Vivarium 55 (1-3):60-84 (2017)

In a seminal article, Simo Knuuttila and Anja Inkeri Lehtinen drew attention to a “curious doctrine” holding that contradictories can be true at the same temporal instant, and identified the major defenders of the doctrine as John Baconthorpe, Landolfo Caracciolo, and Hugh of Novocastro. Normann Kretzmann later asserted as fact the suggestion by Knuuttila and Inkeri Lehtinen that the doctrine comes from a misreading of a passage from Aristotle’s Physics. In fact, a study of the relevant texts reveals that Hugh of Novocastro first elaborated the doctrine by building on the Scotist doctrines of synchronic contingency and simultaneous causation. As these doctrines require at the same instant of time an order of priority and posteriority between possibility and actuality, cause and effect, so, Hugh says, there must be prior and posterior different states of affairs. Landolfo Caracciolo made this doctrine notorious outside the Franciscan convent by using it in his principia debates, directly engaging the circle of Cardinal Iacopo Stefaneschi. John Baconthorpe, the first to cite the Physics passage, did not have any noticeable effect on the development of the doctrine.
Keywords synchronic contingency   Landolfo Caracciolo   quasi-Aristotelianism   Hugh of Novocastro   creation   John Duns Scotus
Categories (categorize this paper)
DOI 10.1163/15685349-12341329
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Request removal from index
Revision history

Download options

PhilArchive copy

Upload a copy of this paper     Check publisher's policy     Papers currently archived: 62,513
Through your library

References found in this work BETA

Early Scotists at Paris: A Reconsideration.William Courtenay - 2011 - Franciscan Studies 69:175-229.
The Commentary on the Sentences by Landulphus Caracciolus, OFM.C. D. Schabel - 2009 - Bulletin de Philosophie Medievale 51:145-219.

Add more references

Citations of this work BETA

No citations found.

Add more citations

Similar books and articles

A "New Approach" To Nostratic Comparison.Eugene Helimski & Allen R. Bomhard - 1987 - Journal of the American Oriental Society 107 (1):97.
Quasi-O-Minimal Structures.Oleg Belegradek, Ya'acov Peterzil & Frank Wagner - 2000 - Journal of Symbolic Logic 65 (3):1115-1132.
Quasi-o-Minimal Structures.Oleg Belegradek, Ya'acov Peterzil & Frank Wagner - 2000 - Journal of Symbolic Logic 65 (3):1115-1132.
Ludwik Fleck on Proto-Ideas in Medicine.Stig Brorson - 2000 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 3 (2):147-152.
Quasi-Truth in Quasi-Set Theory.Otávio Bueno - 2000 - Synthese 125 (1-2):33-53.


Added to PP index

Total views
13 ( #742,134 of 2,446,457 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
2 ( #310,148 of 2,446,457 )

How can I increase my downloads?


My notes