Abstract
Kidney donation by young children and the mentally retarded has been supported by court decisions, arguments based on obligations inherent in family relationships, an array of contextual factors, and the principle of beneficence. These justifications for taking organs from people who cannot protect themselves are problematic and must be weighed against our obligation to protect the vulnerable. A compromise solution is presented that strongly protects young children and the mentally retarded but does not abdicate all responsibility to relieve suffering. Guidelines are proposed that prohibit the retrieval of kidneys from young children and the mentally retarded but permit one exception. They would allow retrieval of a kidney when the consequence to a first order relative with whom the donor has a meaningful and valuable relationship is otherwise imminent death. This would be done in accordance with additional guidelines that minimize harm to the donor. Since most patients with end stage renal disease can be maintained on dialysis the need for a kidney to prevent death should be an uncommon occurrence. This compromise is proposed as a solution to a dilemma that exists because two ethical principles are in conflict and one cannot be honored without violating the other.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
American Medical Association, Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs, “The Use of Minors as Organ and Tissue Donors,” Code of Medical Ethics: Opinions on Social Policy Issues, E-2.167, http://www. ama-assn. org/ama/pub/category/8452. html
Biller-Adorno, N., G. J. Agich, K. Doepkens, and H. Schauenburg. “Who Shall be Allowed to Give? Living Organ Donors and the Concept of Autonomy.” Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 22 (2001): 351–368.
Cheyette, C. “Organ Harvests from the Legally Incompetent: An Argument Against Compelled Altruism.” Boston College Law Review 41 (2000): 465–515.
Council of Europe 2002. “Additional Protocol to the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine, on Transplantation of Organs and Tissues of Human Origin.” http://conventions. coe. int/treaty/en/treaties/html/186. htm.
Crouch, R. A., and C. Elliott. “Moral Agency and the Family: The Case of Living Related Organ Transplantation.” Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 8 (1999): 275–287.
Dwyer, J., and E. Vig. “Rethinking Transplantation Between Siblings.” The Hastings Center Report 25 (1995): 7–12.
Fost, N. “Children as Renal Donors.” New England Journal of Medicine 296 (1977): 363–367.
Howe, E. G. “Allowing Patients to Find Meaning Where They Can.” The Journal of Clinical Ethics 13 (2003): 179–187.
Johnson, E. M., J. K. Anderson, C. Jacobs, G. Suh, A. Humar, B. D. Suhr, S. R. Kerr, and A. J. Matas. “Long-Term Follow-up of Living Kidney Donors: Quality of Life After Donation.” Transplantation 67 (1999): 717–721.
Lebit, L. E. “Compelled Medical Procedures Involving Minors and Incompetents and Misapplication of the Substituted Judgment Doctrine.” Journal of Law and Health 7 (1992): 107–130.
The Live Donor Consensus Group. “Consensus Statement on the Live Organ Donor.” Journal of the American Medical Association 284 (2000): 2919–2926.
Mudur, G. “Doctors Take Kidney from Patient Incapable of Giving Consent.” British Medical Journal 318 (1999): 753. http://bmj. com/cgi/eletters/318/7186/753/a.
Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network data as of April 19, 2002 provided by the United Network for Organ Sharing.
Spike, J. “Cultural Diversity and Patients with Reduced Capacity: The Use of Ethics Consultation to Advocate for Mentally Handicapped Persons in Living Organ Donation.” Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 22 (2001): 519–526.
Spital, A. “Should Children Ever Donate Kidneys? Views of U. S. Transplant Centers.” Transplantation 64 (1997): 232-236
Veatch, R. M. “Why Liberals Should Accept Financial Incentives for Organ Procurement.” Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 13 (2003): 19–36.
Weizer, N., A. Weizman, Z. Sapira, A. Yussim, and H. Munitz. “Suicide By Related Kidney Donors Following The Recipients Death.” Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics 51 (1989): 216.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Steinberg, D. Kidney Transplants From Young Children and the Mentally Retarded. Theor Med Bioeth 25, 229–241 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11017-004-3140-z
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11017-004-3140-z