Acta Biotheoretica 65 (1):81-85 (2017)
AbstractIn a previous paper recently published in this journal, we argue that the two main theories of carcinogenesis should be considered as compatible, at the metaphysical, epistemological and biological levels. In a reply to our contribution, Bizzarri and Cucina claim we are wrong since SMT and TOFT are opposite and incompatible paradigms. Here, we show that their arguments are not satisfactory. Indeed, the authors go through the same mistakes that we already addressed. In particular, they confuse reductionism, as an ontological frame, and genetic determinism, as a causal pathway. Beside, they make an inadequate use of the Kuhnian notion of paradigm shift. Finally, we confirm our previous conclusion: there is no strong argument to totally abandon the somatic mutation theory. It describes a partial causal pathway, compatible with the one proposed by TOFT.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
References found in this work
The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.Thomas Samuel Kuhn - 1962 - Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.David Bohm - 1964 - Philosophical Quarterly 14 (57):377-379.
Citations of this work
Evidence Amalgamation, Plausibility, and Cancer Research.Marta Bertolaso & Fabio Sterpetti - 2019 - Synthese 196 (8):3279-3317.
Similar books and articles
SMT and TOFT: Why and How They Are Opposite and Incompatible Paradigms.Mariano Bizzarri & Alessandra Cucina - 2016 - Acta Biotheoretica 64 (3):221-239.
SMT or TOFT? How the Two Main Theories of Carcinogenesis Are Made Incompatible.Baptiste Bedessem & Stéphanie Ruphy - 2015 - Acta Biotheoretica 63 (3):257-267.
The Mind-Cancer Relation. Clinical Aspects And Neurobio-Chemiopsychological Correlates.Mariano Bizzarri, Roberto Facco, Fausto Chiriatti, Alessandra Cucina & Tommaso Ielapi - 1997 - Anthropology and Philosophy 2 (1):27-42.
MASNOVO prof. O.- Estetica di B. Croce. [REVIEW]Bizzarri Bizzarri - 1915 - Rivista di Filosofia Neo-Scolastica 7:I:94.
SMT or TOFT? How the Two Main Theories of Carcinogenesis Are Made Incompatible.Angélique Stéphanou & Nicolas Glade - 2015 - Acta Biotheoretica 63 (3):257-267.
Nonstandard Representation Theory of Standard Operators Defined on the Space of Bochner Integrable Functions.Laurent Vanderputten - 2002 - Mathematical Logic Quarterly 48 (3):379-390.
An Inhomogeneous Space–Time Patching Model Based on a Nonlocal and Nonlinear Schrödinger Equation.Christine C. Dantas - 2016 - Foundations of Physics 46 (10):1269-1292.
La Cucina Medievale: Lessico, Storia, Preparazioni. [REVIEW]Wendy Pfeffer - 2012 - The Medieval Review 4.
Classical Foundations of Quantum Groups.Christian Fronsdal - 1993 - Foundations of Physics 23 (4):551-569.
La cucina infernale e la mirabile illusione: Il dulcitius di rosvita fra drammaturgia e innografia.Marco Giovini - 2006 - Mediaevalia 27 (1):155-183.
Matter Creation by Geometry in an Integrable Weyl-Dirac Theory.Mark Israelit - 1999 - Foundations of Physics 29 (8):1303-1322.
Review of Kaufmann, Bergenhotz: Genteknologisk Ordbog. [REVIEW]Annelise Grinsted & Bertha Toft - 1993 - Hermes 11:123-13.