Plagiarism, Cheating and Research Integrity: Case Studies from a Masters Program in Peru
Andres M. Carnero, Percy Mayta-Tristan, Kelika A. Konda, Edward Mezones-Holguin, Antonio Bernabe-Ortiz, German F. Alvarado, Carlos Canelo-Aybar, Jorge L. Maguiña, Eddy R. Segura, Antonio M. Quispe, Edward S. Smith, Angela M. Bayer & Andres G. Lescano
Science and Engineering Ethics 23 (4):1183-1197 (2017)
Abstract
Plagiarism is a serious, yet widespread type of research misconduct, and is often neglected in developing countries. Despite its far-reaching implications, plagiarism is poorly acknowledged and discussed in the academic setting, and insufficient evidence exists in Latin America and developing countries to inform the development of preventive strategies. In this context, we present a longitudinal case study of seven instances of plagiarism and cheating arising in four consecutive classes of an Epidemiology Masters program in Lima, Peru, and describes the implementation and outcomes of a multifaceted, “zero-tolerance” policy aimed at introducing research integrity. Two cases involved cheating in graded assignments, and five cases correspond to plagiarism in the thesis protocol. Cases revealed poor awareness of high tolerance to plagiarism, poor academic performance, and widespread writing deficiencies, compensated with patchwriting and copy-pasting. Depending on the events’ severity, penalties included course failure and separation from the program. Students at fault did not engage in further plagiarism. Between 2011 and 2013, the Masters program sequentially introduced a preventive policy consisting of: intensified research integrity and scientific writing education, a stepwise, cumulative writing process; honor codes; active search for plagiarism in all academic products; and a “zero-tolerance” policy in response to documented cases. No cases were detected in 2014. In conclusion, plagiarism seems to be widespread in resource-limited settings and a greater response with educational and zero-tolerance components is needed to prevent it.My notes
Similar books and articles
Self-plagiarism or appropriate textual re-use?Tracey Bretag & Saadia Mahmud - 2009 - Journal of Academic Ethics 7 (3):193-205.
Electronic media, creativity and plagiarism.Naveed Imran - 2010 - Acm Sigcas Computers and Society 40 (4):25-44.
Exploring Web-Based University Policy Statements on Plagiarism by Research-Intensive Higher Education Institutions.Ewa McGrail & J. Patrick McGrail - 2015 - Journal of Academic Ethics 13 (2):167-196.
On Iranian EFL Undergraduate Students’ Perceptions of Plagiarism.Farzaneh Amiri & Seyyed Ayatollah Razmjoo - 2016 - Journal of Academic Ethics 14 (2):115-131.
A Self-Plagiarism Intervention for Doctoral Students: A Qualitative Pilot Study.Colleen M. Halupa, Erin Breitenbach & Adrian Anast - 2016 - Journal of Academic Ethics 14 (3):175-189.
Plagiarism in Student Research: Responsibility of the Supervisors and Suggestions to Ensure Plagiarism Free Research.Kewal Krishan, Tanuj Kanchan, Neha Baryah & Richa Mukhra - 2017 - Science and Engineering Ethics 23 (4):1243-1246.
Evaluation of an Instructional Activity to Reduce Plagiarism in the Communication Classroom.Nicole Kashian, Shannon M. Cruz, Jeong-woo Jang & Kami J. Silk - 2015 - Journal of Academic Ethics 13 (3):239-258.
Creating a Self-Plagiarism Research Topic Typology through Bibliometric Visualisation.Peter Kokol, Jernej Završnik, Danica Železnik & Helena Blažun Vošner - 2016 - Journal of Academic Ethics 14 (3):221-230.
Academic Plagiarism at the Faculty Level: Legal Versus Ethical Issues and a Case Study.Matthew C. Sonfield - 2014 - Journal of Academic Ethics 12 (2):75-87.
Perceptions of and Attitudes toward Plagiarism and Factors Contributing to Plagiarism: a Review of Studies. [REVIEW]Fauzilah Md Husain, Ghayth Kamel Shaker Al-Shaibani & Omer Hassan Ali Mahfoodh - 2017 - Journal of Academic Ethics 15 (2):167-195.
An Academic Publisher’s Response to Plagiarism.Bruce R. Lewis, Jonathan E. Duchac & S. Douglas Beets - 2011 - Journal of Business Ethics 102 (3):489-506.
Plagiarism in the academic context: A study of Iranian EFL learners.Alireza Ahmadi - 2014 - Research Ethics 10 (3):151-168.
Seven ways to plagiarize: Handling real allegations of research misconduct.Michael C. Loui - 2002 - Science and Engineering Ethics 8 (4):529-539.
Plagiarism: Words and ideas.Mathieu Bouville - 2008 - Science and Engineering Ethics 14 (3):311-322.
“Should It Be Considered Plagiarism?” Student Perceptions of Complex Citation Issues.Dan Childers & Sam Bruton - 2016 - Journal of Academic Ethics 14 (1):1-17.
Analytics
Added to PP
2017-08-02
Downloads
34 (#345,244)
6 months
1 (#447,139)
2017-08-02
Downloads
34 (#345,244)
6 months
1 (#447,139)
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
How Do Chemistry Faculty and Graduate Students Engage in Decision Making on Issues Related to Ethical and Responsible Conduct of Research Including Authorship?Yiyang Gao, Jasmin Wilson & Patricia Ann Mabrouk - 2022 - Science and Engineering Ethics 28 (3):1-26.
Academic Dishonesty in Indonesian College Students: an Investigation from a Moral Psychology Perspective.Sutarimah Ampuni, Naila Kautsari, Meyrantika Maharani, Shabrina Kuswardani & Sukmo Bayu Suryo Buwono - 2020 - Journal of Academic Ethics 18 (4):395-417.
References found in this work
Cheating in Academic Institutions: A Decade of Research.Kenneth D. Butterfield, Linda Klebe Trevino & Donald L. McCabe - 2001 - Ethics and Behavior 11 (3):219-232.
Fostering integrity in research: Definitions, current knowledge, and future directions. [REVIEW]Nicholas H. Steneck - 2006 - Science and Engineering Ethics 12 (1):53-74.
A case for a duty to feed the hungry: GM plants and the third world.Lucy Carter - 2007 - Science and Engineering Ethics 13 (1):69-82.
Scientists Admitting to Plagiarism: A Meta-analysis of Surveys.Vanja Pupovac & Daniele Fanelli - 2015 - Science and Engineering Ethics 21 (5):1331-1352.
Academic Integrity as an Institutional Issue.Patricia Keith-Spiegel & Bernard E. Whitley - 2001 - Ethics and Behavior 11 (3):325-342.