American Political Science Review 99 (1):45-60 (2005)
Two arguments apparently support the thesis that collective identity presupposes an Other: the recognition argument, according to which seeing myself as a self requires recognition by an other whom I also recognize as a self (Hegel); and the dialogic argument, according to which my sense of self can only develop dialogically (Taylor). But applying these arguments to collective identity involves a compositional fallacy. Two modern ideologies mask the particularist thesis’s falsehood. The ideology of indivisible state sovereignty makes sovereignty as such appear particularistic by fusing “internal” with “external” sovereignty; nationalism imagines national identity as particularistic by linking it to sovereignty. But the concatenation of internal sovereignty, external sovereignty, and nation is contingent. Schmitt’s thesis that “the political” presupposes an other conflates internal and external sovereignty, while Mouffe’s neo-Schmittianism conflates difference (Derrida) with alterity. A shared global identity may face many obstacles, but metaphysical impossibility and conceptual confusion are not among them.
|Keywords||collective identity sovereignty recognition difference solidarity Carl Schmitt Jacques Derrida|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
Democracy, Citizenship and the Bits in Between.Sarah Fine - 2014 - In Richard Bellamy & Madeleine Kennedy-Macfoy (eds.), Citizenship. Routledge. pp. 623-640.
Iniuria Migrandi: Criminalization of Immigrants and the Basic Principles of the Criminal Law. [REVIEW]Alessandro Spena - 2014 - Criminal Law and Philosophy 8 (3):635-657.
Two Cheers for Cosmopolitanism: Cosmopolitan Solidarity as Second-Order Inclusion.Max Pensky - 2007 - Journal of Social Philosophy 38 (1):165–184.
Solidarity and the Universal Declaration on Bioethics and Human Rights.D. Gunson - 2009 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 34 (3):241-260.
Democracy, Citizenship and the Bits in Between.Sarah Fine - 2011 - Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 14 (5):623-640.
Similar books and articles
Identity Trouble: Disidentification and the Problem of Difference.Josè Medina - 2003 - Philosophy and Social Criticism 29 (6):655-680.
After Sovereignty: On the Question of Political Beginnings.Charles Barbour & George Pavlich (eds.) - 2010 - Routledge.
Kurios George and the Sovereign State.Jeffrey Paris - 2004 - Radical Philosophy Review 7 (2):115-134.
Self-Reference of the Constitutional State: A Systems Theory Interpretation of the Kelsen-Schmitt Debate.Jiří Přibáň - 2011 - Jurisprudence 2 (2):309-328.
Feminist Praxis Challenges the Identity Question: Toward New Collective Identity Metaphors.María Martínez González - 2008 - Hypatia 23 (3):pp. 22-38.
Justifying Coercive and Non-Coercive Intervention: Strategic and Humanitarian Arguments.Rory J. Conces - 2001 - Acta Analytica 16 (27):133-52.
Liberal Recognition for Identity? Only for Particularized Ones.Sahar Akhtar - 2011 - Politics, Philosophy and Economics 10 (1):66-87.
Global Feminism and Transformative Identity Politics.Allison Weir - 2008 - Hypatia 23 (4):pp. 110-133.
Solidarity After Identity Politics: Hannah Arendt and the Power of Feminist Theory.Amy Allen - 1999 - Philosophy and Social Criticism 25 (1):97-118.
Two Conceptions of State Sovereignty and Their Implications for Global Institutional Design.Miriam Ronzoni - 2012 - Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 15 (5):573-591.
Post-National Citizenship Without Post-National Identity? A Case Study of UK Immigration Policy and Intra-EU Migration.Katherine E. Tonkiss - 2013 - Journal of Global Ethics 9 (1):35-48.
The "World" of the Enlightenment to Come.Jacques Derrida - 2003 - Research in Phenomenology 33 (1):9-52.
"One Nation … Indivisible": Jacques Derrida on the Autoimmunity of Democracy and the Sovereignty of God.Michael Naas - 2006 - Research in Phenomenology 36 (1):15-44.
Added to index2012-01-07
Total downloads45 ( #112,892 of 2,153,864 )
Recent downloads (6 months)10 ( #67,931 of 2,153,864 )
How can I increase my downloads?