Cosmos and History : The Journal of Natural and Social Philosophy 9 (1):73-100 (2013)
AbstractSamuel Butler, a contemporary critic of Charles Darwin, proffered an alternative, vitalistic account of evolution. At the same time, he put into question all modern naturalistic treatments of this fundamental idea which presuppose that evolution is mainly a scientific problem. On the contrary, Butler in effect insists, this extremely vague idea calls for not an `explanation' but rather a fairly comprehensive, plausible story that helps elucidate an inherently complex idea. Butler can thus be read as outlining an anthropomorphic metaphorics that evokes a living Cosmos wherein it might be possible to do justice to the problem which Darwin left unresolved---the problem of heredity. In this picture of the Cosmos Butler links the fundamental notion of organization not to the allegedly universal and immutable `laws of nature,' as the moderns would have it, but rather to dynamically evolving relationships between only more or less stable habits. The variations in extant habits that emergence elicits are moreover the products of quasi-intelligent responses to new challenges from the environment. For Butler follows Lamarck in holding that all organisms possess powers capable of responding to felt needs and/or desires to make alterations in the habits that characterize their modes of existence. He thus in the end effectively bequeaths to his readers a challenge to extend and amplify, if possible, his outline of a promising metaphysical imaginary that can take into account some highly unorthodox conjectures.
Similar books and articles
Was Samuel Butler Mainly Right About Evolution?Murray Code - 2013 - Cosmos and History 9 (1):73-100.
How Right Was Samuel Butler About Evolution? Part II: Why Evolution is Really a Problem for the Humanities.Murray Code - 2014 - Cosmos and History 10 (2):92-120.
On Having Faith in a Living Reason: Or, Why You Can't Get There From Here.Murray Code - 2016 - Cosmos and History 12 (1):1-36.
Book Review:The Notebooks of Samuel Butler. Samuel Butler, Henry Festing Jones. [REVIEW]Sydney Waterlow - 1913 - International Journal of Ethics 23 (4):497-.
The Notebooks of Samuel Butler. Samuel Butler, Henry Festing Jones.Sydney Waterlow - 1913 - International Journal of Ethics 23 (4):497-499.
The Notebooks of Samuel Butler.Samuel Butler & Henry Festing Jones - 1913 - International Journal of Ethics 23 (4):497-499.
The Ideal of Intellectual Integrity, in Life and Literature.Susan Haack - 2005 - New Literary History 36 (3):359-375.
Butler and the Nature of Self-Interest.David Phillips - 2000 - Philosophical and Phenomenological Research 60 (2):421-438.
The Works of the Right Reverend Father in God Joseph Butler, D.C.L., Late Lord Bishop of Durham to Which is Prefixed a Preface, Giving Some Account of the Character and Writings of the Author. [REVIEW]Joseph Butler & Samuel Halifax - 1874 - University Press.
Sex and Gender Through an Analytic Eye: Butler on Freud and Gender Identity.Anna Gullickson '00 - unknown
Judith Butler's Precarious Politics: Critical Encounters.Terrell Carver & Samuel Allen Chambers (eds.) - 2008 - Routledge.
Butler and the Nature of Self-Interest.David Phillips - 2000 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 60 (2):421-438.
Joseph Butler on Forgiveness.Linda Radzik - 2014 - In Johannes Brachtendorf & Stephan Herzberg (eds.), Vergebung: Philosophische Perspektiven auf ein Problemfeld der Ethik. Muenster: Mentis. pp. 139-47.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads