Is dialetheism an idealism? The Russellian fallacy and the dialetheist's dilemma

Dialectica 61 (2):235–263 (2007)
Abstract
In his famous work on vagueness, Russell named “fallacy of verbalism” the fallacy that consists in mistaking the properties of words for the properties of things. In this paper, I examine two (clusters of) mainstream paraconsistent logical theories – the non-adjunctive and relevant approaches –, and show that, if they are given a strongly paraconsistent or dialetheic reading, the charge of committing the Russellian Fallacy can be raised against them in a sophisticated way, by appealing to the intuitive reading of their underlying semantics. The meaning of “intuitive reading” is clarified by exploiting a well-established distinction between pure and applied semantics. If the proposed arguments go through, the dialetheist or strong paraconsistentist faces the following Dilemma: either she must withdraw her claim to have exhibited true contradictions in a metaphysically robust sense – therefore, inconsistent objects and/or states of affairs that make those contradictions true; or she has to give up realism on truth, and embrace some form of anti-realistic (idealistic, or broadly constructivist) metaphysics. Sticking to the second horn of the Dilemma, though, appears to be promising: it could lead to a collapse of the very distinction, commonly held in the literature, between a weak and a strong form of paraconsistency – and this could be a welcome result for a dialetheist.
Keywords Dialetheism  Pure and applied semantics  Paraconsistency
Categories (categorize this paper)
DOI 10.1111/j.1746-8361.2007.01101.x
Options
 Save to my reading list
Follow the author(s)
My bibliography
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Revision history
Request removal from index
Download options
Our Archive
Through your library
References found in this work BETA
Counterfactuals.David K. Lewis - 1973 - Blackwell.
Situations and Attitudes.Jon Barwise & John Perry - 1981 - Journal of Philosophy 78 (11):668-691.
Ways of Worldmaking.Nelson Goodman - 1978 - Harvester Press.
The Nature of Necessity.Alvin Plantinga - 1974 - Clarendon Press.

View all 55 references / Add more references

Citations of this work BETA
Dialectic and Dialetheism.Elena Ficara - 2013 - History and Philosophy of Logic 34 (1):35-52.

Add more citations

Similar books and articles
Further Remarks on Truth and Contradiction.Bradley Armour-Garb & JC Beall - 2002 - Philosophical Quarterly 52 (207):217-225.
Incompleteness and Inconsistency.Stewart Shapiro - 2002 - Mind 111 (444):817-832.
Adynaton and Material Exclusion.Francesco Berto - 2008 - Australasian Journal of Philosophy 86 (2):165 – 190.
Yes, Virginia, There Really Are Paraconsistent Logics.Bryson Brown - 1999 - Journal of Philosophical Logic 28 (5):489-500.
Dialetheism, Semantic Pathology, and the Open Pair.Bradley Armour-Garb & James A. Woodbridge - 2006 - Australasian Journal of Philosophy 84 (3):395 – 416.
Against Classical Dialetheism.Wenfang Wang - 2011 - Frontiers of Philosophy in China 6 (3):492-500.
Why and How to Be a Dialetheist.Manuel Bremer - 2008 - Studia Philosophica Estonica 1 (2):208-227.
A Dilemma for Dialetheism.Jason Zarri - 2010 - The Dualist 15 (Spring):21-31.

Monthly downloads

Added to index

2009-01-28

Total downloads

385 ( #6,681 of 2,168,526 )

Recent downloads (6 months)

61 ( #3,229 of 2,168,526 )

How can I increase my downloads?

My notes
Sign in to use this feature


Discussion
Order:
There  are no threads in this forum
Nothing in this forum yet.

Other forums