Thinking and Reasoning 13 (3):273 – 294 (2007)
Laboratory-based studies of problem solving suggest that transfer of solution principles from an analogue to a target arises only minimally without the presence of directive hints. Recently, however, real-world studies indicate that experts frequently and spontaneously use analogies in domain-based problem solving. There is also some evidence that in certain circumstances domain novices can draw analogies designed to illustrate arguments. It is less clear, however, whether domain novices can invoke analogies in the sophisticated manner of experts to enable them to progress problem solving. In the current study groups of novices and experts tackled large-scale management problems. Spontaneous analogising was observed in both conditions, with no marked differences between expertise levels in the frequency, structure, or function of analogising. On average four analogies were generated by groups per hour, with significantly more relational mappings between analogue and target being produced than superficial object-and-attribute mappings. Analogising served two different purposes: problem solving (dominated by relational mappings), and illustration (which for novices was dominated by object-and-attribute mappings). Overall, our novices showed a sophistication in domain-based analogical reasoning that is usually only observed with experts, in addition to a sensitivity to the pragmatics of analogy use.
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
Expert Analogy Use in a Naturalistic Setting.Donald R. Kretz & Daniel C. Krawczyk - 2014 - Frontiers in Psychology 5.
The Interplay of Conflict and Analogy in Multidisciplinary Teams.Susannah Bf Paletz, Christian D. Schunn & Kevin H. Kim - 2013 - Cognition 126 (1):1-19.
Similar books and articles
Is This Problem Likely to Be Solved? A Cognitive Schema of Effective Problem Solving.Raanan Lipshitz, Daphna Leshem Levy & Keren Orchen - 2006 - Thinking and Reasoning 12 (4):413 – 430.
Constrained Semantic Transference: A Formal Theory of Metaphors.Bipin Indurkhya - 1986 - Synthese 68 (3):515 - 551.
Two Ways of Analogy: Extending the Study of Analogies to Mathematical Domains.Dirk Schlimm - 2008 - Philosophy of Science 75 (2):178-200.
Expert and “Novice” Problem Solving Strategies in Chess: Sixty Years of Citing de Groot (1946).Fernand Gobet, Peter McLeod & Merim Bilalić - 2011 - Thinking and Reasoning 14 (4):395-408.
Expert and “Novice” Problem Solving Strategies in Chess: Sixty Years of Citing de Groot (1946).Merim Bilali - 2008 - Thinking and Reasoning 14 (4):395 – 408.
Observation Can Be as Effective as Action in Problem Solving.Magda Osman - 2008 - Cognitive Science 32 (1):162-183.
The Effect of Expertise on Collaborative Problem Solving.Timothy J. Nokes-Malach, Michelle L. Meade & Daniel G. Morrow - 2012 - Thinking and Reasoning 18 (1):32 - 58.
Role of Analogical Reasoning in the Induction of Problem Categories.Denise Dellarosa Cummins - unknown
Strategy Shifts and Expertise in Solving Transformation Rule Problems.Vanessa J. Clarke Koen Lamberts - 1997 - Thinking and Reasoning 3 (4):271 – 290.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads40 ( #127,801 of 2,158,821 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #354,157 of 2,158,821 )
How can I increase my downloads?