ed.). (2008). The Mahatma and the poet. New Delhi: National Book Trust.
Duara, P. (2011). Community, nation and sustainability: The contemporary relevance of tagore. In A. Dev, W. Liming, T. Chung and W. Bangwei (Eds.) (2011) Tagore and China. New Delhi: Sage Publications India Pvt, Ltd.
Flathman, R. E. (1998). It all depends…on how one understands liberalism: A brief response to Stephen Macedo. Political Theory, 26(1).
Gandhi, M. K. (1909). Hind Swaraj. In A. J Parel (Ed.) (1997). New Delhi: Cambridge University Press.
Gandhi, M. K. (1917). The collected works of Mahatma Gandhi, vol. 14. (pp. 64-65) New Delhi: Publications Division, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, 1958–1994.
Gandhi, M. K. (1925). Young India, ‘The poet and the charkha’. In S. Bhattacharya (Ed.) (2008). The Mahatma and the Poet. New Delhi: National Book Trust, India.
Gandhi, M. K. (2008). Indian of my dreams. Ahmedabad: Navajivan Publishing House.
Gier, N. F. (2008). Non violence as a civic virtue: Gandhi and reformed liberalism. In D. Allen (Ed.), The philosophy of Mahatma Gandhi for the 21st century. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Giri, A. K. (2001). Gandhi, Tagore and the new ethics of argumentation. In Puri Bindu (Ed.), Mahatma Gandhi and his contemporaries. New Delhi: Indian Institute of Advanced Study.
Habermas, J. (1998). On the relation between the nation, the rule of law, and democracy. In J. Habermas (Ed.), The inclusion of the other. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Kampchen, M. (1991). Rabindranath Tagore and Germany: A documentation. Calcutta: Max Mueller Bhavan.
Kant, I. (1996). Critique of practical reason. In M. J. Gregor (Ed.), Volume on practical philosophy in Cambridge edition of works of Immanuel Kant. Cambridge: CUP.
Kant, I. (1784). An answer to the question: What is Enlightenment? In H. Reiss (Ed.) (1991). Political Writings, CUP.
Macedo, S. (1998). Transformative constitutionalism and the case of religion: defending the moderate hegemony of liberalism. Political Theory, 26(1).
Patel, J. P., & Sykes, M. (1987). Gandhi and the gift of the fight, Rasulia.
Puri, B. (2011). The self and the other: Liberalism and Gandhi. Philosophia, 39, 673–698.
Ray, R. K. (2003). The felt community. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Sengupta, K. (2005). The philosophy of Rabindranath Tagore. Hampshire: Ashgate Publishing, Ltd.
Tagore, R. (1902). Bharatvarsher Itihas (The History of India). Bangadarshan revised and reprinted in 1908.
Tagore, R. (1914). The problem of self. In S. K. Das (Ed.) (1996). The English writings of Rabindranath Tagore, vol 2. New Delhi: Sahitya Akademi.
Tagore, R. (1905). Swadeshi Samaj. In S. Bhattacharya (Ed.) (2008). The Mahatma and the poet. New Delhi: National Book Trust, India.
Tagore, R. (1917a). Nationalism in India. In S. K. Das (Ed.) (1996). The English writings of Rabindranath Tagore, vol 2. New Delhi: Sahitya Akademi.
Tagore, R. (1917b). Nationalism in Japan. In S. K. Das (Ed.) (1996). The English writings of Rabindranath Tagore, vol 2 (p. 440). New Delhi: Sahitya Akademi.
Tagore, R. (1917c). Nationalism in the West. In S. K. Das (Ed.) (1996). The English writings of Rabindranath Tagore, vol 2. New Delhi: Sahitya Akademi.
Tagore, R. (1921). Tagore’s reflections on non-cooperation and co-operation (May 1921, The Modern Review). In S. Bhattacharya (Ed.) (2008). The Mahatma and the poet. New Delhi: National Book Trust, India.
Tagore, R. (1922a). The nation. In S. K. Das (Ed.) (1996). The English writings of Rabindranath Tagore, vol 2. New Delhi: Sahitya Akademi.
Tagore, R. (1922b). The spirit of freedom. In S. K. Das (Ed.) (1996). The English writings of Rabindranath Tagore, vol 2. New Delhi: Sahitya Akademi.
Tagore, R. (1924a). Civilization and progress. In S. K. Das (Ed.), (1996). The English writings of Rabindranath Tagore, volume 2. New Delhi: Sahitya Akademi.
Tagore, R. (1924b). Gora. In Nandy, A. (Ed.) (1994). The illegitimacy of nationalism. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Tagore, R. (1925a, Modern Review). Striving for Swaraj. In S. Bhattacharya (Ed.) (2008). The Mahatma and the poet. New Delhi: National Book Trust, India.
Tagore, R. (1925b, Modern Review). The cult of the Charkha. In S. Bhattacharya (Ed.) (2008). The Mahatma and the poet. New Delhi: National Book Trust, India.
Tagore, R. (1961). Rabindra Racanabali (Vol. 1). Calcutta: Government of West Bengal.
Terchek, R. J. (2002). Gandhian autonomy in the modern world. In A. J. Parel (Ed.), Gandhi, freedom and self rule. New Delhi: Vistaar Publications.
Von Herder, J. G. (1968). Reflections on the philosophy of history of mankind (abridged and with an Introduction by FE Manuel). Chicago: Chicago University Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Puri, B. Freedom and the Dynamics of the Self and the ‘Other’; Re-constructing the Debate Between Tagore and Gandhi. SOPHIA 52, 335–357 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11841-012-0311-7
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11841-012-0311-7