Disputing with Care: Analysing Interviewees' Treatment of Interviewers' Prior Turns in Televised Political Interviews
Discourse Studies 3 (2):203-222 (2001)
AbstractA wide range of previous research has pointed out important interactional features of televised political interviews including the cooperative dimensions to encounters between interviewers and interviewees and the extent to which news interviews differ to everyday conversation. Drawing upon an analysis of 29 televised political interviews broadcast in the UK, this article seeks to build on such work. A preliminary quantitative inspection of the data suggested that a sizeable minority of interviewee responses `hearably' challenged the prior interviewer turn. A conversation analytic approach to the turn-response pairs suggested that whilst a wide range of interviewer turns were potentially vulnerable to such problematizing moves - the challenges made were often boundaried. That is, in making challenges, interviewees typically refrained from developing them in highly personalized terms; they often raised them in passing and, in cases where the interviewee refused to cooperate with interviewers, they typically did so by producing a justification. Further analysis suggested that both interviewers and interviewees did not take the steps to ward off disagreement commonly found in everyday conversation - instead both interviewer and interviewee seemed to orientate to the normality of disagreement. This picture of `boundaried but normalized' challenge was made sense of in terms of different preference structures to those found in everyday talk in which both interviewee and interviewer were understood as skilfully orientating to the normativity of challenges whilst safeguarding the interview structure itself.
Similar books and articles
Impact of age and gender on frequency of interruption in dyadic interviews.Mohammad Almoaily - 2020 - Interaction Studies 21 (2):187-199.
Non-neutrality and argument in the hybrid political interview.Ian Hutchby - 2011 - Discourse Studies 13 (3):349-365.
Neutralism and adversarial challenges in the political news interview.Johanna Rendle-Short - 2007 - Discourse and Communication 1 (4):387-406.
Personalised revision of `failed' questions.Charles Antaki - 2002 - Discourse Studies 4 (4):411-428.
Gaze work in political media interviews.Mats Ekström - 2012 - Discourse and Communication 6 (3):249-271.
Constructing affiliation and solidarity in job interviews.Caroline Lipovsky - 2008 - Discourse and Communication 2 (4):411-432.
Preserving the Respondent’s Standpoint in a Research Interview: Different Strategies of ‘Doing’ the Interviewer. [REVIEW]Francesca Alby & Marilena Fatigante - 2014 - Human Studies 37 (2):239-256.
Extreme case formulations in Spanish pre-electoral debates and English panel interviews.Isabel Iñigo-Mora - 2007 - Discourse Studies 9 (3):341-363.
Mobilizing master narratives through categorical narratives and categorical statements when default identities are at stake.Abha Chatterjee, Marlene Miglbauer & Dorien Van De Mieroop - 2017 - Discourse and Communication 11 (2):179-198.
How Does It Feel to Be a Star?: Identifying Emotions on the Red Carpet.Scott R. Harris & Kerry O. Ferris - 2009 - Human Studies 32 (2):133 - 152.
How Does It Feel to Be a Star?: Identifying Emotions on the Red Carpet.Scott R. Harris & Kerry O. Ferris - 2009 - Human Studies 32 (2):133-152.
Recordability: Resistance and collusion in psychometric interviews with children.Clara Iversen - 2012 - Discourse Studies 14 (6):691-709.
The disaffiliative use of ‘did you know’ questions in Arabic news interviews: The case of Aljazeera’s ‘The Opposite Direction’.Dana Shalash - 2020 - Discourse Studies 22 (5):590-609.
Marketing research interviewers and their perceived necessity of moral compromise.J. E. Nelson & P. L. Kiecker - 1996 - Journal of Business Ethics 15 (10):1107 - 1117.
Address terms in the service of other actions: The case of news interview talk.Steven E. Clayman - 2010 - Discourse and Communication 4 (2):161-183.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Sorry, there are not enough data points to plot this chart.
Citations of this work
`Also' as a Discourse Marker: Its Use in Disjunctive and Disaffiliative Environments.Hansun Zhang Waring - 2003 - Discourse Studies 5 (3):415-436.
References found in this work
No references found.