Abstract
The continuing existence of zoos and their good purposes such as conservation, science, education, and recreation, can be ethically justified only if zoos guarantee the welfare of their animals. The usual criteria for measuring animal welfare in zoos are physical health, long life, and reproduction. This paper looks at these criteria and finds them insufficient. Additional criteria are submitted to expand the range of welfare considerations: natural and abnormal behavior; freedom and choice; and dignity. All these criteria should play a role in analyzing zoo animal welfare and interests but dignity has the overriding part because it impacts on both animal and human interests.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
S. C. Bostock (1993) Zoos and Animals Rights: The Ethics of Keeping Animals Routledge London, New York
Corra, Ema, Corra! Online http://www.uol.com.br/cienciahoje/chdia/n966.htm>, 16th March 2005
H. Hediger (1950) Wild Animals in Captivity Butterworths Scientific Publications London
D. Hancock (1996) “Lions and Tigers and Bears, oh no” G. G. Norton M. Hutchins E. F. Stevens T. R. Maple (Eds) Ethics on the Ark: Ethics, Animal Welfare, and Wildlife Conservation Smithsonian Institution Press Washington 31–37
D. Jamieson (1985) “Against Zoos” P. Winter (Eds) Defence of Animals Basil Blackwell Oxford 108–117
I. Kant (1998) Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals Cambridge University Press Cambridge
R. Lacy (1996) “Culling Surplus Animals for Population Management” G. G. Norton M. Hutchins E. F. Stevens T. R. Maple (Eds) Ethics on the Ark: Ethics, Animal Welfare, and Wildlife Conservation Smithsonian Institution Press Washington 187–194
T. Maple R. McManamon E. Stevens (1996) “Defining the Good Zoo: Animal Care, Maintenance, and Welfare” G. G. Norton M. Hutchins E. F. Stevens T. R. Maple (Eds) Ethics on the Ark: Ethics, Animal Welfare, and Wildlife Conservation Smithsonian Institution Press Washington 219–234
G. Marcel (1971) The Existential Background of Human Dignity Harvard University Press Cambridge
B. Miller D. Biggins A. Vargas M. Hutchins L. Hanebury J. Godbey S. Anderson C. Wemmer J. Oldemeier (1998) “Black-Footed Ferret Reintroduction” D. J. Shepherdson J. D. Mellen M. Hutchins (Eds) Second Nature – Environmental Enrichment for Captive Animals Smithsonian Institution Press Washington and London 97–112
B. Mullan G. Marvin (1999) Zoo Culture University of Illinois Press Urbana
InstitutionalAuthorNamePlato (1997) Defence of Socrates, Euthyphro, Crito Oxford University Press Oxford
M. Stamp Dawkins (1980) Animal Suffering – The Science of Animal Welfare Chapman and Hall London, New York
Z. Veselovsk (2000) _lov_k a zví_e [Man and Animals] Academia Praha
S. M. Wise (2002) Drawing the Line – Science and the Case for Animal Rights Perseus Books Cambridge