Against the backdrop of the recent upsurge of interest in character education and global citizenship education in South Korea, this paper examines scholarly debates over the relation between education for character-building and education for citizenship-building. Is character education compatible with citizenship education, or are they necessarily at odds with one another? After identifying two possibilities of education for character-building and education for citizenship-building, I argue that if character education attempts to help students grow into ethically sophisticated and caring human beings, not to indoctrinate or enforce conformity among them, it can dovetail nicely with the practices of citizenship education for making an active and transformative citizenry. In addition, against the background of a necessary and inevitable tension between "the good man" and "the good citizen," I further posit that the integration between character education and citizenship education can be more successful when it is promoted through the framework of global citizenship education (GCE).
KCI 등재
The Relation between Character Education and Global Citizenship Education: Are Education for the Good Man and Education for the Good Citizen Compatible?
倫理硏究
약어 : -
2015 vol.1, no.104, pp.1 - 27
DOI : 10.15801/je.1.104.201511.1
발행기관 : 한국윤리학회
연구분야 : 학제간연구
Copyright © 한국윤리학회
약어 : -
2015 vol.1, no.104, pp.1 - 27
DOI : 10.15801/je.1.104.201511.1
발행기관 : 한국윤리학회
연구분야 : 학제간연구
Copyright © 한국윤리학회
Character education, Citizenship Education, Global citizenship education
- 1. [단행본] Aristotle / 2013 / Aristotle: Eudemian Ethics / Cambridge University Press
- 2. [단행본] Aristotle / 2000 / Politics / Dover Thrift Editions
- 3. [단행본] Berkowitz, Marvin W. / 2000 / Routledge International Companion to Education / Routledge
- 4. [기타] Berkowitz, Marvin W. / 2005 / What Works in Character Education: A Research-Driven Guide for Educators / Charactere Education Partnership
- 5. [기타] Boston, Bruce O. / 2005 / Restoring the Balance between Academics and Civic Engagement in Public Schools / American Youth Policy Forum and Association for Supervision and Curriculum Developmen
- 6. [단행본] Broadie, Sarah / 2006 / The Blackwell Guide to Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics / Blackwell : 350 ~
- 7. [단행본] Freire, Paulo / 2000 / Pedagogy of the Oppressed / Bloomsbury Publishing
- 8. [단행본] Friedman, Milton / 2005 / The Optimum Quantity of Money / Transaction Publishers
- 9. [단행본] Giddens, Anthony / 1990 / The Consequences of Modernity / Polity
- 10. [단행본] Held, David / 1995 / Cosmopolitan Democracy / Polity
- 11. [단행본] Irwin, Terence / 1988 / Aristotle's First Principles / Clarendon Press
- 12. [단행본] Kerr, David / 1999 / Citizenship Education: An International Comparison / Qualifications and Curriculum Authority
- 13. [단행본] Kraut, Richard / 2002 / Aristotle: Political Philosophy / Oxford University Press
- 14. [단행본] Lickona, Thomas / 2001 / Educating for Character / Bantam
- 15. [단행본] Lickona, Thomas / 2005 / Smart and Good High Schools / Center for 4th and 5th Rs
- 16. [단행본] Mill, John Stuart / 2007 / On Liberty and Other Writings / Cambridge University Press
- 17. [단행본] Nussbaum, Martha C. / 2009 / Frontiers of Justice: Disability, Nationality, Species Membership / Harvard University Press
- 18. [단행본] Rhoads, Robert A / 2011 / Global Citizenship and the University: Advancing Social Life and Relations in an Interdependent World / Stanford University Press
- 19. [단행본] Robinson, Richard / 1995 / Aristotle. Politics: Book 3 and 4, with a Supplementary Essay by David Keyt / Clarendon Press
- 20. [단행본] Ryan, William / 1976 / Blame the Victim / Vintage
- 21. [단행본] Sassen, Saskia / 2002 / Handbook of Citizenship Studies / Sage
- 22. [단행본] Soder, Roger / 2001 / Developing Democratic Character in the Young / Jossey Bass
- 23. [단행본] Soysal, Yasemin N. / 1994 / Limits of Citizenship: Migrants and Postnational Membership in Europe / University of Chicago Press
- 24. [단행본] Torres, Carlos Alberto / 1998 / Democracy, Education, and Multiculturalism: Dilemmas of Citizenship in a Global World / Rowman & Littlefield
- 25. [단행본] Weber, Eugene / 1976 / Pesants into Frenchmen: The Modernization of Rural France, 1870-1914 / Chatto and Windus
- 26. [학술지] Althof, Wolfgang / 2006 / Moral Education and Character Education: Their Relationship and Roles in Citizenship Education / Journal of Moral Education / 35 (4) : 495 ~ 4
- 27. [학술지] Banks, James A. / 2008 / Diversity, Group Identity, and Citizenship Education in a Global Age / Educational Researcher / 37 (3) : 129 ~ 3
- 28. [학술지] Develin, Robert / 1973 / The Good Man and the Good Citizen in Aristotle's "Politics" / Phronesis / 18 (1) : 71 ~ 1
- 29. [학술지] Dobson, Andrew / 2005 / Globalisation, Cosmopolitanism and the Environment / International Relations / 19 (3) : 259 ~ 3
- 30. [학술지] Giroux, Henry A. / 1980 / Critical Theory and Rationality in Citizenship Education / Curriculum Inquiry / 10 (4) : 329 ~ 4
- 31. [학술지] Keyt, David / 2007 / The Good Man and the Upright Citizen in Arisottle's Ethics and Politics / Social Philosophy and Policy / 24 (2) : 220 ~ 2
- 32. [학술지] Lickona, Thomas / 2003 / Educating for Character: A Comprehensive Approach / Orbit / 33 (2) : 17 ~ 2
- 33. [학술지] Lockwodd, Alan L. / 1986 / Keeping Them in the Courtyard: A Response to Wynne / Educational Leadership / 43 (4) : 9 ~ 4
- 34. [학술지] Misiaszek, Greg William / 2015 / Ecopedagogy and Citizenship in the Age of Globalisation: Connections between Environmental and Global Citizenship Education to Save the Planet / European Journal of Education / 50 (3) : 280 ~ 3
- 35. [학술지] Sandy, Leo / 2009 / Educating for Global Citizenship in the New Millennium / International Journal of Diversity in Organizations, Communities and Nations / 9 (1) : 59 ~ 1
- 36. [학술지] Schugurensky, Daniel / 2003 / A Framework to Explore Lifelong Learning: The Case of the Civic Education of Civics Teachers / International Journal of Lifelong Education / 22 (4) : 325 ~ 4
- 37. [학술지] Tambini, Damian / 2001 / Post-National Citizenship / Ethnic and Racial Studies / 24 (2) : 195 ~ 2
- 38. [보고서] Tawil, Sobhi / 2013 / Education for 'Global Citizebship' : A Framework for Discussion. ERF Working Papers Series
- 39. [인터넷자료] Global Citizen / South Korea Steps Up and Supports Global Education
- 40. [인터넷자료] Joongang Daily / Character Education to be Taught in All Schools
- 41. [기타] UNESCO / 2013 / Concept Note UNESCO Forum on Global Citizenship Education: Preparing learners for the challenge of the 21st Century. 2-4 December 2013
타입을 선택하세요
The Relation between Character Education and Global Citizenship Education: Are Education for the Good Man and Education for the Good Citizen Compatible?
@article{ART002049692},
author={
김형렬
},
title={
The Relation between Character Education and Global Citizenship Education: Are Education for the Good Man and Education for the Good Citizen Compatible?
},
journal={
倫理硏究
},
issn={2982-5121},
year={2015},
number={104},
pages={1 - 27},
doi={10.15801/je.1.104.201511.1},
url={http://dx.doi.org/10.15801/je.1.104.201511.1}
TY - JOUR
AU - 김형렬
TI - The Relation between Character Education and Global Citizenship Education: Are Education for the Good Man and Education for the Good Citizen Compatible?
T2 - 倫理硏究
PY - 2015
VL - 1
IS - 104
PB - 한국윤리학회
SP - 1 - 27
SN - 2982-5121
AB - Against the backdrop of the recent upsurge of interest in character education and global citizenship education in South Korea, this paper examines scholarly debates over the relation between education for character-building and education for citizenship-building. Is character education compatible with citizenship education, or are they necessarily at odds with one another? After identifying two possibilities of education for character-building and education for citizenship-building, I argue that if character education attempts to help students grow into ethically sophisticated and caring human beings, not to indoctrinate or enforce conformity among them, it can dovetail nicely with the practices of citizenship education for making an active and transformative citizenry. In addition, against the background of a necessary and inevitable tension between "the good man" and "the good citizen," I further posit that the integration between character education and citizenship education can be more successful when it is promoted through the framework of global citizenship education (GCE).
KW - Character education, Citizenship Education, Global citizenship education
DO - 10.15801/je.1.104.201511.1
UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.15801/je.1.104.201511.1
ER -
김형렬 (2015). The Relation between Character Education and Global Citizenship Education: Are Education for the Good Man and Education for the Good Citizen Compatible?. 倫理硏究, 1(104), 1 - 27.
김형렬 . 2015, “The Relation between Character Education and Global Citizenship Education: Are Education for the Good Man and Education for the Good Citizen Compatible?”, vol.1, no.104, pp. 1 - 27. Available from: doi:10.15801/je.1.104.201511.1
김형렬. “The Relation between Character Education and Global Citizenship Education: Are Education for the Good Man and Education for the Good Citizen Compatible?“ 倫理硏究 1.104 pp. 1 - 27. (2015): 1.
김형렬 . The Relation between Character Education and Global Citizenship Education: Are Education for the Good Man and Education for the Good Citizen Compatible? 倫理硏究 [Internet]. 2015; 1(104), : 1 - 27. Available from: doi:10.15801/je.1.104.201511.1
김형렬 . “The Relation between Character Education and Global Citizenship Education: Are Education for the Good Man and Education for the Good Citizen Compatible?“ 倫理硏究 1, no.104, (2015): 1 - 27. doi: :10.15801/je.1.104.201511.1