Why a World State is Unavoidable in Planetary Defense: On Loopholes in the Vision of a Cosmopolitan Governance
In Nikola Schmidt (ed.), Planetary Defense: Global Collaboration for Defending Earth from Asteroids and Comet. Cham: pp. 375–399 (2019)
Abstract
The main claim of this chapter is that planetary defense against asteroids cannot be implemented under a decentralized model of democratic global governance, as espoused elsewhere in this book. All relevant indices point to the necessity of establishing a centralized global political authority with legitimate coercive powers. It remains to be seen, however, whether such a political system can be in any recognizable sense democratic. It seems unconvincing that planetary-wide physical-threat, all-comprehensive macrosecuritization, coupled with deep transformations of international law, global centralization of core decision-making powers, de-stigmatization of nuclear weapons and the like can proceed, succeed, and be implemented in a non-hierarchical international system where planetary defense constitutes only one regime among many, and where states basically remain the decisive actors. Although rationally and scientifically robust, the project suffers from oversimplification, as well as naivety with respect to how both international and domestic politics works. Among other topics, this chapter discusses problems associated with the rule of law and constituent powers, political representation and sources of legitimacy, conditions of multilevel collective action, or limits of theoretical idealization. The general message is that the planetary defense community needs to be more aware of the social and political context of its own enterprise.Author's Profile
My notes
Similar books and articles
Cosmopolitanism and Democracy: Global Governance without a Global State.Sharon Anderson-Gold - 2009 - Social Philosophy Today 25:209-222.
Cosmopolitanism and Democracy: Global Governance without a Global State.Sharon Anderson-Gold - 2009 - Social Philosophy Today 25:209-222.
Cosmopolitanism and Democracy: Global Governance without a Global State.Sharon Anderson-Gold - 2009 - Social Philosophy Today 25:209-222.
Democratizing Global ‘Bodies Politic’: Collective Agency, Political Legitimacy, and the Democratic Boundary Problem.Terry Macdonald - 2018 - Global Justice : Theory Practice Rhetoric 10 (2).
Democratizing Global ‘Bodies Politic’: Collective Agency, Political Legitimacy, and the Democratic Boundary Problem.Terry Macdonald - 2017 - Global Justice: Theory Practice Rhetoric 10 (2).
Ciudadanía sin límites: el trasfondo de la gobernanza global.Carmen Sarria - 2011 - Quaderns De Filosofia I Ciència 41:89-98.
Why strong moral cosmopolitanism requires a world-state.Pavel Dufek - 2013 - International Theory 5 (2):177–212.
Globalizing the democratic community.Jens Bartelson - 2008 - Ethics and Global Politics 1 (4):159-174.
Effective global governance without effective global government: A contemporary myth.James A. Yunker - 2004 - World Futures 60 (7):503 – 533.
Human rights and democracy in a global context: decoupling and recoupling.Samantha Besson - 2011 - Ethics and Global Politics 4 (1):19-50.
Global democratic theory: a critical introduction.Steven Slaughter - 2015 - Malden, MA: Polity Press.
Evaluating the Quality and Legitimacy of Global Governance: A Theoretical and Analytical Approach.Tim Cadman - 2012 - International Journal of Social Quality 2 (1):4-23.
Global Democratic Theory: A Critical Introduction.Daniel Bray & Steven Slaughter - 2015 - Malden, MA: Polity.
Analytics
Added to PP
2019-01-18
Downloads
416 (#26,882)
6 months
33 (#38,995)
2019-01-18
Downloads
416 (#26,882)
6 months
33 (#38,995)
Historical graph of downloads
Author's Profile
Citations of this work
References found in this work
A political constitution for the pluralist world society?Jürgen Habermas - 2007 - Journal of Chinese Philosophy 34 (3):331–343.
Identita v liberální politické teorii a dilema kosmopolitismu [Identity in Liberal Political Theory and the Cosmopolitan Dilemma].Sylvie Bláhová & Pavel Dufek - 2018 - Filosoficky Casopis 66 (3, 4):383–399, 505–517.
Elements of a theory of global governance.David Held - 2016 - Philosophy and Social Criticism 42 (9):837-846.