Philosophical Review 93 (4):553-567 (1984)

P. T. Geach, notoriously, holds the Relative Identity Thesis, according to which a meaningful judgment of identity is always, implicitly or explicitly, relative to some general term. ‘The same’ is a fragmentary expression, and has no significance unless we say or mean ‘the same X’, where ‘X’ represents a general term (what Frege calls a Begriffswort or Begriffsausdruck). (P. T. Geach, Mental Acts (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1957), p. 69. I maintain that it makes no sense to judge whether things are ‘the same’, or remain ‘the same’, unless we add or understand some general term - ‘the same F’. (P. T. Geach, Reference and Generality, third Edition (Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, 1980), pp. 63f. I am arguing for the thesis that identity is relative. When one says ‘x is identical with y’, this, I hold, is an incomplete expression; it is short for ‘x is the same A as y’, where ‘A’ represents some count noun understood from the context of utterance - or else, it is just a vague expression of a half-formed thought. (P. T. Geach, ‘Identity,’ Review of Metaphysics 21 (1967-8), p. 3.) One of the ways Geach seeks to support this is by tying it to the well nigh universally admired Fregean thesis about cardinality
Keywords Analytic Philosophy  Contemporary Philosophy  General Interest
Categories (categorize this paper)
DOI 10.2307/2184827
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Request removal from index
Revision history

Download options

PhilArchive copy

Upload a copy of this paper     Check publisher's policy     Papers currently archived: 71,199
Through your library

References found in this work BETA

No references found.

Add more references

Citations of this work BETA

Monism.Jonathan Schaffer - 2008 - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
Composition as Identity: Part 2.Meg Wallace - 2011 - Philosophy Compass 6 (11):817-827.
Relative Identity.Harry Deutsch - 2008 - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

View all 18 citations / Add more citations

Similar books and articles

Ascriptivism.P. T. Geach - 1960 - Philosophical Review 69 (2):221-225.
Geach and Relative Identity [with Rejoinder and Reply].Fred Feldman & P. T. Geach - 1968 - Review of Metaphysics 22 (3):547 - 561.
The Frege‐Geach Point.Paul Horwich - 2005 - Philosophical Issues 15 (1):78–93.
Quasi-Realism, Negation and the Frege-Geach Problem.Nicholas Unwin - 1999 - Philosophical Quarterly 49 (196):337-352.
What is the Frege-Geach Problem?Mark Schroeder - 2008 - Philosophy Compass 3 (4):703-720.
Geach on Generalization.Charles Sayward - 2002 - Dialogue 41 (2):221-.


Added to PP index

Total views
200 ( #58,943 of 2,517,922 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
4 ( #167,427 of 2,517,922 )

How can I increase my downloads?


My notes