The Monoamine Oxidase A (MAOA) Genetic Predisposition to Impulsive Violence: Is It Relevant to Criminal Trials?
Neuroethics 6 (2):287-306 (2013)
In Italy, a judge reduced the sentence of a defendant by 1 year in response to evidence for a genetic predisposition to violence. The best characterized of these genetic differences, those in the monoamine oxidase A (MAOA), were cited as especially relevant. Several months previously in the USA, MAOA data contributed to a jury reducing charges from 1st degree murder (a capital offence) to voluntary manslaughter. Is there a rational basis for this type of use of MAOA evidence in criminal court? This paper will review in context recent work on the MAOA gene–environment interaction in predisposing individuals to violence and address the relevance of such findings to murder trials. Interestingly, the MAOA genetic variants impact future violence and aggression only when combined with the adverse environmental stimuli of childhood maltreatment. Thus nature and nurture interact to determine the individual’s risk. Based on current evidence, I argue there is a weak case for mitigation. But should future experiments confirm the hypothesis that individual differences in impulse control and response to provocation found in MAOA-L men (without abuse) are significantly magnified when combined with childhood maltreatment, the case could turn into a stronger one
|Keywords||Violence Genetic predisposition MAOA Monoamine Oxidase A Criminal responsibility Neuroethics Gene × environment interaction|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
Human Genetics and Politics as Mutually Beneficial Resources: The Case of the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Anthropology, Human Heredity and Eugenics During the Third Reich.Sheila Faith Weiss - 2006 - Journal of the History of Biology 39 (1):41-88.
Risky Individuals and the Politics of Genetic Research Into Aggressiveness and Violence.Elisa Pieri & Mairi Levitt - 2008 - Bioethics 22 (9):509-518.
Citations of this work BETA
A Recap on Italian Neurolaw: Epistemological and Ethical Issues.Elisabetta Sirgiovanni, Gilberto Corbellini & Cinzia Caporale - forthcoming - Mind and Society.
Similar books and articles
Genes, Environment and Responsibility for Violent Behaviour:‘Whatever Genes One has It is Preferable That You Are Prevented From Going Around Stabbing People’.Mairi Levitt - unknown
From a Genetic Predisposition to an Interactive Predisposition: Rethinking the Ethical Implications of Screening for Gene-Environment Interactions.James Tabery - 2009 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 34 (1):27-48.
The 'Warrior Gene' and the Mãori People: The Responsibility of the Geneticists.Laurence Perbal - 2013 - Bioethics 27 (7):382-387.
Dysfunction in the Neural Circuitry of Emotion Regulation—A Possible Prelude to Violence.Richard J. Davidson - unknown
Some Reflections on Sex Differences in Aggression and Violence.Stephen C. Maxson - 1999 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 22 (2):232-233.
Genes, Electrotransmitters, and Free Will.Patricia S. Greenspan - 2001 - In Patricia S. Greenspan, David Wasserman & Robert Wachbroit (eds.), Genetics and Criminal Behavior: Methods, Meanings, and Morals. Cambridge University Press.
The Ethics of Force: Against Aggression and Violence.R. G. Apressyan - 2009 - Diogenes 56 (2-3):95-109.
Media Violence and Freedom of Speech: How to Use Empirical Data. [REVIEW]de Bruin Boudewijn - 2008 - Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 11 (5):493-505.
The Impact of Neuroscience and Genetics on the Law: A Recent Italian Case.M. Farisco & C. Petrini - 2012 - Neuroethics 5 (3):317-319.
The Social Construction of Genetic Abnormality: Ethical Implications for Managerial Decisions in the Workplace. [REVIEW]Alan Strudler - 1994 - Journal of Business Ethics 13 (11):839 - 848.
‘‘‘It Could Just Be an Additional Test Couldn’T It?’:Genetic Testing for Susceptibility to Aggression and Violence.Mairi Levitt & Elisa Pieri - unknown
Added to index2011-05-07
Total downloads87 ( #59,357 of 2,164,289 )
Recent downloads (6 months)6 ( #50,899 of 2,164,289 )
How can I increase my downloads?