Journal of Medical Ethics 48 (10):779-784 (2022)
AbstractLord Sumption, a former Justice of the Supreme Court, has been a prominent critic of coronavirus restrictions regulations in the UK. Since the start of the pandemic, he has consistently questioned both the policy aims and the regulatory methods of the Westminster government. He has also challenged rationales that hold that all lives are of equal value. In this paper, I explore and question Lord Sumption’s views on morality, politics and law, querying the coherence of his broad philosophy and his arguments regarding coronavirus regulations with his judicial decision in the assisted-dying case of R v Ministry of Justice. In Nicklinson, Lord Sumption argued for restrictions on liberty given the priority of the sanctity of life principle and the protection of others who may be vulnerable, as well as for deference to policy-making institutions in instances of values-based disagreement. The apparent inconsistencies in his positions, I argue, are not clearly reconcilable, and invite critical analysis of his impacts on health law and policy.
Similar books and articles
Power Tends to Corrupt: Lord Acton's Study of Liberty.Christopher Lazarski - 2012 - Northern Illinois University Press.
A Human Rights Debate on Physical Security, Political Liberty, and the Confucian Tradition.Benedict S. B. Chan - 2014 - Dao: A Journal of Comparative Philosophy 13 (4):567-588.
Ethical Points From the SARS Outbreak in Toronto.[author unknown] - 2004 - Journal of Medical Ethics 30 (4):352-352.
The COVID-19 War in Ceramic Arts: Navigating Aesthetic and Symbolic Expressions. Ponimin & Guntur - 2021 - Aisthesis: Pratiche, Linguaggi E Saperi Dell’Estetico 14 (1):81-99.
Relationships Between the Life Satisfaction, Meaning in Life, Hope and COVID-19 Fear for Turkish Adults During the COVID-19 Outbreak. [REVIEW]Zeynep Karataş, Kıvanç Uzun & Özlem Tagay - 2021 - Frontiers in Psychology 12.
Liberty, Public Health Ethics, and Policy Responses to COVID-19.Stephen Holland - 2021 - Humana Mente 14 (40).
Is Liberty Bad for Your Health? Towards a Moderate View of the Robust Coequality of Liberty and Health.M. Allen - 2011 - Public Health Ethics 4 (3):260-268.
Toleration and Liberty of Conscience.Jon Mahoney - 2021 - In Mitja Sardoc (ed.), Handbook of Toleration. Palgrave.
COVID-19 as the Underlying Cause of Death: Disentangling Facts and Values.Maria Cristina Amoretti & Elisabetta Lalumera - 2021 - History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 43 (1):1-4.
Correlates of Psychological Distress Among Pakistani Adults During the COVID-19 Outbreak: Parallel and Serial Mediation Analyses.Farzana Ashraf, Gull Zareen, Aasia Nusrat, Amna Arif & Mark D. Griffiths - 2021 - Frontiers in Psychology 12.
Liberty as Power.Preston King - 1999 - Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 2 (3):1-25.
Security, Liberty and the Myth of Balance: Towards a Critique of Security Politics.Mark Neocleous - 2007 - Contemporary Political Theory 6 (2):131.
Security, Liberty and the Myth of Balance: Towards a Critique of Security Politics.Mark Neocleous - 2007 - Contemporary Political Theory 6 (2):131-149.
Security, Liberty and the Myth of Balance: Towards a Critique of Security Politics.Robyn Eckersley - 2007 - Contemporary Political Theory 6 (2):131-149.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
No citations found.
References found in this work
Socially Constructed Determinants of Health: The Case for Synergies to Arrive at Gendered Global Health Law.Sarah Hawkes & Kent Buse - 2020 - Public Health Ethics 13 (1):16-28.
Legal, Moral and Political Determinants Within the Social Determinants of Health: Approaching Transdisciplinary Challenges Through Intradisciplinary Reflection.John Coggon - 2020 - Public Health Ethics 13 (1):41-47.
Postscript: COVID-19 and the Legal Determinants of Health.John Coggon & Lawrence O. Gostin - 2020 - Public Health Ethics 13 (1):48-49.
A Threshold of Significant Harm (F)or a Viable Alternative Therapeutic Option?Jo Bridgeman - 2018 - Journal of Medical Ethics 44 (7):466-470.
The Wonder of Euthanasia: A Debate That's Being Done to Death.John Coggon - 2013 - Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 33 (2):401-419.