Abstract
In this article, I argue that persons suffering from Body Integrity Identity Disorder (BIID) can give informed consent to surgical measures designed to treat this disorder. This is true even if the surgery seems radical or irrational to most people. The decision to have surgery made by a BIID patient is not necessarily coerced, incompetent or uninformed. If surgery for BIID is offered, there should certainly be a screening process in place to insure informed consent. It is beyond the scope of this work, however, to define all the conditions that should be placed on the availability of surgery. However, I argue, given the similarities between BIID and gender dysphoria and the success of such gatekeeping measures for the surgical treatment of gender dysphoria, it is reasonable that similar conditions be in place for BIID. Once other treatment options are tried and gatekeeping measures satisfied, A BIID patient can give informed consent to radical surgery.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bayne, T., & Levy, N. (2005). Amputees by choice: Body integrity identity disorder and the ethics of amputation. Journal of Applied Philosophy, 1, 75–86.
Becker, A. (2009). Body integrity identity disorder (BIID) and Me. In A. Stirn, A. Thiel, & S. Oddo (Eds.), Body integrity identity disorder: Psychological, neurobiological, ethical and legal aspects (pp. 103–106). Miami: Pabst Science Publishers.
Bensler, J. M., & Paauw, D. (2003). Apotemnophilia masquerading as medical morbidity. Southern Medical Journal, 96(7), 674–676.
Berer, M. (2007). It’s female genital mutilation and should be prosecuted. British Medical Journal, 7608, 1335.
Berger, B. D., Lehrmann, J. A., Larson, G., Alverno, L., & Tsao, C. I. (2005). Nonpsychotic, nonparaphilic self-amputation and the internet. Comprehensive Psychiatry, 46(5), 380–383.
Blanke, O., Morgenthaler, F. D., Brugger, P., & Overney, L. S. (2009). Preliminary evidence for a fronto-parietal dysfunction in able-bodied participants with a desire for limb amputation. Journal of Neuropsychology, 3(2), 181–200.
Blom, R., Hennekam, R., & Denys, D. (2012). Body integrity identity disorder (BIID)—Is the amputation of healthy limbs ethically justified? PLoS ONE. 4, http://www.plosone.org Accessed 23 February 2014.
Buchanan, A., & Brock, D. (1989). Deciding for others: The ethics of surrogate decision making. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cash, T. F., & Smolak, L. (2011). Body imagine: A handbook of science, practice and prevention. New York: The Guilford Press.
Charland, L. (2001). Mental competence and value: The problem of normativity in the assessment of decisional capacity. Psychiatry, Psychology, and Law, 2, 135–145.
Craimer, A. (2009). The relevance of identity in responding to BIID and the misuse of causal explanation. American Journal of Bioethics., 1, 53–55.
Culver, C. M., & Gert, B. (2004). Competence. In J. Radden (Ed.), The philosophy of psychiatry: A companion (pp. 258–270). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Dyer, C. (2000). Surgeon amputated healthy legs. British Medical Journal, 320(7231), 332.
Elliott, C. (2000). A new way to be mad. Atlantic Monthly, 286(6), 72–84.
Elliott, T. (2009). Body dysmorphic disorder, radical surgery and the limits of consent. Medical Law Review, 17, 149–182.
Faden, R., & Beauchamp, T. (1986). A theory and history of informed consent. New York: Oxford University Press.
First, M. (2005). Desire for amputation of a limb: Paraphilia, psychosis, or a new type of identity disorder. Psychological Medicine, 35, 919–928.
First, M., & Fisher, C. (2012). Body integrity identity disorder: The persistent desire to acquire a disability. Pschopathology, 45(1), 3–14.
Freedman, B. (1981). Competence: Marginal and otherwise. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 4(53–72), 53–72.
Gheen, M. (2009). Clear definitions and scientific understanding: Thoughts of an academic physician with BIID. In A. Stirn, A. Thiel, & S. Oddo (Eds.), Body integrity identity disorder: Psychological, neurobiological, ethical and legal aspects (pp. 94–102). Miami: Pabst Science Publishers.
Giummarra, M., Bradshaw, J., Nicholls, M., Hilti, L., & Brugger, P. (2011). Body integrity identity disorder: Deranged body processing, right fronto-parietal dysfunction, and phenomenological experience of body incongruity. Neuropsychological Review, 4, 320–333.
Henig, R. M. (2005). At war with their bodies, they seek to sever limbs. New York Times, 22, F6.
Hilti, L., & Brugger, P. (2010). Incarnation and animation: physical versus representational deficits of body integrity. Experimental Brain Research, 204, 315–326.
Kovacs, J. (2009). Whose identity is it anyway? The American Journal of Bioethics, 1, 44–56.
Lawrence, A. (2006). Clinical and theoretical parallels between desire for limb amputation and gender identity disorder. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 3, 263–278.
Lawrence, A. (2009). Parallels between gender identity disorder and body integrity identity disorder: A review and update. In A. Stirn, A. Thiel, & S. Oddo (Eds.), Body integrity identity disorder: Psychological, neurobiological, ethical and legal aspects (pp. 154–172). Miami: Pabst Science Publishers.
Müller, S. (2009). Body integrity identity disorder (BIID)—Is the amputation of healthy limbs ethically justified? The American Journal of Bioethics, 9(1), 36–43.
O’Connor, S. (2009). My life with BIID. In A. Stirn, A. Thiel, & S. Oddo (Eds.), Body integrity identity disorder: Psychological, neurobiological, ethical and legal aspects (pp. 88–93). Miami: Pabst Science Publishers.
Patrone, D. (2009). Disfigured anatomies and imperfect analogies: Body integrity identity disorder and the supposed right to self-demanded amputation of healthy body parts. Journal of Medical Ethics, 35(9), 541–545.
Roberts, L. W. (2002). Addiction and consent. American Journal of Bioethics, 2, 58–60.
Ryan, C. J. (2009). Out on a limb: The ethical management of body integrity identity disorder. Neuroethics, 2, 21–33.
Schmidt, S. (2009). My life with BIID. In A. Stirn, A. Thiel, & S. Oddo (Eds.), Body integrity identity disorder: Psychological, neurobiological, ethical and legal aspects (pp. 79–81). Miami: Pabst Science Publishers.
Smith, R. C. (2009). Body integrity identity disorder: The surgeon’s perspective. In A. Stirn, A. Thiel, & S. Oddo (Eds.), Body integrity identity disorder: Psychological, neurobiological, ethical and legal aspects (pp. 41–48). Miami: Pabst Science Publishers.
Sorene, E. D., Heras-Palou, C., & Burke, F. D. (2006). Self-amputation of a healthy hand: A case of body integrity identity disorder. Journal of Hand Surgery, 31(6), 593–595.
Sue, P. (1785). Anecdotes Historiques, Literaires et Critiques sur la Medecine, la Chirurgie et la Pharmacie. Paris: Le Boucher.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
White, A. Body Integrity Identity Disorder Beyond Amputation: Consent and Liberty. HEC Forum 26, 225–236 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10730-014-9246-4
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10730-014-9246-4