Abstract
Individuals’ food choices are intimately connected to their self-images and world views. Some dietary choices adopted by consumers pose restrictions on their use of genetically modified food (GMF). It is quite generally agreed that some kind of labeling is necessary for respecting consumers’ autonomy of choice regarding GMF. In this paper, we ask whether the current practice of mandatory labeling of GMF products in the European Union is a sufficient administrative procedure for respecting consumers’ autonomy. Three issues concerning this question are discussed. First, we argue that labeling needs to be accompanied by relevant and understandable information on genetic modification, genetically modified food, and the European practice of GMF labeling. Second, we claim that this type of informing makes it less likely that consumers start to avoid GMF products just because labels make them suspicious of the products. It is further noted that even though some consumers may react to labels this way, labels do not restrict their autonomy of choice. Third, a need for more precise labels indicating the source of the transferred gene is considered. It is found out that such labels are not morally necessary when also non-GMF products are available and no relevant differences (such as differences in price and healthiness) exist between them and GMF products. However, in some other cases more precise labels may be needed for respecting consumers’ autonomy of choice.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Beauchamp, T. L. (2005). Who Deserves Autonomy and Whose Autonomy Deserves Respect? In J. S. Taylor (ed.), Personal Autonomy: New essays on Personal Autonomy and Its Role in Contemporary Moral Philosophy (pp. 310–329). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Beauchamp T. L., J. F. Childress. (2001). Principles of Biomedical Ethics. Fifth Edition. New York: Oxford University Press
Chadwick, R. (2000). Novel, Natural, Nutritious: Towards a Philosophy of Food. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 100, 193–208
Declaration of Helsinki: Ethical Principles for Medical Research Involving Human Subjects. (2003). Retrieved May 23, 2007, from http://www.wma.net/e/policy/b3.htm
Dworkin, G. (1989). The Concept of Autonomy. In J. Christman (ed.), The Inner Citadel (pp. 54–62). New York: Oxford University Press
Frankfurt, H. (1988a). Freedom of the Will and the Concept of the Person. In H. Frankfurt (ed.), The Importance of What We Care About (pp. 11–25). New York: Cambridge University Press
Frankfurt, H. (1988b). Three Concepts of Free Action. In H. Frankfurt (ed.), The Importance of What We Care About (pp. 47–57). New York: Cambridge University Press
Gaskell, G., A. Allansdottir, N. Allum, C. Corchero, C. Fischer, J. Hampel, J. Jackson, N. Kronberger, N., Mejlgard, G. Revuelta, C. Schreiner, S. Stares, H. Torgersen, and W. Wagner (2006), Europeans and Biotechnology in 2005: Patterns and Trends. Retrieved January 9, 2007, from http://www.ec.europa.eu/research/press/2006/pdf/pr1906_eb_64_3_final_report-may2006_en.pdf
GMO Compass (2006a). Processed Foods: GMOs Working Behind the Scenes. Retrieved July 4, 2007, from http://www.gmo-compass.org/eng/grocery_shopping/processed_foods/
GMO Compass (2006b). Fruits and Vegetables: No GMOs in EU. Retrieved July 4, 2007, from http://www.gmo-compass.org/eng/grocery_shopping/fruit_vegetables/
GMO Compass (2007), GMO Labeling: Labelled Goods Hard to Find. Retrieved July 4, 2007, from http://www.gmo-compass.org/eng/regulation/labeling/92.gmo_labeling_labelled_goods.html
Greenpeace UK. (n.d.) The Problems. Retrieved June 20, 2007, from http://www.greenpeace.org.uk/gm/problems
Hagemann K. S., J. Scholderer. (2007). Consumer Versus Expert Hazard Identification: A Mental Models Study of Mutation-bred Rice. Journal of Risk Research, 10, 449–464
Hansen, K. (2004). Does Autonomy Count in Favor of Labeling Genetically Modified Food? Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 17, 67–76
Harms K., P. von Ballmoos, C. Brunold, R. Högen, H. Hesse (2000). Expression of a Bacterial Serine Aceltyltransferace in Transgenic Potato Plant Leads to Increased Levels of Cysteine and Glutathione The Plant Journal, 22, 335–343
Ho, M.-W. (2002). The Unholy Alliance. In G. E. Pence (ed.), The Ethics of Food (pp. 80–95). Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers
Holland D., C. R. Wessells (1998). Predicting Consumer Preferences for Fresh Salmon: The Influence of Safety Inspection and Production Method Attributes. Agricultural and Resource Economics Review, 27, 1–14
Hyun, I. (2001). Authentic Values and Individual Autonomy. Journal of Value Inquiry, 35, 195–208
Kapitan, T. (1999). Free Will Problem. In R. Audi (eds.), The Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy (pp. 326–328). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Klopenhouwer T, H. van den Belt (2003). Regulating Functional Foods in the European Union: Informed Choice Versus Consumer Protection? Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 16, 545–556
Lal P., V. G. Ramachandran, R. Goyal, R. Sharma. (2007). Edible Vaccines: Current Status and Future. Indian Journal of Medical Microbiology, 25, 93–102
NCBE (2006), NCBE Guide: Issues. Retrieved July 3, 2007, from http://www.ncbe.reading.ac.uk/NCBE/GMFOOD/issues.html
NCBE. (2006). NCBE Guide: That Was the Food That Was? Retrieved July 3, 2007, from http://www.ncbe.reading.ac.uk/NCBE/GMFOOD/menu.html
Nuffield Council on Bioethics (1999). Genetically Modified Crops: The Ethical and Social Issues. Retrieved March 17, 2007, from http://www.nuffieldbioethics.org/fileLibrary/pdf/gmcrop.pdf
Nykiforuk C. L., J. G. Boothe, E. W. Murray, R. G. Keon, J. Goren, N. A. Markley, M. M. Moloney (2006). Transgenic Expression and Recovery of Biologically Active Recombinant Human Insulin from Arabidopsis thaliana Seeds. Plant Biotechnology Journal, 4, 77–85
Oshana, M. A. L. (1998). Personal Autonomy and Society. Journal of Social Philosophy, 29, 81–102
Oshana, M. A. L. (2001). The Autonomy Bogeyman. The Journal of Value Inquiry, 35, 209–226
Pascalev, A. (2003). You Are What You Eat: Genetically Modified Foods, Integrity, and Society. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 16, 583–594
Pardo R., C. Midden, J. D. Miller (2002). Attitudes Toward Biotechnology in the European Union. Journal of Biotechnology, 98, 9–24
Pietarinen, J. (1994). Itsemäärääminen ja itsemääräämisoikeus. In J. Pietarinen, V. Launis, J. Räikkä, E. Lagerspetz, M. Rauhala, M. Oksanen (eds.), Oikeus itsemääräämiseen (pp. 17–47). Helsinki: Painatuskeskus
Rachmawati, D., T. Mori, T. Hosaka, F. Takaiwa, E. Inoue, and H. Anzai (2004). “Production and Characterization of Human Lactoferrin in Transgenic Javanice Rice cv Rojolele,” New Directions for a Diverse Planet: Proceedings of the 4th International Crop Science Congress. Retrieved September 27, 2007 from http://www.cropscience.org.au/icsc2004/poster/3/8/1248_rachmawati.htm
Rawwas, M. Y. A. (1996). Consumer Ethics: An Empirical Investigation of the Ethical Beliefs of Austrian Consumers. Journal of Business Ethics, 15, 1009–1019
Regulation (EC) No. 1829/2003 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 22 September 2003 on Genetically Modified Food and Feed. (2003). Retrieved June 11, 2007, from http://europa.eu.int/eur-lex/pri/en/oj/dat/2003/l_268/l_26820031018en00010023.pdf
Robert J. S., F. Baylis (2003). Crossing Species Boundaries. American Journal of Bioethics, 3, 1–13
Rubel A., R. Streiffer (2005). Respecting the Autonomy of European and American Consumers: Defending Positive Labels on GM Foods. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 18, 75–84
Räikkä, J. (1999). On the Morality of Avoiding Information. In V. Launis, J. Pietarinen, J. Räikkä (eds.), Genes and Morality (pp. 63–75). Amsterdam: Rodopi
Shiva, V. (2002). Genetic Engineering and Food Security. In G. E. Pence (ed.), The Ethics of Food (pp. 130–147). Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers
Snow, A. (2003). Genetic Engineering: Unnatural Selection. Nature 424, 619
Streiffer R., A. Rubel (2004). Democratic Principles and Mandatory Labeling of Genetically Engineered Food. Public Affairs Quarterly, 18, 223–248
Taylor, J. S. (2004). Autonomy and Informed Consent: A Much Misunderstood Relationship. The Journal of Value Inquiry, 38, 383–391
Thorpe A., C. Robinson (2004). When Goliaths Clash: US and EU Differences Over the Labeling of Food Products Derived from Genetically Modified Organisms. Agriculture and Human Values, 21, 287–298
Varelius, J. (Forthcoming). On Taylor on Autonomy and Informed Consent. The Journal of Value Inquiry, forthcoming
Wachbroit, R. (2001). Understanding the Consumer’s Right to Know. Philosophy and Public Policy Quarterly, 21, 25–31
Wolf, S. (1990). Freedom Within Reason. Oxford: Oxford University Press
Acknowledgments
We wish to thank Juha Räikkä and Jukka Varelius at the Department of Philosophy, University of Turku and the three anonymous referees for their helpful comments on a previous version of this article.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Siipi, H., Uusitalo, S. Consumer Autonomy and Sufficiency of GMF Labeling. J Agric Environ Ethics 21, 353–369 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-007-9077-2
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-007-9077-2