Cultural System or norm circles? An exchange [Book Review]
European Journal of Social Theory 15 (1):93-115 (2012)
AbstractThis article takes the form of a debate between the two authors on the social ontology of propositional culture. Archer applies the morphogenetic approach, analysing culture as a cycle of interaction between the Cultural System and Socio-Cultural Interaction. In this model, the Cultural System is comprised of the objective content of intelligibilia, as theorized by Karl Popper with his concept of objective World 3 knowledge. Elder-Vass agrees that culture works through an interplay between subjective belief and an external objective moment, but argues that the external moment cannot take the form of ‘objective knowledge’ as this is understood by Popper. Instead, the external moment of culture takes the form of normative pressures exerted by groups of people: norm circles. Ultimately both authors share a commitment to a similar critical realist ontological framework, while offering alternative accounts of the nature of culture within that framework.
Similar books and articles
Reply to Sealey and Carter on Realism and Language.Dave Elder-Vass - 2014 - Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 44 (3):282-287.
Cultural Wantons of the new Millennium.Margaret S. Archer - 2020 - Journal of Critical Realism 19 (4):314-328.
Cultural System vs. Pan‐cultural Dimensions: Philosophical Reflection on Approaches for Indigenous Psychology.Kwang-Kuo Hwang - 2015 - Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 45 (1):2-25.
The Causal Power of Discourse.Dave Elder-Vass - 2011 - Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 41 (2):143-160.
The Theory Of Social–Cultural Genetic Gene (S- c Dna).Jiayin Min - 2013 - World Futures 69 (2):89 - 101.
The Corporate Culture in Conditions of Modern Business Environment: Philosophical-Cultural Analysis.R. I. Mamina & S. I. Tsareva - 2017 - Дискурс 5:16-25.
Debate: Seven Ways to be A Realist About Language.Dave Elder-Vass - 2014 - Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 44 (3):249-267.
What is Progress in Realism? An Issue Illustrated Using Norm Circles.Jamie Morgan - 2014 - Journal of Critical Realism 13 (2):115-138.
Quality circles and human rights: tackling the universalism and cultural relativism divide. [REVIEW]Paresh Kathrani - 2012 - AI and Society 27 (3):369-375.
Culturological approach to the problem of consumption in the context of educational tasks.O. V. Kisyel - 2014 - Granì 11:58-63.
Culture and Evolutionary Explanations.Jean Lachapelle - 1999 - Dissertation, University of Guelph (Canada)
On Elder-Vass: Refining a refinement.Douglas Porpora - 2007 - Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 37 (2):195–200.
The Propositional vs. Hermeneutic Models of Cross-Cultural Understanding.Xinli Wang & Ling Xu - 2009 - South African Journal of Philosophy 28 (3):312-331.
Cultural Development and Information Science and Technology.Guan Shijie - 2003 - Contemporary Chinese Thought 35 (2):8-33.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Contributions to realist social theory: an interview with Margaret S. Archer.Margaret S. Archer & Jamie Morgan - 2020 - Journal of Critical Realism 19 (2):179-200.
American sociology, realism, structure and truth: an interview with Douglas V. Porpora.Douglas V. Porpora & Jamie Morgan - 2020 - Journal of Critical Realism 19 (5):522-544.
‘Materially social’ critical realism: an interview with Dave Elder-Vass.Dave Elder-Vass & Jamie Morgan - 2022 - Journal of Critical Realism 21 (2):211-246.
Critical realism, critical discourse analysis, and the morphogenetic approach.Jack Newman - 2020 - Journal of Critical Realism 19 (5):433-455.
The normative foundations of critical realism: a comment on Dave Elder-Vass and Leigh Price.Frédéric Vandenberghe - 2019 - Journal of Critical Realism 18 (3):319-336.
References found in this work
Objective Knowledge.K. R. Popper - 1972 - Journal for General Philosophy of Science / Zeitschrift für Allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie 4 (2):388-398.