Abstract
The word ``deme'' was coined by the botanists J.S.L. Gilmour and J.W.Gregor in 1939, following the pattern of J.S. Huxley's ``cline''. Its purposewas not only to rationalize the plethora of terms describing chromosomaland genetic variation, but also to reduce hostility between traditionaltaxonomists and researchers on evolution, who sometimes scorned eachother's understanding of species. A multi-layered system of compoundterms based on deme was published by Gilmour and J. Heslop-Harrison in1954 but not widely used. Deme was adopted with a modified meaning byzoologists leading the evolutionary synthesis – Huxley, Simpson, Wright,and Mayr. Connections are shown between Gilmour's ideas around definingthe deme, his role in founding the Systematics Association, and his chapter``Taxonomy and Philosophy'' in the book The New Systematics. Thishistorical episode raises questions about the role of carefully-definedwords in scientific practice.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allen, G.E.: 1978, Thomas Hunt Morgan: The Man and his Science, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Bain, A.: 1870, Logic, Longman's, Green, Reader and Dyer, London.
Baker, H.G.: 1952, 'The Ecospecies – Prelude to Discussion', Evolution 6, 61–68.
Baker, J.R.: 1976, 'Julian Sorell Huxley', Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society of London 22, 207–238.
Birdsell, J.B.: 1972, 'The Problem of the Evolution of Human Races: Classification or Clines?', Social Biology 19, 136–162.
Botany Archives: Botany Library, British Natural History Museum, London.
Bremekamp, C.E.B.: 1939, 'Phylogenetic Interpretations and Genetic Concepts in Taxonomy', Chronica Botanica 5, 398–403.
Briggs, D. and Walters, S.M.: 1969, Plant Variation and Evolution, Weidenfeld & Nicholson, London.
Briggs, D. and Walters, S.M.: 1984, Plant Variation and Evolution, 2nd edn., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Briggs, D. and Block, M.: 1981, 'An Investigation into the Use of the “Deme” Terminology', New Phytologist 89, 729–735.
Camp, W.H. and Gilly, C.L.: 1943, 'The Structure and Origin of Species', Brittonia 4, 323–385.
Carter, G.S.: 1951, Animal Evolution: A Study of Recent Views of its Causes, Sidgwick and Jackson, London.
Cockayne, L. and Allan, H.H.: 1927, 'The Bearing of Ecological Studies in New Zealand on Botanical Taxonomic Conceptions and Procedure', Journal of Ecology 15: 234–277.
Committee on Comparative Systematics of the Association for the Study of Systematics in Relation to General Biology, Minutes [1937–1938] (manuscript volume), Library of the British Natural History Museum, Z.89oA.
Danser, H.B.: 1929, 'Ñber die Begriffe Komparium, Kommiskuum und Konvivien und über die Entstehungsweise der Konvivien', Genetica 11, 399–450.
Darlington, C.D.: 1951, 'Do the Chromosomes Fit the Species?' Nature 167, 662–663.
Dean, J.P.: 1979, 'Controversy over Classification: A Case Study from the History of Botany', in B. Barnes and S. Shapin (eds.), Natural Order: Historical Studies in Scientific Culture, Sage, London, pp. 211–230.
Dean, J.P.: 1980, A Naturalistic Model of Classification and Its Relevance to Some Controversies in Botanical Systematics, 1900–1950, dissertation, University of Edinburgh.
Dickinson, T.A. and Phipps, J.B.: 1985, 'studies in Crataegus L. (Rosaceae:Maloideae). XIII. Degree and Pattern of Phenotypic Variation in Crataegus sect. Crus-galli in Ontario', Systematic Botany 10, 322–337.
Dingle, H.: 1938, 'The Rational and Empirical Elements in Physics', Philosophy (The Journal of the British Insititute of Philosophy) 13, 148–165.
Du Rietz, G.E.: 1930, 'The Fundamental Units of Biological Taxonomy', Svensk Botanisk Tidskrift 24, 333–428.
Farris, J.M.: 1977, 'On the Phenetic Approach to Vertebrate Classification', in M.K. Hecht, P.C. Goody and B.M. Hecht (eds.), Major Patterns of Vertebrate Evolution, Plenum Press, New York, pp. 823–850.
Fositer, C.E.: 1981, 'James Wyllie Gregor', Royal Society of Edinburgh Yearbook, pp. 21–22.
Fowler, T.: 1904, Elements of Inductive Logic, 6th edn., Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Gilmour Correspondence, Archives of Directors of the Cambridge Botanical Garden (most items have been transferred to Cambridge University Library).
Gilmour Papers, Cambridge University Library.
Gilmour, J.S.L.: 1935, 'The General Problem', Proceedings of the Linnean Society of London 147, 103.
Gilmour, J.S.L.: 1936, 'Whither Taxonomy?' [abstract], Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, p. 417.
Gilmour, J.S.L.: 1937, 'A Taxonomic Problem', Nature 139, 1040–1042 [reprinted in 1976 and 1989].
Gilmour, J.S.L.: 1938, Diary (two bound manuscript volumes) Gilmour Papers (Additional MSS 8638, Box 1), Cambridge University Archives.
Gilmour, J.S.L.: 1940, 'Taxonomy and Philosophy', in J.S. Huxley (ed.), The New Systematics, Clarendon Press, Oxford, pp. 461–474.
Gilmour, J.S.L.: 1951, 'The Development of Taxonomic Theory Since 1851', Nature 168, 400–402.
Gilmour, J.S.L.: 1960, 'The Deme Terminology', Scottish Plant Breeding Station Report, 99–105.
Gilmour, J.S.L.: 1976, 'Two Early Papers on Classification', Classification Society Bulletin 3, 2–15.
Gilmour, J.S.L.: 1989, 'Two Early Papers on Classification' [reprint of Gilmour 1976], Plant Systematics and Evolution 167, 97–107.
rGilmour, J.S.L. and Gregor, J.W.: 1939, 'Demes: A Suggested New Terminology', Nature 144, 333.
Gilmour, J.S.L. and Heslop-Harrison, J.: 1954, 'The Deme Terminology and the Units of Micro-evolutionary Change', Genetica 27, 147–161.
Gilmour, J.S.L. and Turrill, W.B.: 1941, 'The Aim and Scope of Taxonomy', Chronica Botanica 6, 217–219.
Godwin, H.: 1985, Cambridge and Clare, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Gregor, J.W.: 1930, 'Experiments on the Genetics of Wild Populations. I. Plantago maritima L.', Journal of Genetics 2, 19–27.
Gregor, J.W.: 1931, 'The Experimental Delimitation of Species', New Phytologist 30, 204–217.
Gregor, J.W.: 1939, 'Experimental Taxonomy IV. Population Differentiation in North American and European Sea Plantains Allied to Plantago maritima L.', New Phytologist 38, 293–322.
Gregor, J.W. and Watson, P.J.: 1954, 'some Observations and Reflexions Concerning the Patterns of Intraspecific Differentiation', New Phytologist 53, 291–300.
Hagen, J.B.: 1982, Experimental Taxonomy, 1930–1950: The Impact of Cytology, Ecology, and Genetics on Ideas of Biological Classification, dissertation, Oregon State University.
Hagen, J.B.: 1984, 'Experimental Taxonomy 1920–1950', Journal of the History of Biology 17, 249–270.
Hayata, B.: 1920, Icones Plantarum Formosanarum nec non et contributiones ad Floram Formosanum: or, Icones of the Plants of Formosa, Bureau of Productive Industries, Government of Formosa, Taihoku, vol. 10.
Heslop-Harrison, J.: 1953, New Concepts in Flowering Plant Taxonomy, Heinemann, London.
Hubbard, C.E.: 1971, 'William Bertram Turrill', Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society 17, 689–701.
Huxley, J.S.: 1936, 'Natural Selection and Evolutionary Progress', Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science 106, 81–100.
Huxley, J.S.: 1938a, 'Clines: An Auxiliary Taxonomic Principle', Nature 142, 219–220.
Huxley, J.S.: 1938b, 'Clines: An Auxiliary Method in Taxonomy', Bijdragen tot de Dierkunde 27, 491–520.
Huxley, J.S.: 1942, Evolution: TheModern Synthesis, G. Allen & Unwin, London (also Harper & Brothers, New York, 1943).
Huxley, J.S., Wells, H.G. and Wells, G.P.: 1931, The Science of Life, Cassell, London.
Jevons, W.S.: 1883, The Principles of Science: A Treatise on Logic and Scientific Method, Macmillan, London.
Johnstone, J.: 1914, The Philosophy of Biology, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Keller, E.F. and Lloyd, E.A.: 1992, 'Introduction', in E.F. Keller and E.A. Lloyd (eds.), Keywords in Evolutionary Biology, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, pp. 1–6.
Kew Review: 1939, 'Review of the Work of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, During 1938', Bulletin of Miscellaneous Information of Royal Botanic Gardens 1938, Appendix I.
Marsden-Jones, E.M. and Turrill, W.B.: 1928a, 'Researchers on Silene maritima and S. vulgaris: I.', Kew Bulletin, 1–17.
Marsden-Jones,.M. and Turrill, W.B.: 1928b, 'A Tetraploid Saxifraga of Known Origin', Nature 122, 58.
Marsden-Jones, E.M. and Turrill, W.B.: 1930, 'Report on the Transplant Experiments of the British Ecological Society at Potterne, Wilts.', Journal of Ecology 18, 352–387.
Marsden-Jones, E.M. and Turrill,W.B.: 1957, The Bladder Campions, Ray Society, London.
Mason, H.L.: 1950, 'Taxonomy, Systematic Botany and Biosystematics', Madroño (Journal of the California Botanical Society) 10, 193–208.
Mayr, E.: 1978, 'Origin and History of Some Terms', Systematic Zoology 27, 83–88.
Mayr, E., Linsley, E.G. and Usinger, R.L.: 1953, Methods and Principles of Systematic Zoology, McGraw-Hill, New York.
Mercier,.A.: 1912, A New Logic, Heinemann, London.
Mill, J.S.: 1843, A System of Logic, J.W. Parker, London.
Müntzing, A., Tedin, O. and Turesson, G.: 1931, 'Field Studies and Experimental Methods in Taxonomy', Hereditas 15, 1–12.
Raunkiaer, C.: 1934, The Life Forms of Plants and Statistical Plant Geography, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Read, C.: 1898, Logic, Deductive and Inductive, G. Richards, London.
Ritchie, A.D.: 1923, Scientific Method, Harcourt, Brace, New York.
Schiller, F.C.S.: 1912, Formal Logic: A Scientific and Social Problem, Macmillan and Co., London.
Shull, G.H.: 1929, 'species Hybridizations Among Old and New Species of Shepherd's Purse', in B.M. Duggar (ed.), Proceedings of the International Congress of Plant Sciences, Ithaca, New York, August 16–23, 1926, 1, 832–888.
Sidgwick, A.: 1901, The Use of Words in Reasoning, Black, London.
Simpson, G.G.: 1953, The Major Features of Evolution, Columbia University Press, New York.
Singer, C.: 1931, A Short History of Biology, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Stearn, W.T.: 1987, 'A Tribute to John Gilmour (1906–1986)', The Garden (Journal of the Royal Horticultural Society) 112, 452–455.
Stearn, W.T.: 1989, 'List of Publications of John S.L. Gilmour', Plant Systematics and Evolution 167, 109–112.
Stebbing, L.S.: 1930, A Modern Introduction to Logic, T.Y. Crowell, New York.
Stebbins, G.L.: 1980, 'Botany and the Synthetic Theory of Evolution', in E. Mayr and W. Provine (eds.), The Evolutionary Synthesis: Perspectives on the Unification of Biology, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Stephen, L.: 1900, The English Utilitarians, Duckworth, London.
Stojanoff, N.: 1936, 'Ñber den Artbegriff und die Aussichten der modernen Systematik', Zesde Internationaal Botanisch Congres Amsterdam, 2–7 September, 1935: Proceedings 1, 185–188, E.J. Brill, Leiden.
Systematics Association Archives, Library, University of Durham.
Turesson, G.: 1922a, 'The Species and the Variety as Ecological Units', Hereditas 3, 100–113.
Turesson, G.: 1922b, 'The Genotypical Response of the Plant Species to the Habitat', Hereditas 3, 211–350.
Turrill,W.B.: 1925, 'species', Journal of Botany 63, 359–366.
Turrill, W.B.: 1929, The Plant-Life of the Balkan Peninsula: A Phytogeographical Study, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Turrill, W.B.: 1929, 'Modern Methods in Taxonomic Botany', Bulletin de la Société Botanique de Bulgarie 3, 119–124.
Turrill, W.B.: 1935, 'The Investigation of Plant Species', Proceedings of the Linnean Society of London 147, 104–105.
Turrill,W.B.: 1936, 'Contacts between Plant Classification and Experimental Botany', Nature 137, 563–566.
Turrill,W.B.: 1938, 'The Expansion of Taxonomy with Special Reference to Spermatophyta', Biological Reviews 13, 342–373.
Turrill,W.B.: 1946, 'The Ecotype Concept: A Consideration with Appreciation and Criticism, Especially of Recent Trends', New Phyologist 45, 34–43.
Turrill, W.B.: 1960, 'Obituary of Eric Marsden Marsden-Jones', Proceedings of the Linnean Society 172, 132–133.
Walters, S.M.: 1987, 'Obituary of John Scott Lennox Gilmour', The Linnaean 3, 35–36.
Walters, S.M.: 1989, 'Experimental and Orthodox Taxonomic Categories and the Deme Terminology', Plant Systematics and Evolution 167, 35–41.
Walters, S.M.: 1993, Wild and Garden Plants, Harper Collins, London.
Watson, H.C.: 1847, Cybele Britannica: Or British Plants and Their Geographical Relations, Vol. 1. Longman, London.
Wilmott, A.J.: 1932a, 'Experimental Delimitation of Species', Journal of Botany 70, 49–50.
Wilmott, A.J.: 1932b, 'Correspondence', Journal of Botany 70, 155.
Wilmott, A.J. and Gilmour, J.S.L.: 1936, 'Abstracts of Papers Bearing on the Study of the British Flora', Report of the Botanical Society and Exchange Club of the British Isles 10, 497–507.
Winsor, M.P.: 1995, 'The English Debate on Taxonomy and Phylogeny, 1937–1940', History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 17, 227–252.
Woodger, J.H.: 1929, Biological Principles, Paul, Trench, Trubner, London.
Wright, S.: 1955, 'Classification of the Factors of Evolution', Cold Spring Harbor Symposium on Quantitative Biology 20, 16–24.
Wright, S.: 1956, 'Modes of Selection', American Naturalist 90, 5–24.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Winsor, M.P. Species, Demes, and the Omega Taxonomy: Gilmour and The NewSystematics. Biology & Philosophy 15, 349–388 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006774217770
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006774217770