Abstract
In this paper, we review the conventional analyses of management control systems, to conclude, first, that the “illusion of control” can mislead managers into believing that everything can be controlled and monitored, and, second, that no incentive system based only on extrinsic rewards can motivate individuals properly. Then, we investigate the philosophical foundations of the basic assumptions that, implicitly or explicitly, are made about the nature of the acting person. Based on personalist phenomenology, we show how the development of technical and moral values is crucial to the long-run survival of organizations. We end by offering some guidelines as to what control systems should be like in order to be compatible with the nature of human persons.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
A. Alchian H. Demsetz (1972) ArticleTitle‘Production, Information Costs, and Economic Organization’ American Economic Review 62 777–795
R. N. Anthony V. Govindarajan (2003) Management Control Systems, 11th Edition McGraw-Hill New York
C. Argyris (1990) ArticleTitle‘The Dilemma of Implementing Controls: The Case of Managerial Accounting’, Accounting Organizations and Society 16 IssueID6 503–511
G. Baker (1992) ArticleTitle‘Incentive Contracts and Performance Measurement’ Journal of Political Economy 100 IssueID3 598–614
Ch. Barnard (1938) The Functions of the Executive Harvard University Press Boston
J. Birnberg L. Turopolec S.M. Young (1983) ArticleTitle‘The Organizational Context of Accounting’, Accounting Organizations and Society 8 IssueID2/3 111–129
J. A. Brickley C. Smith J. Zimmerman (2003) ArticleTitle‘Corporate Governance, Ethics and Organizational Architecture’ Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 15 IssueID3 34–45
J. Crosby (1996) The Selfhood of the Human Person The Catholic University of America Press Washington, DC
J. D. Dermer R. G. Lucas (1986) ArticleTitle‘The Illusion of Management Control’, Accounting Organizations and Society 11 IssueID6 471–482
B. Frey S. Meier (2002) ‘Pro-Social Behavior, Reciprocity or Both?’, CESIFO Working Paper No. 750 CESIFO Munich
R. Gibbons (1998) ArticleTitle‘Incentives in Organizations’ Journal of Economic Perspectives 12 IssueID4 115–132
R. Guardini (1999) Ética. Lecciones en la Universidad de Munich BAC Madrid). Original: 1993, Ethik. Vorlesungen an der Universität München (Matthias-Grünerwald-Verlag, Mainz
G. Hofstede (1981) ArticleTitle‘Management Control of Public and Not-For-Profit Activities’, Accounting Organizations and Society 6 IssueID3 193–211
M. Jensen (1994) ArticleTitle‘Self-Interest, Altruism, Incentives and Agency Theory’ Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 7 IssueID2 1–10
M. Jensen W. Meckling (1998) ‘The Nature of Man’, M. Jensen (Eds) Foundations of Organizational Strategy Boston Harvard University Press
S. Kerr (1975) ArticleTitle‘On the Folly of Rewarding A While Hoping for B’ Academy of Management Journal 18 769–783
S. Kerr (1995) ArticleTitle‘On the Folly of Rewarding A While Hoping for B’ Academy of Management Executive 9 IssueID1 7–16
S. Kerr (2003) ArticleTitle‘The Best-Laid Incentive Plans’ Harvard Business Review 81 IssueID1 27–37
E. P. Lazear (1989) ArticleTitle‘Pay Equality and Industrial Politics’ Journal of Political Economy 97 IssueID3 561–580
D. McGregor (1960) The Human Side of Enterprise McGraw-Gill Book Company New York
J. March H. Simon (1958) Organizations Wiley New York
M. Osterloh B. Frey (2003) ‘Corporate Governance for Crooks? The Case for Corporate Virtue’, Working paper ISSN 1424–0459, Institute for Empirical Research in Economics University of Zurich, Zurich
J. A. Pérez López (1993) Fundamentos de la Dirección de Empresas Rialp Madrid
J. M. Rosanas M. Velilla (2003) ArticleTitle‘Loyalty and Trust as the Ethical Bases of Organizations’ Journal of Business Ethics 44 49–59
P. Selznick (1957) Leadership in Administration University of California Press Berkeley, Los Angeles and London
H. Simon (1947) Administrative Behavior The Free Press New York
R. Simons (1995) Levers of Control Harvard Business School Press Boston
K. Wojtyla (1979) The Acting Person D. Reidel Publishing Co. Dordrecht
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rosanas, J.M., Velilla, M. The Ethics of Management Control Systems: Developing Technical and Moral Values. J Bus Ethics 57, 83–96 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-004-3826-1
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-004-3826-1