Philosophical Studies 166 (2):273-284 (2013)
In his book Semantic Relationism, Kit Fine propounds an original and sophisticated semantic theory called ‘semantic relationism’ or ‘relational semantics’, whose peculiarity is the enrichment of Kaplan’s, Salmon’s and Soames’ Russellian semantics (more specifically, the semantic content of simple sentences and the truth-conditions of belief reports) with coordination, “the very strongest relation of synonymy or being semantically the same”. In this paper, my goal is to shed light on an undesirable result of semantic relationism: a report like “Tom believes that Cicero is bald and Tom does not believe that Tully is bald” is correct according to Fine’s provided truth-conditions of belief reports, but its semantic content is (very likely) a contradiction. As I will argue in the paper, even the resort to the notion of token proposition, introduced in Fine’s recent article “Comments on Scott Soames’ ‘Coordination Problems’”, does not suffice to convincingly eliminate the contradiction; moreover, it raises new difficulties
|Keywords||Semantic relationism Coordination Token propositions Belief reports Contradiction|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
Comments on Scott Soames''Coordination Problems'.Kit Fine - 2010 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 81 (2):475-484.
Citations of this work BETA
In Defense of Formal Relationism.Richard G. Heck - 2014 - Thought: A Journal of Philosophy 3 (3):243-250.
Similar books and articles
Belief in Context: Towards a Unified Semantics of De Re and De Se Attitude Reports.Emar Maier - 2006 - Dissertation, Radboud University Nijmegen
A Puzzle About Belief Reports.Kent Bach - 2000 - In K. Jaszczolt (ed.), The Pragmatics of Propositional Attitude Reports. Elsevier.
Pragmatic Attitudes and Semantic Competence (Actitudes Pragmáticas y Competencia Semántica).Maite Ezcurdia - 2004 - Critica 36 (108):55 - 82.
De Re and de Se in Quantified Belief Reports.Emar Maier - 2005 - In Sylvia Blaho, Luis Vicente & Erik Schoorlemmer (eds.), Proceedings of Console Xiii. pp. 211-29.
Logical Foundations for Belief Representation.William Rapaport - 1986 - Cognitive Science 10 (4):371-422.
Is Structural Spacetime Realism Relationism in Disguise? The Supererogatory Nature of the Substantivalism/Relationism Debate.Mauro Dorato - unknown
Two Versions of Millianism.Scott Soames - 2014 - In Analytic Philosophy in America: And Other Historical and Contemporary Essays. Princeton University Press. pp. 231-264.
Misdisquotation and Substitutivity: When Not to Infer Belief From Assent.Joseph G. Moore - 1999 - Mind 108 (430):335-365.
Added to index2012-10-10
Total downloads91 ( #57,137 of 2,172,021 )
Recent downloads (6 months)13 ( #24,564 of 2,172,021 )
How can I increase my downloads?