An inconsistency in direct reference theory

Journal of Philosophy 101 (11):574 - 593 (2004)
George Bealer
Yale University
Direct reference theory faces serious prima facie counterexamples which must be explained away (e.g., that it is possible to know a priori that Hesperus = Phosphorus). This is done by means of various forms of pragmatic explanation. But when those explanations that provisionally succeed are generalized to deal with analogous prima facie counterexamples concerning the identity of propositions, a fatal dilemma results. Either identity must be treated as a four-place relation (contradicting what just about everyone, including direct reference theorists, takes to be essential to identity). Or direct reference theorists must incorporate a view that was rejected in pretty much our first lesson about identity—namely, that Hesperus at twilight is not identical to Hesperus at dawn. One way of the other, the direct reference theory is thus inconsistent with basic principles concerning the logic of identity, which nearly everyone, including direct reference theorists, take as starting points.
Keywords reference  Frege's Puzzle  identity
Categories (categorize this paper)
DOI 10.5840/jphil20041011139
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Request removal from index
Revision history

Download options

Our Archive
External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
Through your library

References found in this work BETA

No references found.

Add more references

Citations of this work BETA

Know-How and Concept Possession.Bengson John & Moffett Marc - 2007 - Philosophical Studies 136 (1):31 - 57.
A Repair of Frege's Theory of Thoughts.Mark Textor - 2009 - Synthese 167 (1):105 - 123.

Add more citations

Similar books and articles

Direct Reference in Thought and Speech.Kirk A. Ludwig - 1993 - Communication and Cognition: An Interdisciplinary Quarterly Journal 26 (1):49-76.
That F.Nathan Salmon - 2008 - Philosophical Studies 141 (2):263 - 280.
The Nameability of Possible Objects.Alberto Voltolini - 1994 - From a Logical Point of View 3:14-33.
Exemplarist Virtue Theory.Linda Zagzebski - 2010 - Metaphilosophy 41 (1-2):41-57.
Public Proper Names, Idiolectal Identifying Descriptions.Stavroula Glezakos - 2009 - Linguistics and Philosophy 32 (3):317-326.


Added to PP index

Total downloads
227 ( #23,028 of 2,304,035 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
12 ( #43,475 of 2,304,035 )

How can I increase my downloads?

Monthly downloads

My notes

Sign in to use this feature