Causation and Liability to Defensive Harm

Journal of Applied Philosophy 37 (3):378-392 (2020)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

An influential view in the ethics of self-defence is that causal responsibility for an unjust threat is a necessary requirement for liability to defensive harm. In this article, I argue against this view by providing intuitive counterexamples and by revealing weaknesses in the arguments offered in its favour. In response, adherents of the causal view have advanced the idea that although causally inefficacious agents are not liable to defensive harm, the fact that they may deserve harm can justify harming them in the course of defending oneself. I argue that this strategy is ad hoc and leads to more problems than it solves. Once we allow normative facts outside our account of liability to affect a person's moral protection against harm, the lieability verdicts cannot tell us whether there is a relevant moral asymmetry between the victim and the target of defence. In conclusion, the causal view is wrong and causal responsibility for an unjust threat is not a necessary requirement for liability to defensive harm.

Similar books and articles

Agent-Relative Prerogatives to Do Harm.Jonathan Quong - 2016 - Criminal Law and Philosophy 10 (4):815-829.
What Follows from Defensive Non-Liaibility?Gerald Lang - 2017 - Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 117 (3):231-252.
Liability to Defensive Harm.Jonathan Quong - 2012 - Philosophy and Public Affairs 40 (1):45-77.
Proportionality, Liability, and Defensive Harm.Jonathan Quong - 2015 - Philosophy and Public Affairs 43 (2):144-173.
Defensive Liability Without Culpability.Saba Bazargan-Forward - 2016 - In Christian Coons & Michael Weber (eds.), The Ethics of Self-Defense. New York, NY: Oxford University Press USA.
Civilian Liability.Helen Frowe - 2019 - Ethics 129 (4):625-650.
Causeless complicity.Christopher Kutz - 2007 - Criminal Law and Philosophy 1 (3):289-305.
I—Rights against Harm.Jonathan Quong - 2015 - Aristotelian Society Supplementary Volume 89 (1):249-266.
Liability and risk.David McCarthy - 1996 - Philosophy and Public Affairs 25 (3):238-262.
Self-Defence Against Multiple Threats.Kerah Gordon-Solmon - 2017 - Journal of Moral Philosophy 14 (2):125-133.

Analytics

Added to PP
2019-06-14

Downloads
314 (#58,889)

6 months
159 (#16,194)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Lars Christie
Inland Norway University of Applied Sciences

Citations of this work

Self-Defense.Helen Frowe & Jonathan Parry - 2021 - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy 2021.
Mortal Mistakes.Lars Christie - 2022 - Journal of Moral Philosophy 20 (5-6):395-414.

Add more citations

References found in this work

No references found.

Add more references