Abstract
Of these two books by Jon Elster, Making Sense of Marx is the more substantial. In it the most substantial parts of Explaining Technical Change reappear; and in it - in its impoverished conception of contradiction - the most striking omission of ETC takes the heaviest toll. ETC is to a very considerable extent taken up with reviews of other people's work on the economics of technical change. Its Part One survey of the philosophy of social science is very rapid, with little novelty in- tended or offered. The survey is not systematically, or even incessantly, drawn upon in the Part Two discussion of technical change. MSM, by contrast, is a library of penetrating and provocative discussion, which ranks in quality with books by G.A. Cohen and John Roemer or Richard Miller among the number of recent exactingly analytical studies of Marx's theories, and is more comprehensive than any of these.