Values as heuristics: a contextual empiricist account of assessing values scientifically

Synthese 201 (6):1-29 (2023)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

Feminist philosophers have discussed the prospects for assessing values empirically, particularly given the ongoing threat of sexism and other oppressive values influencing science and society. Some advocates of such tests now champion a “values as evidence” approach, and they criticize Helen Longino’s contextual empiricism for not holding values to the same level of empirical scrutiny as other claims. In this paper, we defend contextual empiricism by arguing that many of these criticisms are based on mischaracterizations of Longino’s position, overstatements of certain claims, and false dichotomies. Her contextual empiricism not only allows for the empirical support and disconfirmation of values, but Longino explicitly discusses when values can be empirically adjudicated and emphasizes the crucial role of the community for standards of evidence. We support contextual empiricism and elaborate a less direct account of “values as heuristics” by reviewing Longino’s theory of evidence and then using a case study from Elisabeth Lloyd on the biology of female orgasm, demonstrating the disconfirmation of androcentric values in evolutionary science. Within Longino’s and Lloyd’s contextual empiricism, values do not get treated as empirical evidence to be directly assessed by individuals, but rather values are heuristic tools to build models whose use can be validated or invalidated by communities based on their empirical fruitfulness in the logic and pragmatics of research questions in specific historical and cultural contexts.

Other Versions

No versions found

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 97,078

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Analytics

Added to PP
2023-06-14

Downloads
42 (#414,855)

6 months
15 (#317,373)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author Profiles

Christopher ChoGlueck
New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology
Elisabeth Lloyd
Indiana University, Bloomington

Citations of this work

Exploring the socio-ecology of science: the case of coral reefs.Elis Jones - 2024 - European Journal for Philosophy of Science 14 (3):1-32.

Add more citations