Adam Smith’s Reconstruction of Practical Reason
Review of Metaphysics 58 (1):81 - 116 (2004)
Abstract
IN THE LAST PART of the Theory of Moral Sentiments, Adam Smith puts his theory in a class with those of his contemporaries Francis Hutcheson and David Hume, namely, the systems that make sentiments the principle of approbation. Despite recognizing important differences with both of them, he thinks that since he has placed the origin of moral sentiments in sympathy, and in particular the fact that we are able to enter into the motives of the agent and get pleasure from finding them appropriate to their cause, sentiments are the foundation of his theory of morals. Many of Smith’s commentators, in fact almost all of the most important studies over the last few years, reaffirm the author’s self-description. However, my aim in this paper is to challenge this view by showing that Smith’s system can also be plausibly seen as a theory of practical reasoning, and in some important aspects very similar to Aristotelian ethics. Surprisingly few scholars have seen this parallel. Laurence Berns, Samuel Fleischacker, Charles Griswold, and Gloria Vivenza are the latest exceptions, identifying several points of coincidence between Adam Smith and Aristotle’s ethics. None of them, however, has tied all these similarities under a unified interpretation, such as the one I propose here: The basic analogy between these theories, and the source of those particular coincidences, is the operation of practical reason. Moreover, and besides the common elements with Aristotle’s ethics, Smith’s reconstruction of practical reason simultaneously announces some of the main features of modern accounts of ethics, such as impartiality and universality as preconditions of moral judgment. The integration of these ancient and modern elements in a single coherent theory allows Smith’s TMS to overcome the insufficiencies and paradoxes of both these traditions, and it constitutes one of the most interesting and challenging proposals of modern ethics.Author's Profile
ISBN(s)
0034-6632
My notes
Similar books and articles
Adam Smith: Self-Command, Practical Reason and Deontological Insights.Maria A. Carrasco - 2012 - British Journal for the History of Philosophy 20 (2):391-414.
The Glasgow Edition of the Works and Correspondence of Adam Smith: Iii: Essays on Philosophical Subjects: With Dugald Stewart's `Account of Adam Smith'.Adam Smith (ed.) - 1980 - Oxford University Press.
The Autonomous Male of Adam Smith, and: Adam Smith in His Times and Ours: Designing the Decent Society, and: Adam Smith: International Perspectives.Charles L. Griswold - 1997 - Journal of the History of Philosophy 35 (4):629-632.
Index to the Works of Adam Smith.Andrew S. Skinner & Knud Haakonssen - 1976 - Oxford University Press.
Adam Smith on morality, justice andthe political constitution of liberty.Maria A. Carrasco - 2008 - Journal of Scottish Philosophy 6 (2):135-156.
Trust as the End of Practical Reason. Justification Procedures.Alessandro Giordani & Paolo Gomarasca - 2012 - In Botturi Francesco (ed.), Understanding Human Experience. Peter Lang.
Adam Smith's Marketplace of Life, by James R. Otteson. Cambridge: Cambridge university press, 2002. Pp. 352. H/b £50.00, $70.00, P/b £19.95, $26.00. [REVIEW]Jack Weinstein - manuscript
Adam Smith and the Classics: The Classical Heritage in Adam Smith's Thought.Gloria Vivenza - 2001 - Oxford University Press.
Adam Smith's theory of language.Marcelo Dascal - 2006 - In Knud Haakonssen (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Adam Smith. Cambridge University Press.
The 'new view' of Adam Smith and the development of his views over time.James E. Alvey - 2007 - In Geoff Cockfield, Ann Firth & John Laurent (eds.), New Perspectives on Adam Smith's the Theory of Moral Sentiments. E. Elgar.
Adam Smith, religion and the scottish enlightenment.Pete Clarke - 2007 - In Geoff Cockfield, Ann Firth & John Laurent (eds.), New Perspectives on Adam Smith's the Theory of Moral Sentiments. E. Elgar. pp. 47--65.
Sympathy and domination : Adam Smith, happiness, and the virtues of Augustinianism.Eric Gregory - 2011 - In Paul Oslington (ed.), Adam Smith as Theologian. Routledge.
Divine action, providence, and Adam Smith's invisible hand.Paul Oslington - 2011 - In Adam Smith as Theologian. Routledge.
Analytics
Added to PP
2011-02-21
Downloads
38 (#309,488)
6 months
1 (#451,398)
2011-02-21
Downloads
38 (#309,488)
6 months
1 (#451,398)
Historical graph of downloads
Author's Profile
Citations of this work
Will the Real A. Smith Please Stand Up!Matthias P. Hühn & Claus Dierksmeier - 2016 - Journal of Business Ethics 136 (1):119-132.
Adam Smith's Sentimentalist Conception of Self-Control.Lauren Kopajtic - 2020 - The Adam Smith Review 12:7-27.
The Unreality Business - How Economics (and Management) Became Anti-philosophical.Matthias P. Hühn - 2015 - Philosophy of Management 14 (1):47-66.
Adam Smith, Anti-Stoic.Michele Bee & Maria Pia Paganelli - 2019 - History of European Ideas 45 (4):572-584.
Adam Smith: Self-Command, Practical Reason and Deontological Insights.Maria A. Carrasco - 2012 - British Journal for the History of Philosophy 20 (2):391-414.