Is History as a Science Possible? Historical Durée and the Critique of Positivism
Excerpt
History is not a science, and has little to expect from sciences; it does not explain, and has no method. Better still, history,
about which much has been said for two centuries, does not exist.
—Paul Veyne, Writing History1
Science can work only on what is supposed to repeat itself—that is to say, on what is withdrawn, by hypothesis, from the action
of real time. Anything that is … irreversible in the successive moments of a history eludes science.
—Henri Bergson, Creative Evolution2
1. Introduction In this paper I intend to address an idea I found troubling every time I…