Abstract
In this article I discuss the proposition that ecologists may place restrictions on the kinds of plants and animals and on the kinds of systems they consider relevant to assessing the resiliency of ecological generalizations. I argue that to restrict the extension of ecological science and its concepts in order to exclude cultivated plants, captive animals, and domesticated environments ecologists must appeal either (1) to the boundaries of their discipline; (2) to the idea that the effects of human activity are rare and unusual enough to count as ceteris paribus conditions; or (3) to the nature/culture divide. The boundaries of their discipline, however, are practical, not epistemological. The effects of human activity are ubiquitous and profound. And the nature/culture divide, as far as I know, has been infra dignitatem in the natural sciences at least since Charles Darwin and John Stuart Mill. Ecologists may reason, moreover, that organisms and systems that have the kind of history that interests them must as a result possess a kind of organization or some other general biological property that distinguishes them from those that do not. This is to commit a genetic fallacy.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alberti M, Marzluff JM, Shulenberger E et al (2003) Integrating humans into ecology: opportunities and challenges for studying urban ecosystems. Bioscience 53(12):1169–1179
American Fisheries Society (2016) Researchers play matchmaker to save fish population. https://fisheries.org/2016/01/researchers-play-matchmaker-to-save-fish-population/. Accessed 15 Mar 2017
Andrewartha HG (1961) Introduction to the study of animal populations. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Angner E (2015) To navigate safely in the vast sea of empirical facts. Synthese 192(11):3557–3575
Bamford M, Calver M (2014) A precise definition of habitat is needed for effective conservation and communication. Aust Zool 37(2):245–247
Barringer F (2014) Swim to sea? These salmon are catching a lift. New York Times, April 18
Begon M, Townsend CR, Harper JL (2006) Ecology: from individuals to ecosystems. 4th edn. Blackwell Publishing, Malden
Bellemain E, Ricklefs RE (2008) Are islands the end of the colonization road? Trends Ecol Evol 23(8):461–468
Berkes F, Colding J, Folke C (eds) (2008) Navigating social-ecological systems: building resilience for complexity and change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Binder CR, Hinkel J, Bots PWG, Pahl-Wostl C (2013) Comparison of frameworks for analyzing social-ecological systems. Ecol Soc 18(4):26. 10.5751/ES-05551-180426
Bradley B (1998) Two ways to talk about change: ‘The child’ of the sublime versus radical pedagogy. In: Bayer BM, Shotter J (eds) Reconstructing the psychological subject: bodies, practices and technologies. Sage Publications, London, pp 68–93
Brown JH, Sax DF (2004) An essay on some topics concerning invasive species. Austral Ecol 29(5):530–536
Campbell NA, Reece JB, Taylor MR, Simon EJ, Dickey JL (2009) Biology: concepts and connections, 6th edn. Pearson/Benjamin Cummings, New York
Courchamp F, Dunne JA, Le Maho Y, May RM, Thébaud C, Hochberg ME (2015) Fundamental ecology is fundamental. Trends Ecol Evol 30(1):9–16
Crawley MJ, Harral JE (2001) Scale dependence in plant biodiversity. Science 291:864–868
Darwin C (1838–39) Notebook. http://darwin-online.org.uk/converted/published/1960_Notebooks_F1574d.html. Accessed 15 Mar 2017
Daston L (1995) How nature became the other: anthropomorphism and anthropocentrism in early modern natural philosophy. In Biology as society, society as biology: metaphors, pp. 37–56. Springer, Netherlands
Davis MA (2009) Invasion biology. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Didham RK, Tylianakis JM, Gemmell NJ, Rand TA, Ewers RM (2007) Interactive effects of habitat modification and species invasion on native species decline. Trends Ecol Evol 22(9):489–496
Dodson SI et al (1998) Ecology. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Ehrlich PR, Ehrlich AH (2013) Can a collapse of global civilization be avoided?. In Proceedings of the Royal Society B, vol 280, No. 1754, p. 20122845. The Royal Society, London
Ehrlich PR, Roughgarden J (1987) The science of ecology. Macmillan, New York
Ellis EC (2015) Ecology in an anthropogenic biosphere. Ecol Monogr 85(3):287–331
Ellis EC, Klein Goldewijk K, Siebert S et al (2010) Anthropogenic transformation of the biomes, 1700 to 2000. Global Ecol Biogeogr 19(5):589–606
Ellis EC, Kaplan JO, Fuller DQ et al (2013) Used planet: a global history. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 110(20):7978–7985
Elton C (1966) The pattern of animal communities. Methuen, London
ESA (2016) About. Ecological society of America. ESA.org. http://www.esa.org/esa/about. Accessed 26 Oct 2016
Estrada A, Morales-Castilla I, Caplat P, Early R (2016) Usefulness of species traits in predicting range shifts. Trends in ecology evolution 31(3):190–203
Falk-Petersen J, Bøhn T, Sandlund OT (2006) On the numerous concepts in invasion biology. Biol Invasions 8(6):1409–1424
Fauth JE, Bernardo J, Camara M et al (1996) Simplifying the jargon of community ecology: a conceptual approach. Am Nat 147(2):282–286
Flagg TA (2015) Balancing conservation and harvest objectives: a review of considerations for the management of salmon hatcheries in the US Pacific Northwest. North Am J Aquac 77(3):367–376
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) (2014) Global aquaculture production. http://www.fao.org/fishery/collection/global-aquaculture-production/en
Foucault M (1986) The care of the self: the history of sexuality, vol 3. Pantheon Books, New York
Graedel TE (1996) On the concept of industrial ecology. Annu Rev Energy Env 21(1):69–98
Gray A (1963) [1860] The origin of species by means of natural selection. In: Dupree AH (ed) Darwiniana. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Haberl H, Wackernagel M, Wrbka T (2004) Land use and sustainability indicators. An introduction. Land Use Policy 21(3):193–198
Haila Y (2000) Beyond the nature-culture dualism. Biol Philos 15(2):155–175
Hanski I, Gyllenberg M (1997) Uniting two general patterns in the distribution of species. Science 275:397–400
Harmon LJ, Harrison S (2015) Species diversity is dynamic and unbounded at local and continental scales. Am Nat 185(5):584–593
Helmus MR, Mahler DL, Losos JB (2014) Island biogeography of the Anthropocene. Nature 513(7519):543–546
Hubbell SB (2001) The unified neutral theory of biodiversity and biogeography. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Inkpen SA (2016) Like Hercules and the Hydra: trade-offs and strategies in ecological model-building and experimental design. Stud Hist Philos Sci Part C 57:34–43
Inkpen SA (2017) Are humans disturbing conditions in ecology? Biol Philos 32(1):51–71
Jarvie IC (1975) Epistle to the anthropologists. Am Anthropol 77(2):253–266
Jax K (2006) Ecological units: definitions and application. Q Rev Biol 81(3):237–258
Jelinski LW, Graedel TE, Laudise RA et al (1992) Industrial ecology: concepts and approaches. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 89(3):793–797
Keller EF (2005) Ecosystems, organisms, and machines. Bioscience 55(12):1069–1074
Knox B, Ladiges P, Evans B, Saint R (2010) Biology: an Australian focus. McGraw-Hill, North Ryde
Krebs CJ (1972) Ecology. Harper & Row, New York
Krebs CJ (2001) Ecology. Benjamin Cummings, an imprint of Addison Wesley Longman, Inc, Menlo Park
Lange M (2002) Who’s afraid of ceteris-paribus laws? Or: how I learned to stop worrying and love them. Erkenntnis 57:407–423
Lange M (2005) Ecological laws: what would they be and why would they matter? Oikos 110:394–403
Levin SA (1992) The problem of pattern and scale in ecology. Ecology 73:1943–1967
Levin SA (1998) Ecosystems and the biosphere as complex adaptive systems. Ecosystems 1(5):431–436
Levin SA (1999) Towards a science of ecological management. Conserv Ecol 3(2):6. http://www.consecol.org/vol3/iss2/art6/
Levin PS, Williams JG (2002) Interspecific effects of artifically propagated fish: an additional conservation risk for salmon. Conserv Biol 16(6):1581–1587
Linquist S, Gregory TR, Elliott TA et al (2016) Yes! There are resilient generalizations (or “laws”) in ecology. Q Rev Biol 91(2):119–131
Litrico I, Violle C (2015) Diversity in plant breeding: a new conceptual framework. Trends Plant Sci 20(10):604–613
MacArthur RH, Wilson EO (1967) The theory of island biogeography. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Macdonald IA, Loope LL, Usher MB, Hamann O (1989) Wildlife conservation and the invasion of nature reserves by introduced species: a global perspective. In: Biological invasions: a global perspective. Wiley, New York, pp 215–255
Mader SS (2004) Biology. 8th edn. McGraw-Hill, North Ryde
Magnusson WE (2013) The words “population” and “community” have outlived their usefulness in ecological publications. Natureza e Conservação 11(1):1–8. doi:10.4322/natcon.2013.007
Malinowski B (1945) In: Kaberry PM (ed) The dynamics of cultural change: an inquiry into race relations in Africa. Yale University Press, New Haven
McNaughton SJ, Wolf LL (1973) General ecology. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York
Mill JS (1875) Nature, the utility of religion, and theism. Longmans, Green, Reader, and Dyer, London. Mill’s “Essay on Nature” is available at https://archive.org/details/a592828200milluoft
Milla R, Osborne CP, Turcotte MM, Violle C (2015) Plant domestication through an ecological lens. Trends Ecol Evol 30(8):463–469
Mitchell SC (2005) How useful is the concept of habitat?–a critique. Oikos 110(3):634–638
O’Neill RV (2001) Is it time to bury the ecosystem concept (with full military honors, of course!). Ecology 82(12):3275–3284
Odum EP (1969) The strategy of ecosystem development. Science 164(3877):262–270
Odum EP (1971) Fundamentals of ecology, 3rd edn. WB Saunders Company, Philadelphia
Oster S (2010) China’s tiger farms spark a standoff. Wall Street J. http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703455804575057101418533006.html
Pounds JA, Puschendorf R (2004) Ecology: clouded futures. Nature 427:107–109
Pyšek P, Richardson DM, Pergl J, Jarošík V, Sixtová Z, Weber E (2008) Geographical and taxonomic biases in invasion ecology. Trends Ecol Evol 23(5):237–244
Reichard SH, Hamilton CW (1997) Predicting invasions of woody plants introduced into North America. Conserv Biol 11(1):193–203
Reichard SH, White P (2001) Horticulture as a pathway of invasive plant introductions in the United States most invasive plants have been introduced for horticultural use by nurseries, botanical gardens, and individuals. Bioscience 51(2):103–113
Ricciardi A (2014) Biological invasions simply explained. Bioscience 64(2):154–155
Richardson DM, Ricciardi A (2013) Misleading criticisms of invasion science: a field guide. Divers Distrib 19(12):1461–1467
Richardson DM, Pyšek P, Rejmánek M et al (2000) Naturalization and invasion of alien plants: concepts and definitions. Diver Distrib 6(2):93–107
Robinson TP, Wint GW, Conchedda G et al (2014) Mapping the global distribution of Livestock. PLoS One 9(5):e96084
Rosenzweig M (1999) Heeding the warning in biodiversity’s basic law. Science 284(5412):276–277
Sagoff M (2016) Are there general causal forces in ecology? Synthese 193:3003–3024
Scheiner SM, Willig MR (2008) A general theory of ecology. Theor Ecol 1(1):21–28
Schoener TW (1986) Mechanistic approaches to community ecology: a new reductionism. Am Zool 26(1):81–106
Secord JA (1981) Nature’s fancy: Charles Darwin and the breeding of pigeons. Isis 72:163–186
Shelford MB (1913) The decline of primeval communities at the head of Lake Michigan. In: Shelford VE (ed) Animal communities in temperate America. University of Chicago, Chicago
Simberloff D (2010) Invasions of plant communities–more of the same, something very different, or both? Am Midl Nat 163(1):220–233
Simberloff D, Souza L, Nuñez MA, Barrios-Garcia MN, Bunn W (2012) The natives are restless, but not often and mostly when disturbed. Ecology 93(3):598–607
Simberloff D, Martin JL, Genovesi P et al (2013) Impacts of biological invasions: what’s what and the way forward. Trends Ecol Evol 28(1):58–66
Smil V (1991) General energetics: energy in the biosphere and civilization. Wiley, New York
Stiling P (1992) Ecology. Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River
Stohlgren, T.J., Barnett, D.T. and Kartesz, J.T., 2003. The rich get richer: patterns of plant invasions in the United States. Front Ecol Environ 1(1):11–14
Thomas CD (2015) Rapid acceleration of plant speciation during the Anthropocene. Trends Ecol Evol 30(8):448–455
Thomas CD, Palmer G (2015) Non-native plants add to the British flora without negative consequences for native diversity. Proc Natl Acad Sci 112(14):4387–4392
Thompson K (2014) Where do camels belong? The story and science of invasive species. Profile Books, London
Valéry L, Fritz H, Lefeuvre JC (2013) Another call for the end of invasion biology. Oikos 122(8):1143–1146
Vellend M (2014) The value of biodiversity: a humbling analysis. Trends Ecol Evol 29:138–139
Villee CA (1972) Biology. WB Saunders Compamy, Philadelphia
Voget FW (1975) A history of ethnology. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York
Wagner MR, Block WM, Geils BW, Wenger KF (2000) Restoration ecology. J For 98(10):22–27
Walker BH, Gunderson LH, Kinzig AP et al (2006) A handful of heuristics and some propositions for understanding resilience in social-ecological systems. Ecol Soc 11(1):13. http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol11/iss1/art13/
Weber M (1949) [1904] Objectivity in social science and social policy. In: Shilsand EA, Finch HA (eds) The methodology of the social sciences. Free Press, New York
Whittaker RH, Levin SA, Root RB (1973) Niche, habitat, and ecotope. Am Nat 107(955):321–338
World Society for the Protection of Animals (WSPA) (2008) Eating our future: the environmental impact of industrial animal agriculture. http://www.fao.org/ag/againfo/themes/animal-welfare/news-detail/en/c/12203/. Accessed 15 Mar 2017
World Wildlife Fund (2014) More tigers in American backyards than in the wild. https://www.worldwildlife.org/stories/more-tigers-in-american-backyards-than-in-the-wild. Accessed 15 Mar 2017
Acknowledgements
I thank Andrew Inkpen for many helpful suggestions.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sagoff, M. On the Definition of Ecology. Biol Theory 12, 85–98 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13752-017-0263-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13752-017-0263-9