Synthese 161 (2):183-202 (2008)
Proponents of the explanatory gap claim that consciousness is a mystery. No one has ever given an account of how a physical thing could be identical to a phenomenal one. We fully understand the identity between water and H2O but the identity between pain and the firing of C-fibers is inconceivable. Mark Johnston [Journal of philosophy , 564–583] suggests that if water is constituted by H2O, not identical to it, then the explanatory gap becomes a pseudo-problem. This is because all “manifest kinds”—those identified in experience—are on a par in not being identical to their physical bases, so that the special problem of the inconceivability of ‘pain = the firing of C-fibers’ vanishes. Moreover, the substitute relation, constitution, raises no explanatory difficulties: pain can be constituted by its physical base, as can water. The thesis of this paper is that the EG does not disappear when we substitute constitution for identity. I examine four arguments for the EG, and show that none of them is undermined by the move from constitution to identity.
|Keywords||Constitution Identity Water Pain The explanatory gap The firing of C-fibers Manifest kinds Strongly manifest Weakly manifest Natural kind Twin-Earth Necessary constitution|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
From Metaphysics to Ethics: A Defence of Conceptual Analysis.Frank Jackson - 1998 - Oxford University Press.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
No Explanation of Persons, No Explanation of Resurrection: On Lynne Baker’s Constitution View and the Resurrection of Human Persons.James T. Turner Jr - 2014 - International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 76 (3):297-317.
Constitution and the Necessity of Identity.Robert Francescotti - 2005 - Logique Et Analyse 48 (192):311-321.
Identity Over Time, Constitution and the Problem of Personal Identity.Benjamin L. Curtis & Harold W. Noonan - 2015 - In Steven Miller (ed.), The Constitution of Phenomenal Consciousness: Toward a science and theory. John Benjamins. pp. 348-371.
Why Cartesian Intuitions Are Compatible with the Identity Thesis.Christopher S. Hill - 1981 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 42 (December):254-65.
Constitution and Composition: Three Approaches to Their Relation.Simon Evnine - 2011 - Protosociology 27:212-235.
Surviving Resurrection.A. Buckareff Andrei & Wagenen Joel S. Van - 2010 - International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 67 (3):123 - 139.
Experience, Agency and the Self.Richard M. Gaskin - 1988 - Dissertation, University of Oxford (United Kingdom)
What Is a Political Constitution?Graham Gee & Grégoire C. N. Webber - 2010 - Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 30 (2):273-299.
Hypothetical Identities: Explanatory Problems for the Explanatory Argument.Markus I. Eronen - 2014 - Philosophical Psychology 27 (4):571-582.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads204 ( #19,905 of 2,169,644 )
Recent downloads (6 months)7 ( #43,041 of 2,169,644 )
How can I increase my downloads?