Can evolution get us off the hook? Evaluating the ecological defence of human rationality

Consciousness and Cognition 33:524-535 (2015)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

This paper discusses the ecological case for epistemic innocence: does biased cognition have evolutionary benefits, and if so, does that exculpate human reasoners from irrationality? Proponents of ‘ecological rationality’ have challenged the bleak view of human reasoning emerging from research on biases and fallacies. If we approach the human mind as an adaptive toolbox, tailored to the structure of the environment, many alleged biases and fallacies turn out to be artefacts of narrow norms and artificial set-ups. However, we argue that putative demonstrations of ecological rationality involve subtle locus shifts in attributions of rationality, conflating the adaptive rationale of heuristics with our own epistemic credentials. By contrast, other cases also involve an ecological reframing of human reason, but do not involve such problematic locus shifts. We discuss the difference between these cases, bringing clarity to the rationality debate.

Similar books and articles

The role of emotions in ecological and practical rationality.Matteo Mameli - 2004 - In Dylan Evans & Pierre Cruse (eds.), Emotion, Evolution and Rationality. Oxford University Press.
The role of emotions in ecological and practical rationality.Matteo Mameli - 2004 - In D. Evans & Pierre Cruse (eds.), Emotion, Evolution, and Rationality. Oxford University Press. pp. 159--178.
Inquiry in to the Russian Ecological Eschatology Ideology.Liang Kun - 2008 - Proceedings of the Xxii World Congress of Philosophy 45:511-525.
China's eco-historian Line in the conceptual framework and research.Li-hua Wang - 2006 - Nankai University (Philosophy and Social Sciences) 2:22-32.
Trust and ecological rationality in a computing context.Jeff Buechner - 2013 - Acm Sigcas Computers and Society 43 (1):47-68.
Beyond positivist ecology: Toward an integrated ecological ethics.Bryan G. Norton - 2008 - Science and Engineering Ethics 14 (4):581-592.
Adaptive illusions: optimism, control and human rationality.Daniel Nettle - 2004 - In Dylan Evans & Pierre Cruse (eds.), Emotion, Evolution and Rationality. Oxford University Press.

Analytics

Added to PP
2015-04-03

Downloads
414 (#48,643)

6 months
112 (#38,275)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author Profiles

Maarten Boudry
University of Ghent
Michael Vlerick
Tilburg University

Citations of this work

Phylogenetic Distribution and Trajectories of Visual Consciousness: Examining Feinberg and Mallatt’s Neurobiological Naturalism.Koji Ota, Daichi G. Suzuki & Senji Tanaka - 2022 - Journal for General Philosophy of Science / Zeitschrift für Allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie 53 (4):459-476.
Critical Thinking and Cognitive Bias.Jeffrey Maynes - 2015 - Informal Logic 35 (2):183-203.
The kantian notion of freedom and autonomy of artificial agency.Manas Sahu - 2021 - Prometeica - Revista De Filosofía Y Ciencias 23:136-149.

View all 9 citations / Add more citations