On outlining the shape of depiction

Ratio 18 (1):27–38 (2005)
  Copy   BIBTEX


In this paper, I discuss the account of depiction proposed by Robert Hopkins in his book Picture, Image and Experience. I first briefly summarise Hopkins’s account, according to which we experience depictions as resembling their objects in respect of outline shape. I then ask whether Hopkins’s account can perform the explanatory tasks required of an adequate account of depiction. I argue that there are at least two reasons for which Hopkins’s account of depiction is inadequate. Firstly, the notion of outline shape, as Hopkins presents it, is inconsistent. Moreover, I argue that, while a consistent construal of outline shape is possible, Hopkins’s account becomes indistinguishable from previous accounts of depiction under any such construal. Second, I argue that, however it is construed, the notion of outline shape is unable to explain one of the central features which Hopkins himself insists any successful account of depiction must explain.

Similar books and articles

Explaining depiction.Robert Hopkins - 1995 - Philosophical Review 104 (3):425-455.
Resemblance and misrepresentation.Robert Hopkins - 1994 - Mind 103 (412):421-438.
Depicting Depictions.René Jagnow - 2016 - Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 98 (S1):453-479.
Resemblance As Repleteness: A Solution To Goodman’s Problem.Daniel Barnes - 2006 - Postgraduate Journal of Aesthetics 3 (2):59-65.
Understanding Resemblance in Depiction: What Can we Learn from Wittgenstein?Elisa Caldarola - 2013 - Aisthesis: Pratiche, Linguaggi E Saperi Dell’Estetico 6 (1):239-253.
Beyond Resemblance.Gabriel Greenberg - 2013 - Philosophical Review 122 (2):215-287.
Resemblance, Restriction, and Content‐Bearing Features.John Dilworth - 2005 - Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 63 (1):67–70.
Defining depiction.Ben Blumson - 2009 - British Journal of Aesthetics 49 (2):143-157.
Canny resemblance.Catharine Abell - 2009 - Philosophical Review 118 (2):183-223.
Picture, image and experience. [REVIEW]Sonia Sedivy - 2001 - Philosophical Review 110 (3):472-475.


Added to PP

362 (#48,941)

6 months
94 (#37,474)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Catharine Abell
Oxford University

Citations of this work

Depiction.John Hyman & Katerina Bantinaki - 2017 - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
Pictorial representation.John Kulvicki - 2006 - Philosophy Compass 1 (6):535–546.
Idealist Origins: 1920s and Before.Martin Davies & Stein Helgeby - 2014 - In Graham Oppy & Nick Trakakis (eds.), History of Philosophy in Australia and New Zealand. Dordrecht, Netherlands: Springer. pp. 15-54.
The Epistemic Misuse & Abuse of Pictorial Caricature.Christy Mag Uidhir - 2013 - American Philosophical Quarterly 50 (2):137-152.

View all 6 citations / Add more citations

References found in this work

Perspective, Convention and Compromise.Robert Hopkins - 2003 - In Heiko Hecht, Margaret Atherton & Robert Schwartz (eds.), Looking Into Pictures: an interdisciplinary approach to pictorial space. MIT Press. pp. 145-165.

Add more references