The Puzzle of Historical Criticism

Christopher Bartel
Appalachian State University
Works of fiction are often criticized for their historical inaccuracies. But this practice poses a problem: why would we criticize a work of fiction for its historical inaccuracy given that it is a work of fiction? There is an intuition that historical inaccuracies in works of fiction diminish their value as works of fiction; and yet, given that they are works of fiction, there is also an intuition that such works should be free from the constraints of historical truth. The puzzle of historical criticism is that these intuitions are obviously in conflict, and yet we wish to give up neither. In this essay, I address the shortcomings of two seemingly intuitive strategies for solving the puzzle: the puzzle cannot be solved by appealing to historical constraints of a work’s genre, nor can it be explained as an instance of imaginative resistance. Given the failure of these two strategies, I suggest that there is no easy way to account for our conflicting intuitions and that the puzzle is deserving of greater attention.
Keywords Aesthetics  Literature  Fiction  Historical inaccuracy  Truth in fiction  imaginative resistance
Categories (categorize this paper)
DOI 10.1111/j.1540-6245.2012.01513.x
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Request removal from index
Revision history

Download options

Our Archive
Through your library

References found in this work BETA

No references found.

Add more references

Citations of this work BETA

The Puzzle of Factual Praise.John Holliday - 2017 - Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 75 (2):169-179.

Add more citations

Similar books and articles


Added to PP index

Total downloads
68 ( #96,107 of 2,293,879 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
7 ( #73,567 of 2,293,879 )

How can I increase my downloads?

Monthly downloads

My notes

Sign in to use this feature