2009-06-24
Describing zombies
Reply to Derek Allan
Derek,

It sounds like you might be in agreement with Dennett's line:

Contrary to what is presupposed by the zombie idea, consciousness is ‘not a single wonderful separable thing … but a huge complex of many different informational capacities that individually arise for a wide variety of reasons. … It is not a separate organ or a separate medium or a separate talent. He compares health: Supposing that by an act of stipulative imagination you can remove consciousness while leaving all cognitive systems intact — a quite standard but entirely bogus feat of imagination — is like supposing that by an act of stipulative imagination, you can remove health while leaving all bodily functions and powers intact. … Health isn’t that sort of thing, and neither is consciousness.

SEP

Yes, No?